Live data from Hacker News

Metal Archives 20th Anniversary

metal-archives.com

21–30 of 65 posts

Re: Metal Archives 20th Anniversary

#21
post #11
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There may not be. There seems to be something obsessive about metal fans to catalog and classify and document. I mean, look at the wiki page on subgenres: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heavy_metal_genres It fills me with awe and giggles.

I wouldn't take that list too seriously. Metal-archives genres tend to not delve into "styles" as much. But there are certainly many distinct sub-genres and one can't exactly argue that Black Sabbath, Dimmu Borgir and Cannibal Corpse sound similar. I agree that the community itself takes the genre thing way too far and it often ends up being pretty funny. Then again, electronic music probably gives metal a run for it…

I agree that the community itself takes the genre thing way too far and it often ends up being pretty funny.

Some people are in on the joke and some are serious. Sometimes, it's hard to tell the difference, but that's OK, because I like talking with both types of people. It's usually informative and/or entertaining. :)

Re: Metal Archives 20th Anniversary

#24

Ah, yes. The site that has a thousand reasons why the band you're looking for isn't "metal" enough to be in its database, but then has an entry for Rush: https://www.metal-archives.com/bands/Rush/1206

It's a little puzzling that Blue Oÿster Cult isn't there. There's a historical case for them and the post-1980's records have recognizable modern metal.

Re: Metal Archives 20th Anniversary

#26

Argh! No Pirate Metal category? They categorize them generically as Folk Metal but have a separate Viking Metal category.

Pirate metal is probably seen as "ironic," or maybe just too niche to deserve a top level genre (how many bands besides Alestorm are there?). Viking metal has a long history, though, given the Nordic roots of many extreme metal genres.

That being said, I don't think Viking Metal is too helpful of a genre anyway given the completely different sound of, say, Ensiferum vs Borknagar, or Tyr vs Windir.

Re: Metal Archives 20th Anniversary

#27

And for the 20th anniversary it sounds like the project could use some better architecture to protect against a DDoS despite using Cloudflare. I'll be sure to donate somehow given it's been a big part of my life and I've sadly probably used it more than Wikipedia in my life.

No post body was provided.

Re: Metal Archives 20th Anniversary

#28
!mab or !metal for DDG and Kagi, in case someone is interested ;)

I often use them to find out if some band I found in the depth of my hard disk still exists, or to help decide what genre to sort some band in.

Re: Metal Archives 20th Anniversary

#30
post #2

If there is anything like the Metal Archives for electronic music or rock music (actually any genre) out there, I'd like to know about it. It's simply the greatest music encyclopedia I've come across, albeit entirely focused on metal. As much as I appreciate Discogs and RateYourMusic, they tackle different things and don't really function as encyclopedias, the former functioning more as a catalogue and the latter as…

It’s not totally an archive per se but I discovered this site for electronic music when it was originally a Flash application: https://music.ishkur.com/
Post reply on HN