Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Has the quality of Google search declined for anyone else, or just me?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 106 posts

Re: Ask HN: Has the quality of Google search declined for anyone else, or just me?

#31

Impossible to use. I’ve started adding “ Reddit” to my searches but even now that’s not working as well as it did.

You have to use "site:reddit.com" which selects that specific domain, otherwise you get any page that contains the word reddit, and spammers are certainly catching on to that trick.

Re: Ask HN: Has the quality of Google search declined for anyone else, or just me?

#32
If you want high quality materials, you need a University library or a journal, whitepapers or an academic textbook. Or if you want practical information and experience, you need to be an employee or apprentice or business owner.

The web is the lowest common denominator. The high quality information is elsewhere and Google isn't allowed to reveal it due to rights holders, such as Google Scholar and Google Books.

I tend to spend my time on Infinity Family https://o2oo.li and https://halfbakery.com a community of inventors and creators. We have an ontology to solve the world's problems and work towards goals and projects as a community. We relax and share opinionated perspectives to problems in the world.

Re: Ask HN: Has the quality of Google search declined for anyone else, or just me?

#33

Impossible to use. I’ve started adding “ Reddit” to my searches but even now that’s not working as well as it did.

You have to use "site:reddit.com" which selects that specific domain, otherwise you get any page that contains the word reddit, and spammers are certainly catching on to that trick.

Thanks I will start using that. Appreciate the tip.

Re: Ask HN: Has the quality of Google search declined for anyone else, or just me?

#35
post #16

With all the Googlers here and this question being asked again and again including by myself I wonder if this feedback has already reached the right folks at google but there just isn't much that could be done given the business incentives at play.

Honestly I don’t think anyone at Google or Facebook really cares that much. They are old companies, the big money has been made, and it’s pretty much impossible to launch a new successful product. Everything big has been acquisitions for a decade. If you climb up to executive level it’s just twiddling thumbs until the cash cow starts to die, then you ride off into the sunset because nothing is going to replace the cash cow.

And then the products - does anyone wake up every day feeling super excited to help push ads and shrill partisan hacks to boomers? It’s like to work there you just accept “this is how it is and I like money” and you punch a card and leave. It must be a miserable existence for anyone who truly ponders it.

Re: Ask HN: Has the quality of Google search declined for anyone else, or just me?

#37

There’s been some debate about this here on HN and someone made a point that resonated with me: The quality of _the web_ has been in decline lately. With ML’s capacity to paraphrase original content and to generate plausible rubbish content from scratch, it’s very difficult for Google’s pagerank (or whatever they call their algo these days) to fight back. That been said, there does seem to be a fair bit of scraping a…

Also the quality of hyperlinks has declined precipitously. Google's big insight was that what people say about a page matters more than what the page says itself. Hyperlinks were fundamental to the (pre-2013) ranking algorithm, in ways that were far more fundamental than just pagerank. This worked really well when people authored HTML pages by hand (or in FrontPage or DreamWeaver) and would promiscuously link out whe…

As well as the fact fewer ppl are maintaining their own websites or blog. The content is now in places that cant be crawled as easily like Instagram, Tiktok and Twitter as well as FB groups.

Re: Ask HN: Has the quality of Google search declined for anyone else, or just me?

#38
post #35
post #16

With all the Googlers here and this question being asked again and again including by myself I wonder if this feedback has already reached the right folks at google but there just isn't much that could be done given the business incentives at play.

Honestly I don’t think anyone at Google or Facebook really cares that much. They are old companies, the big money has been made, and it’s pretty much impossible to launch a new successful product. Everything big has been acquisitions for a decade. If you climb up to executive level it’s just twiddling thumbs until the cash cow starts to die, then you ride off into the sunset because nothing is going to replace the ca…

I dont know about miserable. The money, benefits and work/life balance can be very good. And while the work is uninteresting, its probably a lot more tolerable than working elsewhere.

Re: Ask HN: Has the quality of Google search declined for anyone else, or just me?

#39
No, Google search remains awesome for me. I’d switch if there was something that gave better results, but that doesn’t exist for me. I gave DDG a fair shake (about 3 months) and it was horrid.

I’m also not concerned with privacy/whatever so I won’t switch to something equally as good or worse to make a statement.

Re: Ask HN: Has the quality of Google search declined for anyone else, or just me?

#40
I suspect, but can’t prove that the entire internet is rotting. I get the feeling that organic user contributions are plummeting and being swamped by bots. HN is a small life raft. Many of the niche subreddits I’ve been following for years are seeing their post frequency drop, from dozens a days to a few a week. All the other forums are gone. Maybe there’s something going on in the apps, but they aren’t searchable. The internet is becoming a cold dead place. There’s not much for Google to find these days.

Case in point: I was just trying to find some information about TGV rail routes. Standard Google searched yielded nothing but spam. Appending “Reddit” game me posts more than 5 years old with out of date information.

Post reply on HN