Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What are some unpopular opinions here that should not be?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 70 posts

Re: Ask HN: What are some unpopular opinions here that should not be?

#21
post #8

Fighting a proxy war with Russia is better than fighting a hot war with either Russia or China. But, the people doing the proxy fighting are really unhappy being used this way.

People of Ukraine are not being used. They want to fight the invaders and are thankful that some Western nations are helping them. That the same western nations benefit from this is not the cause of their fighting. That cause is Russia.

Re: Ask HN: What are some unpopular opinions here that should not be?

#22

A strangely misplaced whiff of anti-intellectualism seems present and growing within tech/hacker circles (?)

String theory is a hoax because "there's no experimental evidence". How about we build bigger and better experiments? No, colliders are just hand outs to the industry and a waste of money /s

It's more than a whiff, it's a disgusting stench.

Re: Ask HN: What are some unpopular opinions here that should not be?

#24
post #8

Fighting a proxy war with Russia is better than fighting a hot war with either Russia or China. But, the people doing the proxy fighting are really unhappy being used this way.

People of Ukraine are not being used. They want to fight the invaders and are thankful that some Western nations are helping them. That the same western nations benefit from this is not the cause of their fighting. That cause is Russia.

The context here is Syria, Lebanon, Yemen, a range of hotspots in the middle east aside from the war with Ukraine, not to mention Afghanistan, and all the places in Africa where the Wagner group are at play. Arming Ukraine was the least thing they could do but also the most. I totally do not mean to invalidate your war.

Re: Ask HN: What are some unpopular opinions here that should not be?

#25
post #4

The free market sell off mania needs to end, real soon. We need big government far more than we are prepared to appreciate.

>The free market sell off mania needs to end, real soon. We need big government far more than we are prepared to appreciate.

Translation: I'm not prepared for what is coming.

Re: Ask HN: What are some unpopular opinions here that should not be?

#26
post #7

Free speech is overrated, and very misunderstood.

>Free speech is overrated, and very misunderstood. Maybe your free speech is overrated. But as for the rest of us, it is not.

Hmm. Well the OP did say "unpopular" -But, "rest of us" suggests you think I'm in a camp of 1. I assure you a lot of people worldwide accept constraint on their freedom of speech, for social gain. Would I want to have my social credit measured by an app? Nope. Not even close. But, asked about it, most shrug.

Plus, the misunderstood bit. I mean I get you know this, but do you think people actually know their 1st amendment rights? Like, its about specific things, not all things, and no, you (nor Trump) do not have an axiomatic right to say anything you like on Twitter, because "freedom of speech" (hint: Twitter is not a commons, or public space, or bound by laws in Congress)

Do you think "free speech" is going to save the defendents in the Dominion Voting case, Specifically Fox? Remember, the fine point here is "misunderstood" not "is important" -I think the libel laws may save Fox, but it won't be Free speech, it will be Libel laws. I kind of hope they lose because even if $1b is an over estimate, they trashed a corporate entity for political gain, by lying. Thats really bad. They could do it tomorrow to anyone else. Thats bully pulpit bad.

Re: Ask HN: What are some unpopular opinions here that should not be?

#30
post #27

Linux really is a good general purpose desktop OS.

Setting aside privacy or software freedom idealism, why would someone use it over Windows or macOS?

Software development, particularly for large-scale computing environments.
Post reply on HN