Live data from Hacker News

Pepsi: Breathtaking Design Strategy (2008) [pdf]

jimedwardsnrx.files.wordpress.com

161–170 of 276 posts

Re: Pepsi: Breathtaking Design Strategy (2008) [pdf]

#161
post #156

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You will have to take up your objections with the endocrinologists. Good luck, though, 'cause endocrinologists are the smartest of all medical doctors. Have to be, to do it at all.

This is a non-response - or do you have a specific cite linking uric acid as causative of diabetes or cardiovascular disease? It can be in a colorectal journal for all I care. > Have to be, to do it at all. Lol. Yeah bud, I have a ton of friends that are endocrinologists, all mostly great and intelligent folks, but I’m not letting them touch me with a colonoscope - or pretty much any implement. It’s not exactly a fie…

So, ask them. It is their job to know. You have already said you don't trust me.

Be sure to report back what they tell you.

Re: Pepsi: Breathtaking Design Strategy (2008) [pdf]

#163

Earlier quoted context omitted.

LOL, this is not "sophistication", this is bullshit. A million(s?) dollar study for a global brand is justified by things like: * Research to see if the brand logos/names are misunderstood or offensive for a particular market/culture. * Research regarding brand recognition before/after the proposed changes. * A lot of design/thought behind how the brand will look in the many communication channels/products that it ow…

It’s a now legendary document designed to promote Pepsi’s brand. They nailed it. That other stuff was covered in another document.

So, first of all, was this document actually meant for public consumption like you suggest?

Second of all, do you actually think anyone who reads this document will associate positive feelings with Pepsi?

All it's making me think is "Man, those Coke ads with the polar bears were pretty cool."

Re: Pepsi: Breathtaking Design Strategy (2008) [pdf]

#164
post #160
post #123

Pepsi, Tropicana and the like, and their parent companies, are a direct cause of the Metabolic Syndrome epidemic in (particularly) the US, other former UK colonies, and UK, causing many times the preventable deaths from COVID, year in and year out. The "cause of death" noted for these cases never mentions metabolic syndrome (variously, fatty liver disease, cirrhosis, processed-food disease), but rather secondary illn…

Sure metabolic syndrome is a thing, but can you point to me evidence it is caused by these drinks? I agree re: the metabolic pathways, but yet to be convinced that most of these issues are not primarily caused by obesity. And sure, drinking enough sugar will result in obesity, but so will eating too much carbs or fat.

Obesity is a separate morbidity. 30% of obese Americans are not actually ill. But 40% of non-obese Americans are sick with metabolic syndrome. So, more than are obese and sick, by the raw numbers. Obesity is a big problem in the US, but metabolic syndrome is a bigger problem, and suffering both is worse than either alone.

Pakistan has as much metabolic syndrome as other former UK colonies, but remarkably little obesity.

Metabolic syndrome is a product of excess fructose in the bloodstream, itself a product of sugar consumed without enough accompanying fiber. Beverages are a particularly concentrated source, but other stuff packaged as food can be as bad.

Re: Pepsi: Breathtaking Design Strategy (2008) [pdf]

#165

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree that brand and marketing is of paramount importance here. But to say this is sophisticated and well-thought is a stretch. It's funny precisely for its lack of sophistication, for how many millions of dollars and countless hours were spent creating something that lacks real value, that's crafted together with the well-meaning exuberance of a teenager trying to look "deep" or earn brownie points.

I think the sophistication is lacking in the criticisms voiced in the comments. Regardless of the excessive & laughable b.s. factor of this high level design concept document, the proposal meets its brief: design a rebranding strategy that can be used in 2d, 3d, kiosks, blah, etc. as required, without each needing their own design proposal. So this designer latched onto geometric features of original pepsi logos, ext…

> fairly simple approach

I think we can all agree this PDF goes out of its way to convince the reader that it's anything but simple.

- Pepsi DNA

- Pepsi Energy Fields

- The Pepsi Universe

It's all gold, to be honest. I love this document.

Re: Pepsi: Breathtaking Design Strategy (2008) [pdf]

#167

Worth mentioning that this is the same design company that blew $35MM on a terrible redesign of Tropicana Orange Juice, which they reverted back within a couple days (but kept the mock orange cap) https://www.thebrandingjournal.com/2015/05/what-to-learn-fro...

Their new design was just yet another example of how the currently in vogue "minimalism everywhere" design aesthetic sucks. The Tropicana case study is such a great example because the effects were so drastic, but only really because there were easily substituted goods - consumers basically thought the carton was just "generic store brand OJ". My guess is that other recent brand redesigns to this boring, same, sans-s…

Saying that this guy's designs were terrible therefore all modern design is terrible is like saying all children's TV presenters are pedophiles (apologies I know that's an extreme analogy).

The truth is that the guy behind this design agency is not a good designer at all and his career seems to have been driven by confidence, greed and the incompetence of his clients. It's a sample of one. He's the Jimmy Saville of bad design

Re: Pepsi: Breathtaking Design Strategy (2008) [pdf]

#169
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

i'd like to have whatever the author of this document is having

This is good stuff, you can't make it up. It looks like lots was going on at the Arnell group at this time. In this article it even quotes Arnell as saying this work for Pepsi in OP as "Bullshit" https://www.cbsnews.com/news/why-the-firing-of-weird-design-... You can't make this stuff up

Quote from the article about the "Breathtaking Design Strategy" document:

> February 2009: Arnell sold Pepsi a pretentious, mostly made-up brand ideology document linking Pepsi to the Mona Lisa, De[s]cartes and Hinduism, as part of a successful logo redesign. Price: $1 million, reportedly.

Re: Pepsi: Breathtaking Design Strategy (2008) [pdf]

#170
post #123

Pepsi, Tropicana and the like, and their parent companies, are a direct cause of the Metabolic Syndrome epidemic in (particularly) the US, other former UK colonies, and UK, causing many times the preventable deaths from COVID, year in and year out. The "cause of death" noted for these cases never mentions metabolic syndrome (variously, fatty liver disease, cirrhosis, processed-food disease), but rather secondary illn…

Video that covers fructose and uric acid:

https://youtu.be/BzwH-94vMis

Post reply on HN