Live data from Hacker News

Making a Maradona: Meat Consumption and Soccer Prowess

ideas.repec.org

51–56 of 56 posts

Re: Making a Maradona: Meat Consumption and Soccer Prowess

#51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

probably wasnt vegan during his formative years.

also took hgh bc of his growth hormone disorder

Some seriously desperate denialism here. There's absolutely no evidence that a reasonable vegan diet is inferior to a meat eating diet, in fact quiet the opposite.

Re: Making a Maradona: Meat Consumption and Soccer Prowess

#52
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, that's probably why the gladiators were basically vegetarians. ;) https://www.bbc.com/news/education-29723384

Correction twenty out of twenty-two gladiators that died in one particular place ate mostly but not exclusively plants. Two other did not follow said died because they didn't come from the same area. That's a drastically different conclusion

How do we know they didn't follow the diet because they didn't come from the same area?

Maybe they were special otherwise? Super stars? I.e. this may well be coincidence. At a sample size of two any conclusion is a tad hard to support.

There is overwhelming evidence for meat being consumed rarely in most western cultures until very recently. Excavations of food pits mostly.[1]

The link I posted is just one example.

[1] My brother is an archeologist. I take his word for this.

Re: Making a Maradona: Meat Consumption and Soccer Prowess

#53
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Correction twenty out of twenty-two gladiators that died in one particular place ate mostly but not exclusively plants. Two other did not follow said died because they didn't come from the same area. That's a drastically different conclusion

How do we know they didn't follow the diet because they didn't come from the same area? Maybe they were special otherwise? Super stars? I.e. this may well be coincidence. At a sample size of two any conclusion is a tad hard to support. There is overwhelming evidence for meat being consumed rarely in most western cultures until very recently. Excavations of food pits mostly.[1] The link I posted is just one example. […

Well I hope that his evidence is stronger than your overstatement of the link you posted.

Re: Making a Maradona: Meat Consumption and Soccer Prowess

#54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

also took hgh bc of his growth hormone disorder

Some seriously desperate denialism here. There's absolutely no evidence that a reasonable vegan diet is inferior to a meat eating diet, in fact quiet the opposite.

For growing children athletes where strength and speed are important?

Re: Making a Maradona: Meat Consumption and Soccer Prowess

#55
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Brazil are good at soccer simply because they are the biggest country where soccer is the main sport so it will be hard to control for that trying to find other reasons. It will be more interesting to look at small countries with relative success like Uruguay or Holland.

Population is something that as a Scot mystifies me. We have a population similar to Croatia, yet they’ve been an incredible force in international football while we have languished in mediocrity, missing out on most major tournaments in the last 30 years. At a club level there’s no contest - our domestic leagues are usually ranked higher in the UEFA coefficient than Croatia’s and traditionally we’ve had greater succ…

No post body was provided.

Re: Making a Maradona: Meat Consumption and Soccer Prowess

#56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some seriously desperate denialism here. There's absolutely no evidence that a reasonable vegan diet is inferior to a meat eating diet, in fact quiet the opposite.

For growing children athletes where strength and speed are important?

Once again, there is no evidence that a balanced vegan diet is inferior at any stage of growth or age.
Post reply on HN