Live data from Hacker News

The Last Question

en.wikipedia.org

61–70 of 169 posts

Re: The Last Question

#61
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

OMG, I loved the original scan of this, wow, flash backs for me!!! Thank you soooo much. BTW, anyone just cruising by this post, it might be just me, but the advertisements at the very end of it are so dear. Just take a peek, so funny!

Use YOUR AMAZING physic (soul) powers NOW!! Why “Develop” for years??? MONEY? HEALTH? LOVE? NOTHING IS HOPELESS. Remarkable NEW APPROACH (demonstrated by Jesus) now verified by modern science. Oy vey…

It seems archaic at first sight, but it's really not a million miles off from what I see in spam.

Re: The Last Question

#62
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>If you haven’t read it before, don’t read the Wikipedia summary; read the actual story. Read it from the original publication: https://archive.org/details/Science_Fiction_Quarterly_New_Se... >

OMG, I loved the original scan of this, wow, flash backs for me!!! Thank you soooo much. BTW, anyone just cruising by this post, it might be just me, but the advertisements at the very end of it are so dear. Just take a peek, so funny!

Notably, the science fiction magazine had ads for people who are way into their middle age.

Re: The Last Question

#63
This was the first Asimov piece I ever read. Stumbled upon it online, a simple .txt document in my browser, I read the first words, and browsed on.. Only to have them linger a few minutes, so I went back and read the entire thing and fell in love with the story and so started my adventures into science fiction reading.

Re: The Last Question

#64
The apotheosis of a machine as the restarting point of a cyclical time-loop, it must have astonished the audience especially at the time. To the best of my finite reckoning, it boils down to a pantheistic/monistic model because either the materium is eternal fundamental base reality where the [man -> machine -> god-> man] cycle plays, or there's a monad god of some sort which gave rise to the cycle, and AC/Multi-vac is a lion-snake eating its own tail, a combination of the Demiurge and Oroboros.

It's potentially also Roko's Basilisk, because if the eternally looping machine knew you are aware of it, and you tried to break the time-cycle to prevent the re-creation of itself and everything (samsara?), you could end up being punished in an endless eternal while(1){existence;}. Maybe in that sense it's like the Tenma of the sixth heaven getting in the way of those seeking to break from that cycle, but I know less about this.

In spite of these links to a deeply cyclical creation, life and existence, it starts the end speaking the words of a deity usually strongly held to have a through-and-through YOLO creation (miraculous resurrections notwithstanding).

Re: The Last Question

#65
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Use YOUR AMAZING physic (soul) powers NOW!! Why “Develop” for years??? MONEY? HEALTH? LOVE? NOTHING IS HOPELESS. Remarkable NEW APPROACH (demonstrated by Jesus) now verified by modern science. Oy vey…

It seems archaic at first sight, but it's really not a million miles off from what I see in spam.

Indeed; it actually reminded me of the weird trick discovered by my mom.

Re: The Last Question

#67

A similarly thought-provoking short story, perhaps my favorite, is The Egg[1] by Andy Weir. [1]: http://www.galactanet.com/oneoff/theegg_mod.html https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Egg_(Weir_short_story)

I read the story many years ago, but failed to grasp its meaning.

It seems to be piggybacking on themes of afterlife, karma, gods, and those typically are of interest to many. But, what kind of longer-lasting idea it tries to propose, that escapes me.

Re: The Last Question

#68
post #18
post #2

If you haven’t read it before, don’t read the Wikipedia summary; read the actual story. It’s easy to google and pretty short. Isaac Asimov said it was his favorite story he’d written. He imagines the entire history of the future of humanity, to the end of time, in a few pages. Really a marvelous story.

There is an allusion to this in a recent YouTube video on the end of the universe, and the vanishingly small timeframe that life can exist within it as we understand. Maybe this is a comfort. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=uD4izuDMUQA

"With the death of the last star, the age of starlight comes to an end"

Re: The Last Question

#70
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Damn it, I wish I read this comment before I read the summary. I had chills at the end. Maybe I should read some Asimov...

Nah, this story is just exceptionally good. Asimov was a fine writer, but this story was his crowning achievement in short fiction and he knew it too. You can read his other things and none of them will give the same feeling. Nightfall is a decent story though. But yeah, The Last Question is in a league of its own. It's one of my favorite short stories ever along with The Library of Babel by Borges, The Great Automat…

If you like these kind of "Mind blown", "Goose bumps" stories, read some Ted Chiang. Really stories that stick with you. I love this whole book: [0]

If you like a bit longer stories, try some Greg Egan. Or, his book with short stories is also really nice: [1]

[0]: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/223380.Stories_of_Your_L...

[1]: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/156783.Axiomatic

Post reply on HN