Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What do you do to receive honest feedback for your products?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 64 posts

Re: Ask HN: What do you do to receive honest feedback for your products?

#21

I tell people that I'm not precious about my stuff, and if something sucks I want them to tell me so that I can make it better. The other thing that I find works really well is "what is your least favorite thing about this tool?"

Yea, need to do that to get brutally honest feedback.

Re: Ask HN: What do you do to receive honest feedback for your products?

#22

> Especially when you're just starting out, and have no users yet. Add analytics, even rudimentary. Something like PostHog is good. Add monitoring (Sentry) so you catch exceptions in your code when soon to be people and systems use your product without them having to report them. You'll fix problems faster and prioritize (most frequent, most impactful, etc). Create a Slack workspace where your users could ask questio…

Thanks for the detailed answer, this is very useful.

You're welcome. You may want to take a look at Gabriel Weinberg's book entitled "Traction". Here's a playlist that's not properly ordered: https://m.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLpNwgXYhL09_afXgVjigb_k...

Re: Ask HN: What do you do to receive honest feedback for your products?

#23
Super users and dogfooding

When we started out with Quepid, we found a small handful of champions that loved the idea and advocated heavily for adopting the tool in their orgs. They became an extension of the team. We engaged with them all the time. We did everything we could to take their feedback seriously. Even if they never even converted their orgs to heavy users, their feedback was worth the high level of investment.

We also offered consulting services and would use the tool on our own projects. Here we were the customer to ourselves, and had to ensure the product was stable during engagements.

During consulting, we would train up teams on the tool. We could see where they fell in love with it and where it wasn’t a good fit.

As a SaaS product, we weren’t successful. We decided to focus on just the consulting business model. In the end Quepid became open source, and the community built around it seeded the open source community.

Re: Ask HN: What do you do to receive honest feedback for your products?

#24
post #13
post #4

Definitely lots of feedback from everyone possible. Try and have someone other than you ask in some cases, because people will be deferential and kind to you as inventor/creator. Sometimes you can get small grants to cover professional advice, which can include feedback, or sometimes there will be events where you can get such advice from experts for free. I also help run an invetors' club, and that is another good v…

Not trying to clever here but you’re missing a letter in the most interesting word. Is what you run an invester’s club, or an inventor’s club?

Inventors'!

https://www.kingstoninvents.com/

Re: Ask HN: What do you do to receive honest feedback for your products?

#25
A survey honestly helps a lot. Also Hotjar has a tool thar records users using a site. You can see people's frustrations on it.

Most people should avoid friends and family. Or rather "normies" who aren't your target market. You'll get dishonest replies by people who want to support you, people who are blindly envious, people who want to sound clever or helpful. You'll often get feedback like "this costs too much" or "this is too ugly", when your actual target market is happy for it.

Re: Ask HN: What do you do to receive honest feedback for your products?

#26

Have you read The Mom Test? Highly recommended. Here's a summary: https://www.slideshare.net/xamde/summary-of-the-mom-test The closer you are to the target user and target buyer (not necessarily the same person), the better. You can learn a lot from anyone, but it might be at a pretty abstract level and less useful. Focus as much as you can on users and buyers. Speak with them often, observe what they do often, where…

I recommend getting the actual book. Most of the summaries get some gist of it but miss the mark.

Re: Ask HN: What do you do to receive honest feedback for your products?

#27
Try to actually sell them something, that's the best way to get genuine feedback :P Until money is involved (or the hassle of account creation, I guess) it's all play to them.

Perhaps more useful answer is to be part of a practitioner community, as you noted.

Re: Ask HN: What do you do to receive honest feedback for your products?

#28
I’ve noticed that asking leading _negative_ questions opens up people a lot.

Me: “The lights are too bright, right?” (Hardware product)

User: “No they are fine but I wish the display was larger.”

I think questioning like this makes user comfortable criticising you.

Re: Ask HN: What do you do to receive honest feedback for your products?

#29

I’ve noticed that asking leading _negative_ questions opens up people a lot. Me: “The lights are too bright, right?” (Hardware product) User: “No they are fine but I wish the display was larger.” I think questioning like this makes user comfortable criticising you.

That's a brilliant tactic! May I ask where/how you learned it?

Re: Ask HN: What do you do to receive honest feedback for your products?

#30
There are a handful of web forums where people discuss the hobby that my product is related to. They're pretty frank. In addition to reading comments about my product, I also read both the praise and horror stories about other vendors, and try to form a picture in my mind of what really went wrong with the bad customer experiences.
Post reply on HN