Live data from Hacker News

Twitter Notes

twitter.com

51–60 of 316 posts

Re: Twitter Notes

#51

Aside, why is this shared in a very very long weird GIF and not a video. (can't pause/seek)

I was curious about this too and thought it must be a massive GIF. However it's not actually a GIF, it's an MP4 video[1], I wonder why it's mislabelled as a GIF.

[1]: https://video.twimg.com/tweet_video/FV3mdpEXoAIrkA1.mp4

Re: Twitter Notes

#53
post #4

I welcome this. I always hated the long multi-tweet essays and have often just given up on reading them, especially when I'm not logged in I can't even make it to the end before twitter blocks me from scrolling further. As of now it doesn't look like you can reply to a note with another note? That might go a long way for improving debate and discussion.

I still won't bother. No matter how fast of a computer you use, Twitter is annoyingly slow to load and seems to leak memory if you scroll too far.

My most despised (feature) of Twitter on desktop is that purposeful delay to alerts, where it blinks for a splitsecond and then the little colored alert icon disappears for a solid 3 to 5 seconds only to appear again this time correctly and permanently

It is just so annoying that they would do such a thing, I am sure that they have a/b tested it, I don't care it drives me insane, just make it work properly tho I am sure that they have also taken onto account people like me whom despise it, yet not enough to leave the platform

Just an overall worsening of user experience

Re: Twitter Notes

#54
post #4

I welcome this. I always hated the long multi-tweet essays and have often just given up on reading them, especially when I'm not logged in I can't even make it to the end before twitter blocks me from scrolling further. As of now it doesn't look like you can reply to a note with another note? That might go a long way for improving debate and discussion.

I just tried reading some of the things written by Twitter's test authors. I immediately missed the old format. For one, the old format forces succinct points. There isn't any fluff in a Twitter thread. First four paragraphs in the sample I read:

> Hello. Hi. Do you have a moment to talk about porgs?

> Yes. Porgs, the cute things seen in Star Wars Episodes VII and VIII.

> These.

> (Image of porg)

> Many people might look at this face and see an adorable CGI workaround for the puffins on Skellig Michael, aka Ahch-To. I see a cute, charming, complete menace to the galaxy’s ecology as we know it.

A Twitter thread would have started out with something like: "Porgs, the adorable CGI workaround for puffins, are a complete menace to the galaxy's ecology as we know it."

So much more direct and to the point. Sometimes, less is more.

Re: Twitter Notes

#55
post #51

Aside, why is this shared in a very very long weird GIF and not a video. (can't pause/seek)

I was curious about this too and thought it must be a massive GIF. However it's not actually a GIF, it's an MP4 video[1], I wonder why it's mislabelled as a GIF. [1]: https://video.twimg.com/tweet_video/FV3mdpEXoAIrkA1.mp4

Calling videos without an audio track “gifs” has been done for years now.

Re: Twitter Notes

#56

I get why they have been working on this (ppl's thread posting out of control) but making longform posts content live on / inside the platform reaks of Facebook walled garden, or Medium etc. Should be encouraging ppl to have blogs or post on urls and just link to them. I dunno, it's annoying direction.

I have a feeling that one aspect of it is that with Musk potentially coming on board, they realized that the pathetic absence of new features is going to have high visibility drawn to it soon.

Just an opinion.

Re: Twitter Notes

#58

It seems that self hosted blogs are out with this new Twitter Notes feature, I can even see that Medium is pretty much in trouble here as well. Is there any point to starting a self hosted blog now that this exists for non technical people?

I think self-hosted blogs and Medium (and Substack) are in as much danger from Twitter Notes as Instagram stories were from Fleets.

Re: Twitter Notes

#59

I love that the mobile website forces me to use the app and now then you click a Note in the app it opens it in the browser.

Yeah, this was a huge benefit of threads for me! They don't break me out of twitter flow into some other website. On top of this they have barely distinguished notes from links (despite owning the platform!)

Re: Twitter Notes

#60
Now that Twitter have decided the solution to long form content is a link off the main thread hopefully more creators will feel more comfortable to instead link to their own blog rather then to "Notes". This could be a very positive thing for creators to gain back more control over their brand and content.
Post reply on HN