Live data from Hacker News

Ten Percent of the Brain Myth

en.wikipedia.org

11–20 of 133 posts

Re: Ten Percent of the Brain Myth

#11
post #9

It's a bit like saying a piano player will only use 10% of the keys at a time.

This is an extremely good analogy that I must remember (if case anyone quotes this myth to me again, which hasn't happened in a couple of decades... :)

I don’t think anyone except Luc Besson still thinks this is true anymore tho..

Re: Ten Percent of the Brain Myth

#12
It's amazing to think how common these sorts of myths used to be before the internet. If you heard something like this and wanted to challenge it, you would have to get on the bus and spend a couple of hours at the library and return with some photocopies. Now you can pull up Wikipedia on your phone.

Re: Ten Percent of the Brain Myth

#15

It's amazing to think how common these sorts of myths used to be before the internet. If you heard something like this and wanted to challenge it, you would have to get on the bus and spend a couple of hours at the library and return with some photocopies. Now you can pull up Wikipedia on your phone.

There are plenty of post-internet myths that are humming along just fine. :D

It's a crazy phenomenon to watch play out.

Re: Ten Percent of the Brain Myth

#16

It's amazing to think how common these sorts of myths used to be before the internet. If you heard something like this and wanted to challenge it, you would have to get on the bus and spend a couple of hours at the library and return with some photocopies. Now you can pull up Wikipedia on your phone.

There are plenty of post-internet myths that are humming along just fine. :D It's a crazy phenomenon to watch play out.

Absolutely true, but there somehow seems different quality to them. The myths of old seemed to be little factoids that were not easy to verify and were taken at face value, then just spread until they became "common knowledge". The new ones seem to have an almost religious quality to them. Flat-earthers for example, if someone told me 25 years ago that this would be a thing I would have just laughed.

Re: Ten Percent of the Brain Myth

#18
post #8

>Studies of brain damage: If 10 percent of the brain is normally used, then damage to other areas should not impair performance This is unbelievably naive to use as some sort of proof, using 10% does not imply that its 10% of the physical organ. Rather 10% compared to what one could do with better training, improved lifestyle, etc. And this does not have to be purely intellectual, it can be imagination capabilities,…

counterpoint - people do take damage to brain and recover abilities, suggesting that the brain has redundancies built into it.

Re: Ten Percent of the Brain Myth

#19
post #9

It's a bit like saying a piano player will only use 10% of the keys at a time.

This is an extremely good analogy that I must remember (if case anyone quotes this myth to me again, which hasn't happened in a couple of decades... :)

It's a good analogy for the hardware (brain) aspect, but there's also the software (mind) aspect.
Post reply on HN