Live data from Hacker News

GeForce Now: A Review

whatever.scalzi.com

11–20 of 198 posts

Re: GeForce Now: A Review

#11
post #6

My experience with GeForce Now is that despite having fiber internet and WiFi 6, games are still unplayably laggy. I also wasn't able to play Cities Skylines, because none of my Steam Workshop mods would install.

It's better if you have Ethernet, that way I get no stutter and the lag is almost unnoticeable (I get 9ms ping which is lower than the duration between 2 monitor refreshes at 60Hz)

Re: GeForce Now: A Review

#12
If I was 9 years old, again...

I, urgently, must play the latest AAA extravaganza, again...

...I've only $30 to my name, again. I'm collecting my family's supply of $2 coins, again.

I'd be all over it.

---------------------------------------------------------

Tons of software works REALLY well on Geforce now. Asynchronous, turn based games. XCOM: Enemy Unknown is one.

Server side rendering latency w/ monitor is a fascinating problem. I found the idea incredibly technically interesting.

NOT so much for me, an engineer who one click buys electronics.

I'm not the audience.

Re: GeForce Now: A Review

#13
post #6

My experience with GeForce Now is that despite having fiber internet and WiFi 6, games are still unplayably laggy. I also wasn't able to play Cities Skylines, because none of my Steam Workshop mods would install.

It's gotta be the wifi, you're probably dropping packets here and there.

Re: GeForce Now: A Review

#14
post #5

I tested out GeForce Now and Stadia two years ago and decided fairly quickly to build a desktop machine instead. Turns out that lots of PC games work really well on desktop Linux these days! The author discusses his internet connection, but for me even with a 500mbit connection and ~10ms ping to NYC area data centers I felt the video compression artifacts and periodic stutters were too noticeable. I also had some inp…

I came to the same conclusion really, it's a neat service but even using something like Parsec locally induces enough latency that I just can't use it.

I still run windows in a VFIO setup but Linux is really good for gaming these days. Was even playing Cyberpunk on the release day!

Re: GeForce Now: A Review

#15
I've found it to be a pretty good product, at least for my use case. I only have an hour or two/wk to play games these days, so it doesn't make a ton of sense to spend the time and $ to buy and install a new video card. So I got whatever the bottom paid tier is for GeForce Now and, while there are occasional lag-spikes and jitters, they're generally rare enough to only rise to the level of minor annoyance.

If I wanted to spend a lot of time playing games, especially multi-player ones, I don't think it would be a good substitute for using my own machine, but for being able to occasionally dip a toe into a game when I get the itch, its a pretty good deal.

Re: GeForce Now: A Review

#16
post #6

My experience with GeForce Now is that despite having fiber internet and WiFi 6, games are still unplayably laggy. I also wasn't able to play Cities Skylines, because none of my Steam Workshop mods would install.

It's better if you have Ethernet, that way I get no stutter and the lag is almost unnoticeable (I get 9ms ping which is lower than the duration between 2 monitor refreshes at 60Hz)

More anacedata: GeForce now over Ethernet is significantly better than Wi-Fi 6 in my apartment building.

Re: GeForce Now: A Review

#17
I've used it for about 14 months extensively - I wasn't able to upgrade my rig when cyberpunk 2077 came out. It was brilliant - I played the game at max settings, looked beautiful, not a care in The world. Then I used it too for some turn based / strategy / rpg games as I could play them on laptop, desktop etc, and it was easy to try games without bothering with downloading and local storage. It was sufficiently excellent experience that even once I got an upgraded gaming computer, I still kept the basic foundation paid package due to sheer convenience. It's just great to try and play games with low frequency without installation / configuration / troubleshooting hassle.

I have also found it consistently less glitchy over last year to stream a game from cloud to my media computers via geforce now, than from my next room gaming rig via steam link... Which speaks more bad things of steam link itself, but also I think at least some good things of geforce now.

Note that I have Ethernet for my laptop and desktop. I can not speak to latency via wireless - my assumption would be "frustrating" so I didn't even test.

Re: GeForce Now: A Review

#18
post #5

I tested out GeForce Now and Stadia two years ago and decided fairly quickly to build a desktop machine instead. Turns out that lots of PC games work really well on desktop Linux these days! The author discusses his internet connection, but for me even with a 500mbit connection and ~10ms ping to NYC area data centers I felt the video compression artifacts and periodic stutters were too noticeable. I also had some inp…

Even using Steam in-home streaming on the same network games look much worse because of compression.

Re: GeForce Now: A Review

#19
GFN is tested to be faster than native consoles in terms of input latency.

https://imgur.com/TzPnCLs

People are talking about turn based games but my experience is that it's flawless and indistinguishable from native in twitch games like fortnite and counterstrike. But then again I live on the East Coast pretty close to a datacenter and I'm on fiber, so obviously this won't be the case for people in rural areas. But for people who are in situations like mine, it's great.

Re: GeForce Now: A Review

#20
>> My rural internet connection is 40mbps/sec down in theory — in practice it’s between 25 and 40 depending which second you poll it, and the speed is affected by whether someone is downstairs watching Netflix while I’m upstairs playing a graphics-intensive game.

I'm surprised he even bothered trying the service let alone he found it playable. A rural area with 25-40mbps with someone using the internet at the same time ( let alone netflix!) is basically worst case scenario. If you are playing near a datacenter with reasonable internet your experience will be significantly better. Geforce now is technically very good when configured properly; it is similar to parsec (which is probably state of the art).

Worth pointing out: the Geforce now library is not great and and I wouldn't hold my breath on it improving too much. Most interested publishers have already signed up and the rest are either commited to other platforms or aren't willing to choose nvidia over other monetization options.

Post reply on HN