Live data from Hacker News

Nokia Lumia 800

nokia.com

21–30 of 71 posts

Re: Nokia Lumia 800

#21
CPU seems to be MSM8255T (they didn't mention the T) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snapdragon_(system_on_chip) 1.4GHz is fast, but the OS might be slow, and certainly they have less experience in integrating it with the hardware, to make it fast.

BTW the images look like CGI mockups to me. EDIT I was wrong

Re: Nokia Lumia 800

#23

It's a great form factor, I like it very much -- it feels slimmer than the iPhone: http://versusio.com/en/nokia-lumia-800-vs-apple-iphone-4s-64... (click at the top right to view the phones in original size) I'd love it with a different OS

Why don't you get the N9 then? You can get it from Expansys if you're in USA. This form factor was designed together with the Harmattan software and Swipe UX. I'm waiting for mine to arrive.

Re: Nokia Lumia 800

#24
post #14

It's a great form factor, I like it very much -- it feels slimmer than the iPhone: http://versusio.com/en/nokia-lumia-800-vs-apple-iphone-4s-64... (click at the top right to view the phones in original size) I'd love it with a different OS

That Versio site is terrible. For start, some of its facts are just plain wrong, the 4S has 512MB RAM not 1GB. It also has HDMI mirroring and video output. Branded Lens? Who cares? Why is a bigger screen better?

Yeah, and a bunch of stuff is missing as well: resolution is not there (even though screen size is), neither is autonomy (claimed or actual, who cares about 3% more/less battery capacity when the hardware and OS are widely different?), performances (CPU and/or GPU).

And some of the claims are downright weird ("1.9 newer Bluetooth version"? Really?).

It's everything that's wrong about checklist comparisons, made even worse.

Re: Nokia Lumia 800

#25
post #9
post #6

Interesting how it has only 0.5GB of RAM. Is this meant to be Nokia's flagship Windows Phone product? As an aside, I still think Apple got it right with the single hardware "home" button vs the three in WP7 and Android.

What needs more than half a gig? The 4S copes. Going up to 1GB adds an unnecessary $9 to the BOM which eats into margins.

Biggest issue with more RAM is not money so much as battery capacity: it's very hard to gate RAM, so more ram means more transistors which are very hard to shut down, meaning lower battery capacity. And a higher surface area and more heat (assuming the manufacturing process is constant).

On a mobile device, more RAM is often a balancing act.

Re: Nokia Lumia 800

#27
post #20
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why different OS? WP7 is a great system.

Really? Let's talk about compatibility with Linux, ergo, being able to use your phone as a mass-storage device. Let's talk about compatibility with all major mobile web apps. Let's talk about the ability, or lack thereof, to detach oneself from Microsoft's ecosystem, should you decide to get a Windows Phone. Who wants to use Bing, Hotmail, or the Windows Live stuff? Let's talk about universal usage in modern society,…

1. It's a phone, not a mass-storage device.

2. Based on my experience, they work pretty well.

3. Or gmail, twitter, facebook? (although bing kinda annoys me as a default search engine)

4. Just wait for WP7 userbase to grow.

Re: Nokia Lumia 800

#28
post #8

It's a great form factor, I like it very much -- it feels slimmer than the iPhone: http://versusio.com/en/nokia-lumia-800-vs-apple-iphone-4s-64... (click at the top right to view the phones in original size) I'd love it with a different OS

You can have it with Meego, as the N9. It's almost exactly the same hardware (the N9 has an additional button).

No, Lumia has three capacitive windows buttons and physical camera button in addition to N9 hardware. N9 has buttonless interface.

Re: Nokia Lumia 800

#29
post #6

Interesting how it has only 0.5GB of RAM. Is this meant to be Nokia's flagship Windows Phone product? As an aside, I still think Apple got it right with the single hardware "home" button vs the three in WP7 and Android.

Just get the N9. 1GB of RAM and no buttons. Seems to solve your problems. Also, Lumia sells about half of the iPhone 4S price; high-end models are due in spring.

Re: Nokia Lumia 800

#30
post #21

CPU seems to be MSM8255T (they didn't mention the T) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snapdragon_(system_on_chip) 1.4GHz is fast, but the OS might be slow, and certainly they have less experience in integrating it with the hardware, to make it fast. BTW the images look like CGI mockups to me. EDIT I was wrong

Hands on video: http://www.engadget.com/2011/10/26/nokia-lumia-800-hands-on/
Post reply on HN