Live data from Hacker News

Lightyear One

lightyear.one

11–20 of 55 posts

Re: Lightyear One

#11

Has no one done the math on this? Isn't it clearly a horrible idea, based on how much energy is available from the sun over a few square meters if car, versus the amount of energy cars use? I guess if you live in the desert, and every week you park your car for 6 days and drive 1 day.

It's for sure a Nikola Motors situation.

As long as you're going down hill the range is infinite!

Re: Lightyear One

#12
Maybe this is a good idea and maybe it isn’t.

But few people will want to drop XX,000 for a car that they have to leave outside all the time.

Speaking as a person who parks his 2007 Camry under a tree every day.

Re: Lightyear One

#14

Has no one done the math on this? Isn't it clearly a horrible idea, based on how much energy is available from the sun over a few square meters if car, versus the amount of energy cars use? I guess if you live in the desert, and every week you park your car for 6 days and drive 1 day.

Depending on the specific use case, it may not be terrible.

I drive a Nissan Leaf. It gets 5.5 mi per kWh in the summer, 4.8 in the winter. My commute is about 7 miles 1-way. So less than 3kWh used daily assuming I just commute.

They have a 1kW solar panel on their car. If I had a car with the efficiency of my Leaf that charged from a 1kW panel every day, it's conceivable that for my specific use case I would rarely ever charge.

That said I don't think my case is typical and I am not a large enough market segment to cater to. Nor would I ever trade my dirt-cheap Leaf for whatever exorbitant price these things will cost.

Re: Lightyear One

#16
post #2

I keenly await the Thunderf00t debunking video. There is no way a roof solar panel would enable you to "drive for months".

> There is no way a roof solar panel would enable you to "drive for months".

FYI: Solar-powered race cars can go 88km/h: https://newsroom.unsw.edu.au/news/science-technology/world%C...

Having said that, if you throw in the required safety features and basic creature comforts of a modern car that's going to add a lot of weight but I wouldn't be surprised if such a purely solar-powered car could reach ~30MPH (with a 0-30 time of like 30 seconds =)

With the right balance of batteries-to-weight I wouldn't be surprised if you only needed to charge the car for like 8 hours to get 100 miles of range at highway driving speeds (on a sunny day with solar assist). The 1000-mile range is probably only possible if you're doing like 30MPH with the wind at your back with the sun beating down the entire time.

Re: Lightyear One

#17
A car that passively recharges using solar is always superior to one that doesn't. I don't care if it only charges 5 miles per day. Just the fact that if you're stranded just a few miles from help, or to stave off charge losses when parked for a long time, or to power connected car features when it's off without draining drive battery, all make this make sense, and every EV should have at least a consideration for a solar panel on the hood and roof if not a glass roof.

Re: Lightyear One

#18
Lol - get real. $255k? It's not particularly "cool" looking so unless they fix the styling, I can't see people dropping $255k for a solar car.

Re: Lightyear One

#19

Has no one done the math on this? Isn't it clearly a horrible idea, based on how much energy is available from the sun over a few square meters if car, versus the amount of energy cars use? I guess if you live in the desert, and every week you park your car for 6 days and drive 1 day.

Depending on the specific use case, it may not be terrible. I drive a Nissan Leaf. It gets 5.5 mi per kWh in the summer, 4.8 in the winter. My commute is about 7 miles 1-way. So less than 3kWh used daily assuming I just commute. They have a 1kW solar panel on their car. If I had a car with the efficiency of my Leaf that charged from a 1kW panel every day, it's conceivable that for my specific use case I would rarely…

Wouldn’t it add weight though? It seems like if the car is parked next to a solar panel and drives away without it then it’s a lot more efficient.
Post reply on HN