Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Google Search down?

news.ycombinator.com

231–240 of 286 posts

Re: Ask HN: Google Search down?

#231
post #69

Down in Sydney. Intermittent errors when searching. How am I supposed to work? Also, I don't remember when Google Search was last down. Either google has great uptime, or I have terrible memory.

> How am I supposed to work?

Whatever happened to the man pages, y'know.

Re: Ask HN: Google Search down?

#232
post #111

https://www.cnn.com/2009/TECH/06/26/michael.jackson.internet... This reminds me of the distant past. The death of Michael Jackson resulted in ( almost literally) the entire internet suffering an outage.

More than that on 9/11. Every news site, online forum any online resource for news you can think of was unaccessible for hours. TV turned out to be the only news source.

I was working at an ISP on 9/11. We were still online but none of our customers were getting anything (dialup modems) ... so people started calling our tech support number to read them the news. Or to get info about loved ones. That was a long day. I left a different person than I showed up as. Didn't we all though.

Re: Ask HN: Google Search down?

#233

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Bing works pretty well most of the time. I switched my personal primary search engine to bing around the beginning of this year after noticing a marked degradation of Google search quality. In fact, anecdotally, Bing is markedly better at narrow search results (quoted phrases, excluding or including specific words, etc). Google on the other hand is significantly better at what I’d call fuzzy searches, where you don’t…

I feel like I need to read the manual for specific Google searches. Sometimes, it seems to drop an important search term and not give a suggestion link to include it. +term doesn’t help sometimes. It seems like +”term” usually does. It seems overfitted to delivering results with mass appeal. Perhaps I’ll try bing the next time I get that tingling feeling google will throw out the search terms intended to narrow down…

My guess is, storing the whole index is expensive.

So they just look at popular (or profitable) queries.

Re: Ask HN: Google Search down?

#234
Good time to switch to a search engine that has code snippets, coding tutorials, AI code completion, AI blog writing, a useful yelp app, great privacy, gives control over the sources and apps I want to see and summarizes pros/cons for products.

you.com

(founder here :)

Re: Ask HN: Google Search down?

#235
post #140

https://www.sfgate.com/news/article/google-electrical-incide... Three people in critical condition after Google data center 'electrical incident' in the Council Bluffs, Iowa datacenter (us-central region, I believe)

not at all relevant to this outage

Re: Ask HN: Google Search down?

#236

Good time to switch to a search engine that has code snippets, coding tutorials, AI code completion, AI blog writing, a useful yelp app, great privacy, gives control over the sources and apps I want to see and summarizes pros/cons for products. you.com (founder here :)

[deleted]

Re: Ask HN: Google Search down?

#238
post #111

https://www.cnn.com/2009/TECH/06/26/michael.jackson.internet... This reminds me of the distant past. The death of Michael Jackson resulted in ( almost literally) the entire internet suffering an outage.

More than that on 9/11. Every news site, online forum any online resource for news you can think of was unaccessible for hours. TV turned out to be the only news source.

I seem to remember Slashdot holding up.

Re: Ask HN: Google Search down?

#239

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Seems unrelated. This happened ~10 hours ago.

10 hours ago we had a flood of network failures in us-central1 and saw no GCP status changes. We blindly attempted to mitigate in various ways (freezing HPAs because we thought that we were making excessive calls to external infra and getting throttled) and it resolved itself eventually. Maybe we were at fault the entire time but not seeing this issue exposed up on the GCP dashboard is infuriating.

At AWS, if the status changes then someone somewhere gets fired, so a lot of time incidents happen without being recorded on the status board. Maybe it’s the same issue with GCP, or maybe concern for their injured peers made everyone forget to update the status. I really hope the later.

Re: Ask HN: Google Search down?

#240

Google clearly saw my search engine's week-long outage as I reconstructed the index and felt confused and intimidated by the revelation that 89.9999% also is five nines.

Everybody wants nine nines, but you achieved eight eights, which is pretty close? :)
Post reply on HN