Live data from Hacker News

The Iceberg That Sank the Titanic

smithsonianmag.com

1–10 of 13 posts

Re: The Iceberg That Sank the Titanic

#3

The arrogant engineering and delusional captain that ensured that the Titanic sank

Agreed, though this comment feels a bit unecessary to the point of the article? Anyway, interesting is that these two points

"Towson knew that icebergs posed an existential danger to the wooden hulls of nineteenth‐century ships. Steel hulls were invincible, he said, but that was based on assumption, not experience"

"Only 1 percent of northern hemisphere icebergs survive this desert zone, and finally, only one in several thousand would make it to 41 degrees north, the same latitude as New York City and directly in the path of transatlantic ships."

even challenge this a bit?

Re: The Iceberg That Sank the Titanic

#4

The arrogant engineering and delusional captain that ensured that the Titanic sank

Agreed, though this comment feels a bit unecessary to the point of the article? Anyway, interesting is that these two points "Towson knew that icebergs posed an existential danger to the wooden hulls of nineteenth‐century ships. Steel hulls were invincible, he said, but that was based on assumption, not experience" "Only 1 percent of northern hemisphere icebergs survive this desert zone, and finally, only one in seve…

Just need 1 rock from the sky or 1 more stupid war like invasion of Taiwan will extinguish our home fire I guess.

Re: The Iceberg That Sank the Titanic

#6
post #5

Really amazing article to read. Love the focus on the ice itself. I had no idea that is was so close to not existing

It’s an excerpt from the author’s book:

https://www.danielstonebooks.com/

The Food Explorer was his first book?

https://www.amazon.com/Food-Explorer-Adventures-Globe-Trotti...

Re: The Iceberg That Sank the Titanic

#7
Wow.

It had been observed and tracked, which seems surprising at first, but of course the Victorians and Edwardians would do that, and I would expect that activity and sharing of information goes back much further. A history would be fascinating.

While it had not been named, by pointing that out the article implies that others were. I wonder what Edwardian conventions for naming icebergs were. Current ones are rather bland: https://www.antarcticreport.com/articles/the-us-national-ice...

Re: The Iceberg That Sank the Titanic

#8
"The ship rolled off a drydock in Northern Ireland in early 1912 and stopped to make pick-ups in Cherbourg, France, and Queenstown, Ireland, before turning west for New York."

Somehow the departure from Southampton got omitted so it looks like the Titanic didn't pick up any passengers from Britain.

Re: The Iceberg That Sank the Titanic

#9

The arrogant engineering and delusional captain that ensured that the Titanic sank

Agreed, though this comment feels a bit unecessary to the point of the article? Anyway, interesting is that these two points "Towson knew that icebergs posed an existential danger to the wooden hulls of nineteenth‐century ships. Steel hulls were invincible, he said, but that was based on assumption, not experience" "Only 1 percent of northern hemisphere icebergs survive this desert zone, and finally, only one in seve…

They would have made a good pair on Wall Street with all their supposed “knowledge” of statistics.

Re: The Iceberg That Sank the Titanic

#10

"The ship rolled off a drydock in Northern Ireland in early 1912 and stopped to make pick-ups in Cherbourg, France, and Queenstown, Ireland, before turning west for New York." Somehow the departure from Southampton got omitted so it looks like the Titanic didn't pick up any passengers from Britain.

  She stands along
  Southampton Dock
  with her handkerchief 
  And her summer frock
  That clings to her wet body in the rain
Post reply on HN