Live data from Hacker News

Ford CEO says EVs will be sold 100% online with nonnegotiable price

usatoday.com

151–160 of 612 posts

Re: Ford CEO says EVs will be sold 100% online with nonnegotiable price

#151
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>That being said, is there any counterpoint to this view? Are there any benefits that dealerships offer today over direct sales? the only thing I can think to say is that they are still a convenient repair facility, Tesla is fairly notorious for slow turn-around for repair.[0] I think a nice middle-ground would be the conversion of dealerships into showrooms/receiving-centers/repair facilities -- oust the sales porti…

I’ll second this from a privileged position. I own a late model Land Rover, and if I take it down to the dealer to solve something, they treat me very well and put me in a very nice lounge while I wait. It’s a first class experience. I don’t think I’d get as nice attention from a non-luxury dealer though.

Every dealership I’ve ever been to has been like that.

Sometimes they’re even worth using for “normal” repairs because they will sometimes bill by the book even if the actual labor time is higher.

Re: Ford CEO says EVs will be sold 100% online with nonnegotiable price

#152
post #39

A lot has been said about the dealership model in the last few years, and the almost universal consensus is that it is an unnecessary and predatory industry and all auto makers should just sell cars directly like Tesla does. That being said, is there any counterpoint to this view? Are there any benefits that dealerships offer today over direct sales? What would we lose if we got rid of every dealership? If there is t…

The way I've heard it explained before, feel free to correct me if my facts are wrong: State sales taxes. The big 3 auto makers are all located in Michigan, USA. If they sold a vehicle direct, the sales tax dollars goes to the State of Michigan. Which means all the other states are missing out on *significant* tax dollars. To force each state to get tax dollars, local dealerships were established. That way tax dollar…

IME car sales tax are captured by the registering arm (DMV).

You absolutely pay local sales tax on amazon, not Washington salestax. Taxation is about nexus of transaction.

Re: Ford CEO says EVs will be sold 100% online with nonnegotiable price

#153
post #127
post #39

A lot has been said about the dealership model in the last few years, and the almost universal consensus is that it is an unnecessary and predatory industry and all auto makers should just sell cars directly like Tesla does. That being said, is there any counterpoint to this view? Are there any benefits that dealerships offer today over direct sales? What would we lose if we got rid of every dealership? If there is t…

When I see "No Haggle, Fixed-Price, Online Only", I think "Rip Off", and I can't be the only one. It's not that I enjoy haggling with car salesmen, walking out the door and getting hunted down in the parking lot like an animal... I don't... in fact I hate it. But at the end of the day I get a deal I'm satisfied and comfortable with - and it's always below MSRP - far below. I think what we're seeing here is a combinat…

If you believe in competition then the logical consequence will be that the no haggle MSRP will be much more competitive than the current (well pre-COVID supply chain horror) MSRP with 5% padding built in because everyone likes to haggle and think that they are getting a good deal.

Re: Ford CEO says EVs will be sold 100% online with nonnegotiable price

#154
post #94
post #39

A lot has been said about the dealership model in the last few years, and the almost universal consensus is that it is an unnecessary and predatory industry and all auto makers should just sell cars directly like Tesla does. That being said, is there any counterpoint to this view? Are there any benefits that dealerships offer today over direct sales? What would we lose if we got rid of every dealership? If there is t…

In my opinion, we lose a lot, some things practical and others societal. Practically first, when I’m in the market for a new vehicle, I’m not sure which I honestly want. I like being able to go to a dealership and find something that convinced me otherwise from what I came to originally look at it. In the most recent case, I was really wanting a truck and being able to see them in person, how I fit, etc, was what sol…

[deleted]

Re: Ford CEO says EVs will be sold 100% online with nonnegotiable price

#155
post #127

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When I see "No Haggle, Fixed-Price, Online Only", I think "Rip Off", and I can't be the only one. It's not that I enjoy haggling with car salesmen, walking out the door and getting hunted down in the parking lot like an animal... I don't... in fact I hate it. But at the end of the day I get a deal I'm satisfied and comfortable with - and it's always below MSRP - far below. I think what we're seeing here is a combinat…

Why would a fixed, online price end up being higher on average than what someone paid after haggling at a dealership. If anything, it should be lower because of (1) Reduced overhead, and (2) It is more closer to a free-market due to more transparency. Yes, there might be outliers where an extremely good haggler paid less, but that would be outweighed by a novice who paid way more, and the average has to be higher bec…

Why would Ford (or any manufacturer) offer cars on their website for cheaper than MSRP? What is their incentive?

MSRP is a suggested retail price, which is based off the manufacturer's costs + what they believe is a reasonable margin for their vendor (dealership in this case).

Ford cutting out the middle man means they can offer cars at the same exact price (MSRP in this case), but not have all the expenses dealerships have... meaning massive profit for them.

There is literally no incentive for Ford to offer the cars for less money. Plenty of people have eagerly paid $10,000+ over MSRP already - indicating they could even raise prices if they desired.

Look at Carmax as an example. Their entire business is built around the "no haggle" model - and if you know anything about the cars you are looking at, you will not find any good deals there. Everything is overpriced - but they will tell you it's their "rock bottom price" and any defects or problems have already been factored in.

It's just a sales tactic. Plenty of folks walk into a Carmax believing they're getting the best possible price without any of the hassle... just like their commercials tell you.

Re: Ford CEO says EVs will be sold 100% online with nonnegotiable price

#156
post #27

Tesla may not be the future of EVs, but we have to thank them for dragging everyone else into the present.

> Tesla may not be the future of EVs Based on what metric? I have a hard time looking at Tesla's sales, revenue, profit, production capacity growth and not thinking they will continue to be a leader in EVs far into the future.

I think they were qualifying their statement to avoid it getting sidetracked, and it still got sidetracked in the other direction!

Re: Ford CEO says EVs will be sold 100% online with nonnegotiable price

#157
post #82

This article takes an off-the-cuff comment from the CEO of Ford and reads too much into it IMO. He wasn’t saying dealerships are going away; he was actually saying the opposite. The point he was making was that Ford is going to adopt some of Tesla’s practices while using the dealership network to compete with them. Here’s the quote with more context: “I believe for retail, we have to -- it's kind of like what happene…

Selling online without negotiated price is a big change. That should make the dealerships really uncomfortable in the long run… he's kind of saying "oh the dealerships could rent out Mustangs" but is that actually realistic?

Re: Ford CEO says EVs will be sold 100% online with nonnegotiable price

#158
post #123

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But it sounds like the local middleman is getting rich at the expense of fellow-locals

There is little reason to think moving to direct sales will help anyone local, is there? I'm now convinced it is a bad idea. But I don't see it being good for local at all.

The manufacturer can set the invoice price at whatever they want already. Dealerships are only negotiating their piece of the pie, they aren't actually able to alter the core price of the vehicle. The market/competition determines what a manufacturer charges, the dealerships just obfuscate the exact figure.

So I agree with the other commentor, they exist to extract local money, to make a few locals rich, the manufacturer's piece of the pie is whatever they think they can charge either way. If you cut out dealerships you make prices less obscure and force manufacturers to compete more closely with one another, and also save the middleman rent-seeking.

Re: Ford CEO says EVs will be sold 100% online with nonnegotiable price

#159
post #39

A lot has been said about the dealership model in the last few years, and the almost universal consensus is that it is an unnecessary and predatory industry and all auto makers should just sell cars directly like Tesla does. That being said, is there any counterpoint to this view? Are there any benefits that dealerships offer today over direct sales? What would we lose if we got rid of every dealership? If there is t…

The way I've heard it explained before, feel free to correct me if my facts are wrong: State sales taxes. The big 3 auto makers are all located in Michigan, USA. If they sold a vehicle direct, the sales tax dollars goes to the State of Michigan. Which means all the other states are missing out on *significant* tax dollars. To force each state to get tax dollars, local dealerships were established. That way tax dollar…

I don’t think so.

I just bought a car from an Oregon dealership, but I live in the state of Washington, and that’s where the vehicle is registered.

Washington got every cent of sales tax from the sale, and Oregon didn’t get anything.

Re: Ford CEO says EVs will be sold 100% online with nonnegotiable price

#160
post #123

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But it sounds like the local middleman is getting rich at the expense of fellow-locals

There is little reason to think moving to direct sales will help anyone local, is there? I'm now convinced it is a bad idea. But I don't see it being good for local at all.

Well, we've recently seen dealers marking up cars insane prices, so maybe direct sales at MSRP do help keep money local.
Post reply on HN