Live data from Hacker News

Smart mushroom growing device for beginners

shrooly.com

181–190 of 209 posts

Re: Smart mushroom growing device for beginners

#181
post #25

as a home mushroom cultivator I can tell you that this device is pretty much the Juicero of the mushroom world. from what i'm reading this device accomplishes nothing that one can't do with a homemade monotub composed of a 32 quart storage tote, a spray bottle and some polyfill. if you are interested in growing edible gourmet mushrooms look up a local mushroom farm in your area, most of them sell blocks that you can…

Lolls like this device won't even fit most blocks.

Re: Smart mushroom growing device for beginners

#182
post #114
post #100

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yea if I was cooking for someone I would feel better about harvesting food from this device than "hold on a second while I get this bucket out of my cupboard."

I agree. Mushroom growing needs to be hygienic but depends on conditions that are not normally considered hygienic. Having some help in terms of the inputs and conditions would provide reassurance. There are lots of products like that in the kitchen that take something relatively easy and make it more consistent.

I don't see this device really providing any hygiene benefit. If anything it looks like it would be harder to clean than a tote.

Re: Smart mushroom growing device for beginners

#183
post #170

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A tip: sous vide is guaranteed not to get hot enough to kill eg Botulinum nor many kinds of spores, because the heat conductor is liquid water. Pressure cooker (modern teks use Instant Pot) will achieve the necessary thermal properties because they produce superheated steam.

Yes but I was using straw and if the temperature is too high it cooks the straw and then it’s useless. I guess it’s a crap shoot hoping there wasn't anaerobic conditions to grow botulism in the straw bale. For all other spores, the mycelium grows fast enough to make sure nothing else can gain a foothold.

you do realise that you aren't sterilising anything though right? It's not a crap shoot - it's a unnecessary step since you aren't actually achieving anything. You might as well not do that step

Re: Smart mushroom growing device for beginners

#184
post #61
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

i fear coming off as a hostile know it all, but i think this company is simply parting a fool from their money (see Juicero). i don't think that a click and grow equivalent is needed in the cubensis cultivation space. with the advent of uncle bens tek around 2019 and pf tek years before that the flood gates for at home cultivation psilocybe cubensis have already been opened.

Yet there's still no begginer-friendly way of doing any of that without diving head-first into the DIY home growing literature. Your comments are coming off as gatekeeping for no other reason than speculation and the fact you're already familiar with the space. This product seems to simplify the entire process of home growing, which is a bit more involved than squeezing juice out of fruit. As long as it's priced and…

"This product seems to simplify the entire process of home growing,"

Eh, it can be difficult. The most difficult part is sterilization and inoculations/transfers. This doesn't help with that. You can literally hook up a mister to a timer to get the same effect (I know, I've done it as a newbie).

But I agree that people will buy it, as they do many things that aren't truly necessary (doesn't bother me).

Re: Smart mushroom growing device for beginners

#185
post #25

as a home mushroom cultivator I can tell you that this device is pretty much the Juicero of the mushroom world. from what i'm reading this device accomplishes nothing that one can't do with a homemade monotub composed of a 32 quart storage tote, a spray bottle and some polyfill. if you are interested in growing edible gourmet mushrooms look up a local mushroom farm in your area, most of them sell blocks that you can…

You don't even need the tub, just a fruiting block and a sprayer. For oysters many places this machine is just way overkill.

Re: Smart mushroom growing device for beginners

#187

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes but I was using straw and if the temperature is too high it cooks the straw and then it’s useless. I guess it’s a crap shoot hoping there wasn't anaerobic conditions to grow botulism in the straw bale. For all other spores, the mycelium grows fast enough to make sure nothing else can gain a foothold.

you do realise that you aren't sterilising anything though right? It's not a crap shoot - it's a unnecessary step since you aren't actually achieving anything. You might as well not do that step

Nonsense, you get everything except things that are heat resistant (like botulism) at 170F.

Re: Smart mushroom growing device for beginners

#188
post #168

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>This is a fruiting chamber, not a mushroom growing device. Fruiting is by far the most trivial part of mushroom growing. You've hit on exactly the value being provided here - they are handling the culture, inoculation, spawning, and colonization stages and selling you an expensive box to put the result in. Sometimes people just want a quick fun activity and they don't want to research it beforehand. This product fil…

I can go buy $10 kits (pre-innoculated block) that fruits in a few days from the local farmers market. $20 on Etsy.

You are not the target audience of this, obviously.

Re: Smart mushroom growing device for beginners

#189

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>This is a fruiting chamber, not a mushroom growing device. Fruiting is by far the most trivial part of mushroom growing. You've hit on exactly the value being provided here - they are handling the culture, inoculation, spawning, and colonization stages and selling you an expensive box to put the result in. Sometimes people just want a quick fun activity and they don't want to research it beforehand. This product fil…

$300 fancy plastic box for humidity and heat control. And shrooms sold separately. Some rich family will get it for their kids to use it once.

Okay but what about the reverse? If I'm an actual beginner can I just buy their $10 blocks, skip the device, and do the easy part?

Re: Smart mushroom growing device for beginners

#190
post #168

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can go buy $10 kits (pre-innoculated block) that fruits in a few days from the local farmers market. $20 on Etsy.

You are not the target audience of this, obviously.

Who is the target audience of this, do you think?
Post reply on HN