Live data from Hacker News

European Union leaders announced a write down of Greek bonds by 50%

money.cnn.com

11–20 of 48 posts

Re: European Union leaders announced a write down of Greek bonds by 50%

#11
Great, so German's pay for the fiscal and political indiscretion of the Greeks. I guess they had little alternative as Greece was too big to fail -or, had they been allowed to default, The German people, via German bank investments in Greece,would have lost even more --seems they didn't learn much from our Wall Street banks and saddling die Volkes with the bag.

Or do I have this wrong? I've been trying to follow this a bit..

Re: European Union leaders announced a write down of Greek bonds by 50%

#12

As someone not wholly familiar with government bonds, let me ask- does this mean that private creditors, aka individuals like you or I, are taking a 50% loss on investments? Or is this at a corporate or governmental level?

Individuals who directly hold Greek bonds aren't affected, because it's structured as a "voluntary" agreement between several large bond-holders, the European Central Bank, and Greece. Only bondholders in that group agreed to accept a 50% lower repayment, so if you personally own some Greek bonds in your brokerage account, they haven't yet defaulted. However, if you own the bonds via a fund where the bonds themselves are owned by a bank in the group, you would be affected.

Re: European Union leaders announced a write down of Greek bonds by 50%

#13
post #11

Great, so German's pay for the fiscal and political indiscretion of the Greeks. I guess they had little alternative as Greece was too big to fail -or, had they been allowed to default, The German people, via German bank investments in Greece,would have lost even more --seems they didn't learn much from our Wall Street banks and saddling die Volkes with the bag. Or do I have this wrong? I've been trying to follow this…

I'd consider this a bit of political and fiscal indiscretion of both Greeks and Germans, both relying on a similar moral hazard. German banks made stupid, risky loans, expecting that the EU wouldn't let anything go wrong, and would bail them out if it did go wrong; and Greek governments accepted the money, with the same expectations that the EU wouldn't let anything go wrong.

Re: European Union leaders announced a write down of Greek bonds by 50%

#14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

'Bond' is another word for 'promise' so you should be able to rely on it... they're supposed to be risk-free Agreed. I'd be livid right about now if I held Greek bonds. Although I suppose anyone looking for shelter in the form of government bonds could have taken the next step and diversified across nations, further reducing their exposure.

A large number of the holders (especially the foreign holders) bought the Greek bonds precisely because of the higher risk, which resulted in them having higher interest rates than, say, American or German bonds. They made a bet and lost.

Oh, I see. I was not aware of that.

Re: European Union leaders announced a write down of Greek bonds by 50%

#16
post #11

Great, so German's pay for the fiscal and political indiscretion of the Greeks. I guess they had little alternative as Greece was too big to fail -or, had they been allowed to default, The German people, via German bank investments in Greece,would have lost even more --seems they didn't learn much from our Wall Street banks and saddling die Volkes with the bag. Or do I have this wrong? I've been trying to follow this…

I'd consider this a bit of political and fiscal indiscretion of both Greeks and Germans, both relying on a similar moral hazard. German banks made stupid, risky loans, expecting that the EU wouldn't let anything go wrong, and would bail them out if it did go wrong; and Greek governments accepted the money, with the same expectations that the EU wouldn't let anything go wrong.

There's also, as I understand it, the matter of how Greece was permitted to join the Eurozone with, shall we say, overly optimistic economic reports that were blindly accepted under a set of rules that would warm a sub-prime lender's heart.

Greece made quite the mess on its own, of course, but the number of ways in which the EU has further screwed the pooch are mind-blowing.

Re: European Union leaders announced a write down of Greek bonds by 50%

#17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Both. Pension funds and the like often invest in government bonds; traditionally they're a safe investment used to hedge against riskier ones like stocks. With the latter you know there's no guarantee of performance, but you expect a risk premium in the firm of a dividend or accelerated growth. 'Bond' is another word for 'promise' so you should be able to rely on it. Saying that 'people knew the risks' of investing i…

> Saying that 'people knew the risks' of investing in bonds misses the point: they're supposed to be risk-free Given the fact that bonds regularly default, I'm not sure how any sane investor could consider them risk-free. If they were, every bond would trade at identical yields, equal to the risk-free rate of return.

Actually, until the financial crisis, all European bonds were considered to be the same risk, and were priced pretty close to the same. That was one of the reasons why Greece could load up on so much debt at good interest rates.

Re: European Union leaders announced a write down of Greek bonds by 50%

#18
post #3

It'd be interesting to see what happens next: will investors flee from Europe? Will the banks have enough to resist the loss? Must the ECB and the stability fund support banks holding greek debt? Will fear about default spread to Italy or Spain?

Basically everyone is waiting for Spain, Italy, Greece, Portugal, Ireland and Iceland to crash. None of them have, despite all the screaming and all of them will have to implode in their own sad ways, eventually. Thus, despite all the media talk about fear, drama and emotion people in the investment community are actually very unemotional and pragmatic and unfearful (I can not say they are courageuous now can I?) The…

Are you sure this applies to Iceland? My understanding is they've had their crash and are cleaning up from it.

Re: European Union leaders announced a write down of Greek bonds by 50%

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

'Bond' is another word for 'promise' so you should be able to rely on it... they're supposed to be risk-free Agreed. I'd be livid right about now if I held Greek bonds. Although I suppose anyone looking for shelter in the form of government bonds could have taken the next step and diversified across nations, further reducing their exposure.

A large number of the holders (especially the foreign holders) bought the Greek bonds precisely because of the higher risk, which resulted in them having higher interest rates than, say, American or German bonds. They made a bet and lost.

Not quite true - Greek bonds did not have significantly higher interest rates than other Euro denominated bonds.

Greek bond chart: http://www.bloomberg.com/quote/GGGB1YR:IND/chart German bond chart: http://www.bloomberg.com/quote/GDBR1:IND/chart

Go back out 3 years, and you'll see that as late as December 2009, the yield spread was minor, and that it didn't start to really diverge until July of this year.

Post reply on HN