Live data from Hacker News

Eating at your desk is banned in France

npr.org

31–40 of 85 posts

Re: Eating at your desk is banned in France

#31

As someone who regularly works 10-12 hours a day, shifting the end of the work day a further 1.5hrs sounds like a special kind of hell. I'll be sticking to my hasty desk-lunch thank you very much.

Regularly working 10-12 hours a day is more banned than eating at your desk in France, so that's not actually a problem.

Re: Eating at your desk is banned in France

#32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

IMO the bulk of this is due to workplace culture, not being remote. Naturally being at home adds some logistical flexibility, but the bulk of the gap is between companies who treat their employees like toddlers and those who actually respect them as adults (see also: dress code for non-customer-facing work, overly-fixed hours, etc). You can see this distinction in the slow creep of employee-monitoring software over t…

Disagree on that law treating employee as children. It treats employers as such. « Oh really company? you can’t have some common sense decency in regard to lunch? Alright, I will spell it out for you » From the worker side, nobody will come to say anything if you decide to put grease on your keyboard and stain your shirt during lunch time. You are free to do so.

Companies aren't people, legal fictions aside. They're machines with a fitness function which minimizes a dollar/production function.

They can't have "common sense".

Re: Eating at your desk is banned in France

#33

People with misophonia will attest that other people eating at their neighborhoods desks is extremely distracting and annoying (and not only because of noises - but smells as well) So, I'm with France on this

Oh god yes, I had a coworker next to me (on a round table) once who used to create a huge bowl of salad each day and then eat it over the course of an hour or so. It's not only noises and smells, but also the constant view of someone shoveling food into their mouth while you try to focus. He used to do that later in the afternoon, so I couldn't arrange an overlap with me being away from desk for lunch myself. Absolute nightmare. Covid home office was the best thing that ever happened to people like me.

Re: Eating at your desk is banned in France

#34

Ninety minutes, free-flowing conversation, perhaps a glass of wine Yuck. Of course it creates more productivity, they're sucking free time out of my evening and injecting into my work day. Screw that. I'm eating a sandwich at my desk in peace and then I'm going home an hour earlier than these shmucks.

France is more productive per capita (edit: the reference I found was from 2009, France is currently slightly less productive than the US per capita[1]) and has a higher quality of life than the US. Consider improving your mental model and recognizing you are not as well off and productive as you believe. Japanese workers spend a lot of time at their desks too, but not that productive! Data > emotions, work to live d…

Consider that aggregates may not scale down to every individual. Data > Statistics

Re: Eating at your desk is banned in France

#35

Ninety minutes, free-flowing conversation, perhaps a glass of wine Yuck. Of course it creates more productivity, they're sucking free time out of my evening and injecting into my work day. Screw that. I'm eating a sandwich at my desk in peace and then I'm going home an hour earlier than these shmucks.

It's also nice to spend time with the colleagues. Especially as we're only in the office one or two days a week now. I like it, though we don't spend 90 minutes but one hour. We always go to a restaurant off-site and have a 3 course meal with a beer for who wants it.

PS I'm in Spain not France but similar culture. But here you can eat at the desk if you really want to.

Also I go to France regularly and people do eat at their desks there. Some people just like to or they're forced to because of cross-timezone meetings. Like most of these protectionist laws (like not being allowed to email out of work hours) they're only for show and not actually enforced. France is a bit weird like that.

Re: Eating at your desk is banned in France

#36
Whatever they say, I’ve known plenty of people eating a sandwich at their desk in France. Some companies like to remind it’s forbidden but usually only to keep the open-spaces clean in case some high profile guy walks around and takes a look, not because they care about people needing a proper lunch break.

Re: Eating at your desk is banned in France

#37

We need more of this in America. Perhaps we just need to take the time ourselves and leave no apologies. Too many meetings get scheduled over lunch and people lose their windows of opportunity. This has somewhat shifted with remote work too and when one decides to take their lunch. I’ve started to do that at the beginning or end of the day because I know I won’t have a chance midday.

I have 12-1 blocked on my calendar every day. I will take the rare meeting in that slot (just like I'd take the rare "sit and eat with a colleague on a scheduled rather than ad-hoc basis" while we were in the office), but most days that's a meeting-free hour where I can go make lunch, walk the dog, listen to some music, or whatever suits me. Blocking your calendar is low-effort and will likely be high-payoff.

Everyone blocks their calendar off and it still happens. That’s why I commented in the first place. Respecting said hour especially working remotely with teammates in various time zones is the challenge. Add on the workplace culture and it can be even more challenging.

Re: Eating at your desk is banned in France

#38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

France is more productive per capita (edit: the reference I found was from 2009, France is currently slightly less productive than the US per capita[1]) and has a higher quality of life than the US. Consider improving your mental model and recognizing you are not as well off and productive as you believe. Japanese workers spend a lot of time at their desks too, but not that productive! Data > emotions, work to live d…

Consider that aggregates may not scale down to every individual. Data > Statistics

Also true! But we have to have an agreement on foundational facts to have a cogent debate of ideas. Preferences aren’t facts, but are still welcome.

If you want to eat at your desk while I have a 90 minute lunch with wine and good company, that’s okay, life is about choices. We are optimizing differently.

Re: Eating at your desk is banned in France

#39
Luckily my office is pretty close to downtown, so I make it a point to grab lunch out every day. And of course, it's usually with coworkers.

It adds variety to the day and I feel more connected with everybody.

If I have a string of days with lunchtime calls and I have to eat something at my desk, I'm definitely starting to feel out of sync with the company and this weird feeling of anxiety starts to set in until I'm back in the usual groove.

Re: Eating at your desk is banned in France

#40
post #25

Ninety minutes, free-flowing conversation, perhaps a glass of wine Yuck. Of course it creates more productivity, they're sucking free time out of my evening and injecting into my work day. Screw that. I'm eating a sandwich at my desk in peace and then I'm going home an hour earlier than these shmucks.

Frenchman here. I leave the office at 6pm at the latest, and I take 2 hour lunch breaks everyday. :)

Just scheduled my time off for the year, 46 days off, not counting week-ends and national holidays. Please someone save me from this oppressive regime!
Post reply on HN