Live data from Hacker News

Cuba about to adopt the most progressive family law in the world

en.granma.cu

11–20 of 77 posts

Re: Cuba about to adopt the most progressive family law in the world

#11

[flagged]

So... they've gone from "gays go into camps" to "gays can have all the rights of family". That sounds like progress to be celebrated to me. It's sixty years later and things are getting better, hooray? I mean, any discussion of shit getting better in the USA sure has a laundry list of atrocities you can dig up too.

Yeah, gay marriage, of all places, wasn’t even legalized in California until 2008

Re: Cuba about to adopt the most progressive family law in the world

#12
post #6

To date no "most progressive family law in the world" has touched the legalization of polyamory; why so? The only thing that comes to mind is that it would become too convenient a loophole to escape taxes.

When the US legalized gay marriage (at least for now), one of the talking points against it was that men could marry their sons to avoid the inheritance tax, the same idea you are talking about. But the fact is fathers could marry their daughters and mothers could marry their sons to avoid taxes before that law was passed, yet it wasn't done. It was all just a smokescreen.

The other funny thing was that the people against gay marriage by and large were also against inheritance taxes, so you'd think they'd applaud a new loophole.

Re: Cuba about to adopt the most progressive family law in the world

#13
post #5

[flagged]

Lots of countries were doing very bad things 60 years ago. Lots of countries were doing very bad things yesterday. That shouldn't stop us from celebrating when one of those countries stops doing those bad things or makes progress to treat people more fairly.

Except that nothing has changed. People don't have the right to protest or to vote. It's still the same authoritarian government with a nice coat of pink. Coincidentally this changes very little for the islands lgbt community which is still quite persecuted (by the government no less)

Re: Cuba about to adopt the most progressive family law in the world

#14
post #6

To date no "most progressive family law in the world" has touched the legalization of polyamory; why so? The only thing that comes to mind is that it would become too convenient a loophole to escape taxes.

Abuse and violence.

Re: Cuba about to adopt the most progressive family law in the world

#15
post #6

To date no "most progressive family law in the world" has touched the legalization of polyamory; why so? The only thing that comes to mind is that it would become too convenient a loophole to escape taxes.

When the US legalized gay marriage (at least for now), one of the talking points against it was that men could marry their sons to avoid the inheritance tax, the same idea you are talking about. But the fact is fathers could marry their daughters and mothers could marry their sons to avoid taxes before that law was passed, yet it wasn't done. It was all just a smokescreen. The other funny thing was that the people ag…

> But the fact is fathers could marry their daughters and mothers could marry their sons to avoid taxes before that law was passed, yet it wasn't done.

No fathers cannot marry their children. Nor can mothers. That is illegal in every state I believe.

Re: Cuba about to adopt the most progressive family law in the world

#17
post #6

To date no "most progressive family law in the world" has touched the legalization of polyamory; why so? The only thing that comes to mind is that it would become too convenient a loophole to escape taxes.

Polyamory isn't illegal in most 'progressive' nations.

Re: Cuba about to adopt the most progressive family law in the world

#18
post #6

To date no "most progressive family law in the world" has touched the legalization of polyamory; why so? The only thing that comes to mind is that it would become too convenient a loophole to escape taxes.

Abuse and violence.

Logically I don't see how a n>2 person marriage would be more likely to be abusive than a two person marriage.

Re: Cuba about to adopt the most progressive family law in the world

#19
post #2

Maybe a more digestible resource: https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/cubans-split-over-mor... My quick read seems to me that these are things that exist in most developed Western societies today: same sex marriage, equal sharing of domestic responsibilities, prenuptial agreements, assisted pregnancy. There's probably more to it - but probably the more significant news is these concepts are taking root in Cuba?

[flagged]

Re: Cuba about to adopt the most progressive family law in the world

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Abuse and violence.

Logically I don't see how a n>2 person marriage would be more likely to be abusive than a two person marriage.

Sharing a household with a genetically unrelated adult is one of the biggest risk factors for experiencing child abuse. This is well known and well supported by evolutionary psychology: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cinderella_effect

Therefore, introducing additional genetically unrelated adults into a family would likely increase the risk of child abuse.

Post reply on HN