Live data from Hacker News

Reddit moderators need to be stopped

ashlan.com

21–30 of 55 posts

Re: Reddit moderators need to be stopped

#21
"Reddit moderators", your issue is with the /r/technology moderators. While there are some moderators who are over many subreddits, for the most part it's per-subreddit. These people don't work for or at "Reddit", they are just the people who originally created the subreddit or the people who were added later to help with moderation (by the people who originally created it).

Looking at the /r/technology rules I don't see anything about submitting your own content (some subs have rules against this).

All that said I agree a total ban is uncalled for but Reddit moderation is a thankless job that makes you sift through a ton of shit (depending on the size of the sub you moderate), I understand knee-jerk bans/deletions. Unless you've done moderation on a decently sized sub you don't understand how much work mods do to keep subs "healthy", sometimes this leads to false positives which is unfortunate but most subs accept that downside to keep out the spam.

Re: Reddit moderators need to be stopped

#23

default/top subs are terrible places, imho. find niche ones instead. moderators have too much power overall and rely too much on auto-filtering algorithms otherwise. Spam is a problem I know, but part of moderating means actually going through submissions instead of just outsourcing it to a filtering system.

I'm a mod on Reddit. Mods will be mediocre to bad, because they're volunteers. There just isn't enough time to do a good job on popular subs. And you can't fix this by getting more mods without introducing other problems.

the worst subreddits are the ones that have like 10-15 mods who just do nothing.

You don't fix a subreddit by adding more mods to the modlist.

Re: Reddit moderators need to be stopped

#26
It's because you submitted so many of your own articles.

> It's not strictly forbidden to submit a link to a site that you own or otherwise benefit from in some way, but you should sort of consider yourself on thin ice. So please pay careful attention to the rest of these bullet points.

> If your contribution to reddit consists mostly of submitting links to a site(s) that you own or otherwise benefit from in some way, and additionally if you do not participate in discussion, or reply to peoples questions, regardless of how many upvotes your submissions get, you are a spammer. If over 10% of your submissions and conversation are your own site/content/affiliate links, you're almost certainly a spammer.

- https://old.reddit.com/wiki/faq#wiki_what_constitutes_spam.3...

I'm sorry they banned you instead of just telling you that and asking you to stop.

Re: Reddit moderators need to be stopped

#27
You violated Reddit's self promotion rules by only posting your own content to that subreddit multiple times and are railing against the mods for doing their job?

https://www.reddit.com/wiki/selfpromotion

And you're posting the complain on HN which also has a rule against it:

>Please don't use HN primarily for promotion. It's ok to post your own stuff occasionally, but the primary use of the site should be for curiosity.

Re: Reddit moderators need to be stopped

#28

You won't get a response from them. A famous list revealed that almost all top subreddits are moderated by the same people: https://www.reddit.com/r/ThatsInsane/comments/pbloje/almost_...

I bet those very same people, without awareness of the irony, promote the outrage about concentration of wealth or income inequality.

Re: Reddit moderators need to be stopped

#29

Is it not trivial to create your own subreddit and mod it however you like?

Yes, but it defeats the purpose of the intent to share with as many relevant people as possible; since you have to build up that membership count in the first place.

So it really sucks when the Reddit mods get out of control from time to time over what should just be simple situations able to be remedied with a simple 'sorry'.

Re: Reddit moderators need to be stopped

#30
I have been a mod on one of the top/default subredits, as well as other popular subreddits. There is a lot of crap to sort through in order to keep the overall value of the subreddit.

Did you post the same article to multiple subreddits? Is a fair amount of your post history on reddit links to the same blog? Is your account new? Those would all be looked at when deciding to ban.

Post reply on HN