Live data from Hacker News

Help me out by taking this spatial ability test

psych.io

61–66 of 66 posts

Re: Help me out by taking this spatial ability test

#61
post #39
post #37

9/9... but with submitting twice (first try: 7/9) The tests that have only different symbols are much easier than the ones where symbols are repeated. For example for question 1, without actually building the whole of the cube in one's head, it's quite obvious that the circle is always on the left side of the heart, except in one case where it will be at the top, and since the cubes have to be absolutely identical on…

Yes, there are many moderators of difficulty. We had some requirements for the test which included graded difficulty from very easy to very hard to be able to separate out people of different abilities over a regular population. We were supposed to design the first question so that 100% of people got it correct; to be an easy, practice type question. Also, you guys aren't even getting to see our hardest questions :D…

Really hard indeed!. Mind blowing. At first I thought C but then I cheated ( it is hard even cheating...) and drawing the diferent posibilities I only see A=D and B=C. I dOn't know what I am missing.

Re: Help me out by taking this spatial ability test

#62
post #48
post #44

Looking for opposing face pairs is the easy method, and works on most of the questions (I think 6 of the 9.) If all the opposing pairs are the same, there are two more ways to distinguish. One is the placement of the symbols relative to each other; the chirality of the whole object. For an example, think of a six-sided die. Position it so that the 6 is on top and 2 is towards you. The left and right faces will be the…

What I have found is that the higher intelligence/spatial ability type people are able to use these types of techniques on more difficult questions. I do very well on traditional spatial tests because they are trivial with relational or structural comparison. Here is a real challenge.. can you think of a design for a spatial ability test (that is able to be done on pen/paper) that does not allow for this type of stra…

[deleted]

Re: Help me out by taking this spatial ability test

#63
post #48
post #44

Looking for opposing face pairs is the easy method, and works on most of the questions (I think 6 of the 9.) If all the opposing pairs are the same, there are two more ways to distinguish. One is the placement of the symbols relative to each other; the chirality of the whole object. For an example, think of a six-sided die. Position it so that the 6 is on top and 2 is towards you. The left and right faces will be the…

What I have found is that the higher intelligence/spatial ability type people are able to use these types of techniques on more difficult questions. I do very well on traditional spatial tests because they are trivial with relational or structural comparison. Here is a real challenge.. can you think of a design for a spatial ability test (that is able to be done on pen/paper) that does not allow for this type of stra…

If you are asking whether it's actually possible to test natural talent rather than learned knowledge - I don't think so. they are always conflated in tests (this is no exception)

Re: Help me out by taking this spatial ability test

#64
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agreed, same here. SPOILER The consensus seems to be that 8 has more than one answer, I definitely see 8A as different from the others (arrows pointing away from each other as opposed to perpendicular), but perhaps there is another one. Brain is too tired to figure out another possibility right now; thanks for the workout :) BTW #6 I found most difficult (even more so than #9), and #7 was far too easy for its positio…

Yes, No. 8 has certainly an error. At least the version I got first, if I load the page now I get a different set of cubes. Proof: https://imgur.com/a/rH5kW

That's exactly the one I had (http://news.ycombinator.org/item?id=3186671). I was pretty sure it was non-unique, but I'm glad you checked it properly!

Re: Help me out by taking this spatial ability test

#65
post #37

9/9... but with submitting twice (first try: 7/9) The tests that have only different symbols are much easier than the ones where symbols are repeated. For example for question 1, without actually building the whole of the cube in one's head, it's quite obvious that the circle is always on the left side of the heart, except in one case where it will be at the top, and since the cubes have to be absolutely identical on…

I found all of them very easy except "question 6", at which I'm still failing hard to visualize the difference, and is the only one I got wrong. (I had to choose a random one)

Re: Help me out by taking this spatial ability test

#66
9/9, first try. Here's how I solved each one (rot13 to avoid unintentional spoilers): 1. Vf gur Fdhner arkg gb gur Pvepyr? 2. Bevrag gur phor fb gung gur Urneg vf va abezny cbfvgvba (gvc qbja) snpvat lbh. Jung funcr vf ba gur yrsg snpr? 3. Jung funcr vf bccbfvgr gur Pvepyr? 4. Vf gur Neebj cbvagvat ng gur Pvepyr? 5. Vf gur Neebj cbvagvat ng gur Pvepyr? 6. Bevrag gur phor fb gur pvepyr jvgu gur neebj cbvagvat njnl sebz vg vf snpvat lbh, naq gung neebj vf ba gbc, cbvagvat njnl sebz lbh. Jung funcr vf ba gur evtug snpr? 7. Bevrag gur phor fb gur pvepyr vf snpvat lbh. Gur neebj vf cbvagvat gbjneq gur urneg va jung bevragngvba? 8. Vf gurer n gevnatyr cbvagvat ng n pvepyr? 9. Rnpu phor unf ybbc bs 4 snprf pbafvfgvat bs n oynax fheebhaqrq ol 3 urnegf. Ner obgu urnegf ba rvgure fvqr bs gur oynax cbvagvat va gur fnzr qverpgvba (abegu fbhgu rnfg jrfg hc qbja)?

Not sure if this is the kind of spatial ability they're trying to test.

Post reply on HN