Live data from Hacker News

Where does Google actually say that they won’t read Gmail or Google Docs?

blogs.law.harvard.edu

81–90 of 94 posts

Re: Where does Google actually say that they won’t read Gmail or Google Docs?

#81

Has there been anyone working to make a comprehensive locally-hostable webmail/weboffice suite that replicates Google's functionality? I can imagine that this would be quite poular. Sure, some of the features like Priority Inbox might require complex heuristics, but things like labels should be easy to add support for.

Google used to sell hardware appliances, before they realized they would actually prefer to read all your documents.

Re: Where does Google actually say that they won’t read Gmail or Google Docs?

#82
post #77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Which is a shame because I think it's pretty clear the OP is actually asking about Google employees reading your email Unless you run your own smtp and pop/imap mail servers, there is no way to be sure no one will read your emails. Even then, your servers could get hacked or maybe your contacts use a hosted solution (and most people do) that could get hacked, there is again no guaranty. The only work around is to f…

Unless you run your own smtp and pop/imap mail servers, there is no way to be sure no one will read your emails. I think you really want to encrypt your email for that kind of peace of mind. Of course you need buy in from your contacts.

Actually there is another option which is to store emails on a secure webserver instead of sending them, and send "you've got mail" notifications instead. There are some usability issues such as message threading and what not, but technically this is much simpler to set up than the conventional encrypted email.

Re: Where does Google actually say that they won’t read Gmail or Google Docs?

#83
philg's comment:

"Folks: The problem with Google promising to hold “personal information” confidential is that a document may not meet the definition of “personal information” given in http://www.google.com/intl/en/privacy/faq.html#toc-terms-per... . For example, if you write down some ideas for a new product and keep it as a Google Doc there may be nothing in the document that identifies you as the author and therefore it might be okay for Google to read or distribute the document.

Generally speaking the Google privacy docs address a separate issue from the question of keeping email or documents confidential. They are about the question of whether your identify is kept confidential when you’re browsing around the Web and Google is figuring out what your interests and demographics are. Worthy stuff to be writing about, no doubt, but it doesn’t shed much light on the subject of whether a Google employee can copy and paste paragraphs from your email messages or Google docs."

http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/philg/2011/11/03/where-does-goo...

Re: Where does Google actually say that they won’t read Gmail or Google Docs?

#84
It's not google you have to fear.

It's the warrantless backdoors installed for most government entities.

What you think is harmless to discuss is probably being auto-indexed by them to use against you if you ever become a "problem" (ie. protest war, etc.)

Re: Where does Google actually say that they won’t read Gmail or Google Docs?

#85
Google should provide the option of automatically encrypting your incoming email with your public PGP key, if you provide one. They could similarly automatically encrypt your Sent folder (not the actual sent messages). That way, even if your account is compromised, or emails subpoenaed, they can't read the emails without your private key.

That's exactly what I do on my system anyway. I host my own email as well though: https://grepular.com/Automatically_Encrypting_all_Incoming_E...

Re: Where does Google actually say that they won’t read Gmail or Google Docs?

#88
It is probably pointless for Google to use humans to read mails, especially the mails of regular people. And it is certain that they use automated processing of the information in the mails.

A most relevant question would be: Does Google match the profiles of its mail users to high profile people, such as company managers or other rich people who can be easily found on, for example, Linkedin? If so, does Google automatically filter their email in order to predict, for example, the stock market?

Re: Where does Google actually say that they won’t read Gmail or Google Docs?

#90

I am more concerned about Google making an arbitrary decision to delete my Gmail account.

That's why I got my own domain. Coupled with offlineimap (or any other mail backuping software) running regularly, I can move from Gmail to any other provider in the time it takes to create a new account and update the MX records.
Post reply on HN