Live data from Hacker News

TikTok updated privacy policy to collect faceprints and voiceprints (2021)

pandasecurity.com

121–130 of 342 posts

Re: TikTok updated privacy policy to collect faceprints and voiceprints (2021)

#121
post #112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree. But until then, what do you think the people should do?

Twitter should bring back Vine so we have a US ran equivalent.

Or maybe we should just support and adopt open source alternatives, so that the rest of the world doesn't get stuck into pointless geopolitical disputes?

Re: TikTok updated privacy policy to collect faceprints and voiceprints (2021)

#122
I don't understand the argument that we shouldn't ban tikTok because Meta/Google/etc.. also collect data. I would rather ban all three, but tikTok is in a whole different league based on how that data is used.

The difference is that the CCP is literally on the board of bytedance and uses this information to arrest, imprison, and harvest the organs of political, ideological, religious, and other dissidents.

Yes, the US has done evil things in the past (and present) but our abuse of data is a far cry from what happens inside many tightly controlled communist countries on a daily basis.

Re: TikTok updated privacy policy to collect faceprints and voiceprints (2021)

#123

A security researcher wrote an article while back and it was shocking to see how much data TikTok was collecting: - biometrics - what words are mentioned in the video, popularity - surrounding wifi, location data - your contacts (presumably to cross link to social media platforms) I just can't believe that a powerful country like America is letting a not-so-friendly military/civilian complex infiltrate it for somewha…

It's TikTok. Funny jokes and dance videos. And they're collecting no more than American IT companies are doing. "I just can't believe that a powerful country like America is letting a not-so-friendly military/civilian complex infiltrate it for somewhat unknown purpose." Are you for real? The one country that fits the description of not-so-friendly military-complex is the U.S. itself. A more pressing problem and quest…

"Yes but what about the US Government?" is not an actual response to concerns about Tiktok, it's a lazy attempt at deflection and distraction.

And the US Government doesn't use private sector data to round up and imprison their citizens in concentration camps. https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2021/12/14/huawei-surve...

Re: TikTok updated privacy policy to collect faceprints and voiceprints (2021)

#126
post #35

Is there someone here that work at TikTok who could explain how collecting such that brings any value to TikTok. That's an honest question. I understand that we're being tracked with cookies, email address, FB/Google accounts. But the biometric stuff, what is it for ? It seems very disproportionate to me if it's just for advertising.

The most obvious (capitalist) application would be to use the data to build AI "creators". Some of these real people make good money as influencers. And if TikTok could use computers to generate influencers, they could seriously cash in. The military applications of this tech would be to stir up decent or manufacture outrage in a country for political gains. Or maybe both. Selling military tech to other countries is…

>The military applications of this tech would be to stir up decent or manufacture outrage in a country for political gains.

I didn't need that thought in my life, thank you. Seriously, though, this genuinely makes it possible to gently tweak an algorithm (which is absolutely invisible to anyone outside the company or the Chinese government) to nudge public opinion. Like, you could probably nudge elections by a percentage point or two, manufacture specific outrage about policies unfriendly to China, generate a bit of chaos with conspiracy theories when convenient, etc, etc. Black Mirror stuff. I

'm telling myself it's unlikely to actually happen but when I ask myself why I can't come up with a reassuring answer. The technology is there. The control is there. The willingness is certainly there. I guess it would be a bigger endeavor and there might be leaks of it happening. But, ultimately, a few dozen people could do a lot of damage.

Re: TikTok updated privacy policy to collect faceprints and voiceprints (2021)

#127

A security researcher wrote an article while back and it was shocking to see how much data TikTok was collecting: - biometrics - what words are mentioned in the video, popularity - surrounding wifi, location data - your contacts (presumably to cross link to social media platforms) I just can't believe that a powerful country like America is letting a not-so-friendly military/civilian complex infiltrate it for somewha…

I'm going to guess that the purpose is to use the data to eventually build life-like, AI-generated social media influencers. The data will show what kind of faces, voices, inflections, word choice, etc. is most influential. I don't think the technology is quite there yet, but very soon it will be possible, with a little hand tweaking, to fake "cool" people — video bots. It will be used as a psy-op.

> I'm going to guess that the purpose is to use the data to eventually build life-like, AI-generated social media influencers.

You think?

> very soon it will be possible, with a little hand tweaking, to fake "cool" people

If your worst thread is being out-done by a bot in the ... what domain is "cool" in. And whom are you quoting from?

PS: What can I say, you got my goat. Vain people are very vulnerable in it (think that's the definition of "vain", but I still want to know what "it" is)

Re: TikTok updated privacy policy to collect faceprints and voiceprints (2021)

#128

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you think that any of it is acceptable?

It should be unacceptable regardless of country of origin.

Stop generalizing the "country of origin" as if it does not matter like the Chinese Comunist Party isn't a threat to the world.

- There will always be a ruler, and which ruler is killing, slaving, censoring and selling it's own people as meat tools for foreign companies?

- China will kill, torture it's own people and their families if they think they are a thread (even if remote) to their government party (CCP).

- China put on a HEAVY surveilance tool and actually forced people to behave like they want using social credit

- China is actively removing ANY historical filosophies, tales, traditions, religions that could be a thread to the CCP's beliefs.

- Have you ever seen a CCP convention? Their plan is to remove the worlds countries boundaries in order to rule over everything from culture to politics and economics. Australia is suffering a lot on their hands, they even sent spies to patronize elections.

Re: TikTok updated privacy policy to collect faceprints and voiceprints (2021)

#129
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is this collection different from, say, Meta? I believe they collect all the same information via Instagram. And before someone says Meta is an American company, not controlled by an adversary, let me recall that it’s controlled by Zuckerberg who spent $419 million to influence US election administration in a seemingly partisan way (“democracy hacking” as another commenter said). Meta may not be YOUR adversary, but t…

> it’s controlled by Zuckerberg who spent $419 million to influence US election administration in a seemingly partisan way Like all US billionaires, then? > Meta may not be YOUR adversary, but that fact is not necessarily true of all (or even most) Americans The US government and ruling class doesn't see Meta as their adversary, even if it this the adversary of some Americans.

There’s also the small issue that many of us aren’t Americans, so if offers little comfort that Meta is an American company.

Re: TikTok updated privacy policy to collect faceprints and voiceprints (2021)

#130
I will repeat my comment:

Stop generalizing the "country of origin" as if it does not matter like the Chinese Comunist Party isn't a threat to the world. - There will always be a ruler, and which ruler is killing, slaving, censoring and selling it's own people as meat tools for foreign companies?

- China will kill, torture it's own people and their families if they think they are a thread (even if remote) to their government party (CCP).

- China put on a HEAVY surveilance tool and actually forced people to behave like they want using social credit

- China is actively removing ANY historical filosophies, tales, traditions, religions that could be a thread to the CCP's beliefs.

- Have you ever seen a CCP convention? Their plan is to remove the worlds countries boundaries in order to rule over everything from culture to politics and economics. Australia is suffering a lot on their hands, they even sent spies to patronize elections.

Post reply on HN