Live data from Hacker News

Google’s Chief Works to Trim a Bloated Ship

nytimes.com

21–30 of 36 posts

Re: Google’s Chief Works to Trim a Bloated Ship

#21

This is off-topic and doesn't address the actual content of the article, but... "Trim a Bloated Ship"? That metaphor could use some work. How does a ship bloat? And wouldn't a bloated ship float pretty well? If you use the common meaning of trim (honestly, how many mariners read the NYT?), isn't cutting bits off a ship a bad thing? I guess it could be worse. I'll give thanks that Thomas Friedman didn't write it.

See also:'trimming sails' as it relates to sailboats.

Re: Google’s Chief Works to Trim a Bloated Ship

#22

This is off-topic and doesn't address the actual content of the article, but... "Trim a Bloated Ship"? That metaphor could use some work. How does a ship bloat? And wouldn't a bloated ship float pretty well? If you use the common meaning of trim (honestly, how many mariners read the NYT?), isn't cutting bits off a ship a bad thing? I guess it could be worse. I'll give thanks that Thomas Friedman didn't write it.

At least one. Trimming is also the term we use when adjusting the ballast or cargo so the ship floats differently in the water. Never heard of a bloated ship before.

Re: Google’s Chief Works to Trim a Bloated Ship

#23
post #8

The risky part is driving people away from Google products and services via uncertainty. Is now the time to put all your eggs into the Google Voice basket? Buy a bunch of Chrome PCs? I understand why they have to do it but it will definitely cause some people to adopt more of a wait-and-see approach.

The only way to get real focus in a company is to kill projects. It's not pretty and it pisses the people off who were working on those projects. But it is absolutely necessary to get focused and start making a few great things instead of lots of OK things.

Re: Google’s Chief Works to Trim a Bloated Ship

#24

This is off-topic and doesn't address the actual content of the article, but... "Trim a Bloated Ship"? That metaphor could use some work. How does a ship bloat? And wouldn't a bloated ship float pretty well? If you use the common meaning of trim (honestly, how many mariners read the NYT?), isn't cutting bits off a ship a bad thing? I guess it could be worse. I'll give thanks that Thomas Friedman didn't write it.

He is certainly shaving the google watermelon, thats for sure!

Re: Google’s Chief Works to Trim a Bloated Ship

#25

This is off-topic and doesn't address the actual content of the article, but... "Trim a Bloated Ship"? That metaphor could use some work. How does a ship bloat? And wouldn't a bloated ship float pretty well? If you use the common meaning of trim (honestly, how many mariners read the NYT?), isn't cutting bits off a ship a bad thing? I guess it could be worse. I'll give thanks that Thomas Friedman didn't write it.

mixing metaphors isn't the end of the world. "bloated" is used metaphorically so often only the "ship" part strikes me as non-literal.

Re: Google’s Chief Works to Trim a Bloated Ship

#26

This is off-topic and doesn't address the actual content of the article, but... "Trim a Bloated Ship"? That metaphor could use some work. How does a ship bloat? And wouldn't a bloated ship float pretty well? If you use the common meaning of trim (honestly, how many mariners read the NYT?), isn't cutting bits off a ship a bad thing? I guess it could be worse. I'll give thanks that Thomas Friedman didn't write it.

It means it has too much pork. They should trim the fat so they don't have as much red tape. Once they're on track, it'll be full steam ahead and smooth sailing.

Re: Google’s Chief Works to Trim a Bloated Ship

#27

Reading this article while I'm reading Stephen Levy's "In the Plex" is interesting. Stephen argues this is all part of Google's nature and that Page and Brin are convinced the "montisorian way" will figure it out one day... I think he's right in many ways, Google definately doesn't work anything like Apple does, it'll just be interesting how Google comes out the "midlife crisis"

Excellent point - if Page had a certain amount of power when a triumvirate ruled Google, what has really changed now that he is the sole CEO? Does he suddenly have immense influence now where he had none before?

It sounds just like a nice PR push really.

Re: Google’s Chief Works to Trim a Bloated Ship

#28
This could mean a lot of potential opportunity for start-ups. If Google is shedding products because they don't fit with their core mission or business requirements, those might be some great areas to get into for different/smaller companies.

In the end, they will probably focus on general purpose products with super large user bases (docs, maps, email, android, social network, offers, payments etc). Around those, will still be a big ecosystem for other companies.

I'm curious if products like SketchUp, Picnik, Desktop and Orkut will also be sunset soon.

Re: Google’s Chief Works to Trim a Bloated Ship

#29
post #3

Moving from an engineering/technology company to a marketing/product company. It needs to happen, or your companu becomes schizophrenic (like Google has been). But doing so without killing the technology culture is hard (I can't think of any successes changing this late off the top of my head). I hope he succeeds. I do like Page's focus on "sit down and work it out in person". So much time wasted trying to do that ov…

Apple somewhat with the transplant of objective-c and next step into apple?

I thought about Apple, but I'm not sure it fits. The company Apple is today is the company that Jobs kept trying to build for 40 years. Proportional fonts and rounded buttons are the result of products, not technologies.

Had he had a weaker personality and Woz a more assertive personality, then I think Apple would have needed to make that shift.

Re: Google’s Chief Works to Trim a Bloated Ship

#30

This is off-topic and doesn't address the actual content of the article, but... "Trim a Bloated Ship"? That metaphor could use some work. How does a ship bloat? And wouldn't a bloated ship float pretty well? If you use the common meaning of trim (honestly, how many mariners read the NYT?), isn't cutting bits off a ship a bad thing? I guess it could be worse. I'll give thanks that Thomas Friedman didn't write it.

Oh wow. Oh wow. Oh wow.
Post reply on HN