Live data from Hacker News

OpenDroneMap

opendronemap.org

1–10 of 66 posts

Re: OpenDroneMap

#4
This is a very cool software! I highly recommend to try it out if you own a drone, even if just for a fun, I learned so much when I was tinkering with it.

Around a year ago I needed to obtain an aerial map of some specific area, but due to recent drastic changes (construction work) and poor quality of the public maps I had to somehow create my own. I fly drones for recreational purposes so I was thinking about using it to make that map when I found out about ODM which is exactly what I was looking for. ODM itself just processes already obtained images (AFAIK) so there is also a whole process of getting them from drone. That's when I found about other software for planning fully automated flight paths so there is a perfect overlap between the photos (required for quality maps and 3D reconstruction). I managed to make a high quality map with 1px:1cm ratio via ODM that I still use from time to time.

Like I mentioned if you own a drone I would recommend to try it out even if it's just for fun as for my case I learned a lot of other stuff I didn't knew before like that automated flight path planning.

Re: OpenDroneMap

#5
Cool idea, which I've wanted to exist (so I'm glad it does). I have two suggestions for improving the site:

1) The huge list of software in the ecosystem is overwhelming. Bury it. The choice of picking the two alternative ways of running it at the top is fine, but that's all the front page should have to say about software.

2) Critically, on the front page you need a quick demo or diagram showing how you get data into it. As a potential user, I really don't care about the open ecosystem or joining a community (this is good content for a "Developers" tab) - instead I want to know how much effort it's going to take me to capture the images and turn them into a cool map. What software does the drone need to run? Can you push video into ODM and get a map out, or do I need to preprocess those images? How far can I go with it, and how are those results achieved? Do I need to be a developer or can I be a semi-technical drone operator? FPV drones ok, or just DJI? Etc etc.

Re: OpenDroneMap

#6
I've been trying to get my organization to use ODM, but finding it difficult. The problem is analogous to the issues that Gimp has to Photoshop or Linux to Windows -- ease of use. Additionally, even if you properly configure the software the quality still is not comparable to the big proprietary players in the photogrammetry field: Bentley Systems; Pix4D; Drone Deploy.

A major reason for the quality issues is that the major drone manufacturers work directly with the proprietary photogrammetry software providers in the field to optimize the algorithms to their drones. These drone manufacturers then promote these proprietary solutions. This puts ODM at a disadvantage as there is no short-term financial incentive for manufacturers to promote ODM.

Like other fields, the proprietary photogrammetry industry is increasing moving to implementing their solutions exclusively in the cloud. This is forcing folks to give up their data and building a data moat - a problem for my organization.

I hope ODM keeps developing and becomes as ubiquitous as linux. Its quality is getting close for my organization to consider its implementation. Keep up the great work!

Re: OpenDroneMap

#7
By coincidence I tried this last week; it really is pretty impressive.

The one thing I missed is some intros/guidance on how best to take photos to feed it; which angle, how much spacing, any tools to use in flight etc. I got pretty good results with my first run but was going to blindly experiment to see if I could improve it. Any tips?

Re: OpenDroneMap

#8
Are maps created by the OpenDroneMap community catalogued anywhere? I may have missed the obvious answer, but only found docs about creating maps (which is, of course, extremely cool!).

Re: OpenDroneMap

#9
post #8

Are maps created by the OpenDroneMap community catalogued anywhere? I may have missed the obvious answer, but only found docs about creating maps (which is, of course, extremely cool!).

I haven't seen a list, but here's a set of well known datasets: https://www.opendronemap.org/odm/datasets/

Some of them include the resulting imagery.

Re: OpenDroneMap

#10
What motivated the choice of AGPL license?

OpenDroneMap has dependencies on GDAL, Proj4J, GeoPackage, SciPy, Python, Nginx, and Django, among other packages. Those foundational libraries tend to have more permissive licenses (PSF, MIT, BSD 3-Clause, Apache 2.0 etc.).

Post reply on HN