Live data from Hacker News

Lego Battle of Verdun [video]

youtube.com

41–50 of 158 posts

Re: Lego Battle of Verdun [video]

#41
post #5

I wonder if this is done with CGI or real Legos. The texture on the prices is excellent but The LEGO Movie achieved this level or realism in CGI. Edit: looked at the rest of his channel. It’s a mix of stop motion, rigs to throw bricks/simulate brick explosions, and CGI.

[deleted]

Re: Lego Battle of Verdun [video]

#42
post #23

Call me a killjoy, but the Battle of Verdun was one of the worst and bloodiest battles of a horrific war that arguably ruined Europe. Is there Lego Auschwitz, too? Bad taste, whoever did this. Bad taste.

I think it’s tastefully made, and doesn’t make light of the war at all. Lego can be a neutral medium to express ideas, like play dough or wooden figurines.

Re: Lego Battle of Verdun [video]

#43

If wonder if this is where they got the French machine guns: https://www.brickwarriors.com/french-lmg/ (first result for "lego chauchat gun"). I kind of love that there's this 3rd-party market for relatively obscure weapons for minifigs.

No post body was provided.

Re: Lego Battle of Verdun [video]

#44
post #5

I wonder if this is done with CGI or real Legos. The texture on the prices is excellent but The LEGO Movie achieved this level or realism in CGI. Edit: looked at the rest of his channel. It’s a mix of stop motion, rigs to throw bricks/simulate brick explosions, and CGI.

They definitely came a long way since their first video 8 years ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bD1AbWGqT4c

What makes you say it contains CGI?

Re: Lego Battle of Verdun [video]

#45
post #3

Lego depicting war is so depressing... (well, except for Lego Star Wars of course, somehow that seems to pass both the corporate and my personal "no way toys!" filters)

When I was a child, Lego was explicitly and deliberately pacifist in outlook. I remember reading that the colour palette was determined in part by this philosophy - green, grey and brown were verboten, the latter colour completely absent and the first two existing only in limited plate form. Of course manufacturing cost limitations made a restricted set of colours sensible anyway.

As a preventative, this was not entirely effective - we war-mad kids still had red bombers intercepted by white fighter aircraft over a battlefield of blue armoured vehicles, we didn't care!

Re: Lego Battle of Verdun [video]

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is that it, are we back at “video games cause murders”-level pearl clutching? I’ll take a peer-reviewed cohort study before I believe that “Lego has been consistent in promoting aggressiveness”.

Poster said Lego has been promoting aggressiveness, not that it has caused aggressiveness. It's undeniable that Lego themes have drifted a lot more to violence (Lego City is half about Policing), plus all the Ninja and other stuff.

I deny Lego themes drifted towards violence. I just went through my kits from the late 80ies/early 90ies since kid is reaching Lego age. I was a big fan of Space, and like > 60% of the sets are Blacktron and Space Police.

City kits always had police and my cousin mostly owned Castles/Knights. There were pirates and pirate ships with cannons that can shoot bricks (we loved those) Pirates seem to be mostly gone and replaced by Ninjago but police stuck around. No surprise, kids love police stories.

On the civilian side of Lego City, a large collection of civilian space exploration has been added. Space definitely has been demilitarized.

Re: Lego Battle of Verdun [video]

#47
post #5

I wonder if this is done with CGI or real Legos. The texture on the prices is excellent but The LEGO Movie achieved this level or realism in CGI. Edit: looked at the rest of his channel. It’s a mix of stop motion, rigs to throw bricks/simulate brick explosions, and CGI.

They definitely came a long way since their first video 8 years ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bD1AbWGqT4c What makes you say it contains CGI?

Look at the "behind the scene": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t1T-RNDWIEU

Re: Lego Battle of Verdun [video]

#48
post #3

Lego depicting war is so depressing... (well, except for Lego Star Wars of course, somehow that seems to pass both the corporate and my personal "no way toys!" filters)

As far as themed sets go, Lego has been consistent in promoting aggressiveness in the last 30 years. Police chasing the bad guys to put them in a prison cell, pirates wanting to plunder the treasure, ninjas riding heavily-armed aircraft.

The police minifigs have certainly kept up with real life US cops: https://twitter.com/aliceavizandum/status/114154755632285286...

Re: Lego Battle of Verdun [video]

#49
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When was that time? Because classic space had rayguns, and the pirate ships had working cannons.

> When was that time? It's literally written in the article that the person you are responding to linked. I'd recommend reading it.

The article is about “realistic weapons that kids may recognize from conflict zones.” Everyone I know from the time took the various “antenna” pieces on the space craft as “laser guns.” The space police figures had weird looking pieces that can be interpreted as or such, but they easily serve as futuristic guns as well.

I’m observing my kid picking up lego and assembling my old sets and they take that the same way without prompting.

Using bricklink as proof that the number of weapons increased is hilarious. Many kits used and still use regular bricks in places where they can clearly be read as weapons. (1) Lego definitely has a trend to make more specialized pieces now, so it’s not surprising at all that more specialized weapons show up.

(1) The cannonballs are listed as “Brick Round, 1x1 open stud”, because that’s what they originally are.

https://www.bricklink.com/v2/catalog/catalogitem.page?P=3062...

Re: Lego Battle of Verdun [video]

#50
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When was that time? Because classic space had rayguns, and the pirate ships had working cannons.

> When was that time? It's literally written in the article that the person you are responding to linked. I'd recommend reading it.

> From 1945 onwards, Lego began producing a wooden version of a toy pistol. The company then applied for a patent of the model in 1946. A plastic version of a rapid-firing pistol began to be manufactured in 1949.

The first minifigure is from 1978, the first weapon is from the same year.

Post reply on HN