Live data from Hacker News

A meteor or alien tech: Harvard professor plans UFO expedition

nbcboston.com

141–150 of 204 posts

Re: A meteor or alien tech: Harvard professor plans UFO expedition

#141
post #22

Can the title be revised to something like "Harvard Professor on Quest for Possible Alien Tech that Crashed in the Pacific Ocean"? Current phrasing makes it seem like the professor crashed into the ocean.

The whole article seems weirdly worded. I the idea about using a magnetic just seems ridiculous. Maybe I am missing something...

It sounds more like a coded message for someone then it does a real article, but maybe I have been watching to many science-fiction movies lately..

Re: A meteor or alien tech: Harvard professor plans UFO expedition

#143

> "We’re planning to board the ship and build a sled and a magnet attached to it that will scoop the ocean floor. And we will go back and forth, like mowing the lawns across the region, 10 kilometers in size and collect with the magnets, all the fragments that are attracted to it, and then brush them off and study their composition in the laboratory." Wouldn't this only work for iron fragments of a meteor? If the the…

He might find "polymetallic nodules". Supposedly there are large fields of them on the ocean floor.

Re: A meteor or alien tech: Harvard professor plans UFO expedition

#144
post #64

I think I've seen this movie before; just don't let anybody touch the strange Sphere thing and you should be alright. Seriously though, this doesn't make much sense to me. Finding shipwrecks even when you know they exist and what general area they should be in is hard enough. This sort of search is a huge money sink, the ships, towed sonars, etc all cost a ton of money to operate.

$1.5M ain’t much depending on your priors and how much you value the discovery of extraterrestrial tech.

Let’s estimate the expected value for that $1.5M…

My estimate is something less than $0.01.

Re: A meteor or alien tech: Harvard professor plans UFO expedition

#145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

All other metals are less magnetic than iron.

Niobium?

Niobium on its own isn't even ferromagnetic, it's paramagnetic, and not very strong. However, it can be alloyed with other metals including iron and nickel to produce a stronger magnet than any pure element.

Re: A meteor or alien tech: Harvard professor plans UFO expedition

#146
post #22

Can the title be revised to something like "Harvard Professor on Quest for Possible Alien Tech that Crashed in the Pacific Ocean"? Current phrasing makes it seem like the professor crashed into the ocean.

As I always look at the comments first, I've got confused with no information about if he died or not. Had to click the link.

Re: A meteor or alien tech: Harvard professor plans UFO expedition

#147
UFO nuts are probably already making memes like, "See, even Harvard believes in E.T." Just like they did about the gov't report that said "of course there are unidentified objects in our skies."

But, unlike their favorite Facebook group's grainy phone videos, this sounds fairly real. Drag the thing up and put it under a spectrograph, and if we haven't seen the stuff in it before, figure out what that means.

Re: A meteor or alien tech: Harvard professor plans UFO expedition

#148

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The actual article's title was "Harvard Professor Believes Alien Tech Could Have Crashed Into Pacific Ocean" which is more clear. Although to make it less woo-woo flying saucer-ish, I might have said: "Harvard Professor Believes Meteor That Crashed Into Ocean Was Alien Metal"

If it was real alien tech it could be anywhere doing anything by now. If we're not going to just assume aliens 'non-terrestrial' might be more accurate.

Right. I was just correcting the grammar, not his (wild) assumptions.

Re: A meteor or alien tech: Harvard professor plans UFO expedition

#149
post #58
post #11

To not bury the lead: His team studied data the government made available from military missile tracking systems, which conveniently also false-positives on asteroids. There was one in 2014 which slammed into the Pacific Ocean at a speed at least twice that of the speed stars around us move relative to the sun, which makes it likely to be extra-solar. Based on that speed & how much burned upon entry, they concluded i…

I can imagine their disappointment if all they recover would be a few tons of platinum, iridium and such. /s

Or just a chunk of titanium. It's only made in novas and supernovas so having an abnormal trajectory, and speed only supports the theory. A bunch of titanium slapped onto some rock and then later breaks off or something.

Re: A meteor or alien tech: Harvard professor plans UFO expedition

#150

So the only thing that has been confirmed is that it is a meteorite from outside of the solar system. Jumping to the conclusion that it is "possible alien tech" seems a liiiittle bit of a stretch.

Even the first part is not confirmed.

Technically, a 99.999% likelihood is not confirmed, but it's good enough for the girls I go out with.
Post reply on HN