Live data from Hacker News

Fake IMDB credits

peabee.substack.com

171–180 of 260 posts

Re: Fake IMDB credits

#171
When I discuss these type of things or phone scams with my Americanized Indian friends, their response is always the same and scary:

"They don't think they are scamming, they think Americans are rich and they just get their share. Otherwise they will suffer and find no food to eat."

Re: Fake IMDB credits

#172
post #122

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I mean hot take, but the whole “United Kingdom” concept is sort of pointless. Either confirm to international norms, or accept that no one outside your borders cares. There’s a reason why the only major organization that respects the distinction is the governing body of the national sport.

Not being from the UK: It's not really pointless. Scotland is way different from England, and I haven't been to Wales but I think that is, too. As for Northern Ireland: I don't even need to cover that one.

I think the parent comment meant that, in this case, make them actual countries.

Re: Fake IMDB credits

#173

I'm a Swiss working in Bangkok (I'm fluent in Thai). So I'm quite a bit acustomed to people cheating in many situations of life. When we started hiring a couple of Indian coworkers for management level as well as data science roles, I became close friends to the whole group. Whenever we discussed frauds like that, I always said that we shouldn't think people (or Indians in particular) wanna game the systems and not e…

At business school one of my living group was an exec at a prominent indian Telco. He described how, when the quarterly revenue was short, they would enable paid features on random customer accounts (at huge scale). This predates smart phones and only a small fraction noticed, complained and got a refund. He mentioned it casually and was a surprised we collectively recommended he quit that company, change that practice, or quit telling people.

Re: Fake IMDB credits

#174

Is the Apu trilogy good for real?

If you wanna go by metrics, all movies in the trilogy are rated above 4.0 with more than 50,000 votes combined on letterboxd. Also they got beautiful remasters from criterion films.

Re: Fake IMDB credits

#175
BTW since India makes a great many of medications and supplements for the USA and the world, and those factories are never inspected or products tested, do you think this "cheating" / "hacking" attitude doesn't spill over into each and every industry?

Webpage is one thing, how about things you consume?

Re: Fake IMDB credits

#176
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would love to have a way to punish people for submitting knownlingly bad information to publicly editable databases like IMDB (note I don't care about Google, it is IMDB that should be protected) Jail is too much, but it woukd be nice to have a fine of some sort, because "poisining the well" for everyone is really not cool. (in practice any such system would be abused a lot, so we are probably better off with statu…

Right. We can achieve heaven if we just punish every sin. Not trusting almighty Google's algorithm is just too much sacrifice the good people are making. Promoting publicly editable database as authoritative is high bar we must achieve at the cost of just banning juvenile behavior.

No, "we can reduce reduce bad behavior if we punish for it". This stuff actually works -- if we don't punishing bad behavior, we get more and more of it over time (which is kinda what happened with internet)

I am not sure why you keep bringing up Google here -- no one cares about it, it is megacorp and it can take care of itself. We want to protect entities like IMDB and Wikipedia. It does not matter why it was vandalized (and that's what happened here) -- to fool Google, or to impress friends, or to get to backstage -- it was bad, and it should not be encouraged.

And finally, learning that actions have responsibilities is an important part of the growing up. I certainly got some parking tickets when I was younger and it taught me an important lesson. (Of course the punishment should not be excessive, nothing that stays on your record for the whole life).

Re: Fake IMDB credits

#178
post #175

BTW since India makes a great many of medications and supplements for the USA and the world, and those factories are never inspected or products tested, do you think this "cheating" / "hacking" attitude doesn't spill over into each and every industry? Webpage is one thing, how about things you consume?

What is the basis of your statement that the factories are never inspected or the products are tested?

I interned at a pharmaceutical company's factory in India for the summer that used to regularly export medications to it's subsidiaries in the western world including United States. The standards are super high, we literally threw away millions of medications due to small uncertainty in a Quality control check.

Besides the local regulations and inspections, a team from FDA regularly visited the factory to audit it for like 10-15 days. Just for one factory. I distinctly remember this as we had a more americanized menu for lunch when the team visited LMAO.

So yeah, when you don't know or are not sure, please don't make statements like "factories are never inspected". It makes it seem like you know something, which you clearly don't.

Re: Fake IMDB credits

#179
post #164

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wikipedia allows anyone to audit edits and raise issues if things are fishy. IMDb allows edits but the history is only visible to admins.

Me and my gang of companion editors, who have a long edit history going many years back (100% deleting content) shall revert your audits and reject your issues. There are 10 of us! You have no further questions. If you continue being disruptive you will be banned.

I don't know if this is tongue-in-cheek, but it is very accurate.

Re: Fake IMDB credits

#180

I'm a Swiss working in Bangkok (I'm fluent in Thai). So I'm quite a bit acustomed to people cheating in many situations of life. When we started hiring a couple of Indian coworkers for management level as well as data science roles, I became close friends to the whole group. Whenever we discussed frauds like that, I always said that we shouldn't think people (or Indians in particular) wanna game the systems and not e…

No post body was provided.
Post reply on HN