Live data from Hacker News

Ask YC: What do you think of my new search engine?

duckduckgo.com

111–120 of 144 posts

Re: Ask YC: What do you think of my new search engine?

#111
post #70
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I disagree, I think it has the quirkiness, the edge to actually make people use it. I also don't find it visually invasive.

I agree with you. I really like it. Worked well for me. I'm also incredibly impressed with the results. Is this a search engine grown from the ground up with its own crawler or is it using an existing dataset? If self-created this must be worth something right now

The search engine seems to have been built on top of Yahoo BOSS

Re: Ask YC: What do you think of my new search engine?

#112
post #18

Pretty impressive results for the terms I searched for. Unfortunately, the design made me temporarily go blind. In all seriousness, the name is pretty horrible and I "feel" as if I am using a website, not a tool. Google feels like a tool - I get in an out quickly, it doesn't invade my flow. Your application (and others, like Mahalo) are so visually invasive I would never use them, no matter the results that we return…

Thanks for the feedback. I would very much like it to be a "tool" as you describe. I've gone through many design iterations, and have tried to keep the "clutter" down to a minimum. I would be interested to know what specific design elements you think are contributing to this problem. I know you said it isn't really a design problem, but there has to be more to say about it :) Colors? The results on the right?

I think the font size is the most obtrusive to begin with - it's just insanely huge. I'm a Web 2.0 fan as much as the next guy and think most websites use a font size that is to small but... ouch.

I think that would be a good place to start - once you do that you may find that the mouseovers are distracting or jump around way to much now that your line-heights are smaller. Jury seems to be out on those, personally I'm not a fan but enough people said they do like them that it's a questionable change.

I think limiting the use of mouseovers could be valuable. By making off-site links (the actual SERPs) not have a mouseover while making in-site links (narrowing of categories, the more... link to activate BOSS, etc) could offer a subconcious identifier to your users as to what the next action will actually do.

Re: Ask YC: What do you think of my new search engine?

#113
post #35
post #18

Pretty impressive results for the terms I searched for. Unfortunately, the design made me temporarily go blind. In all seriousness, the name is pretty horrible and I "feel" as if I am using a website, not a tool. Google feels like a tool - I get in an out quickly, it doesn't invade my flow. Your application (and others, like Mahalo) are so visually invasive I would never use them, no matter the results that we return…

I disagree, I think it has the quirkiness, the edge to actually make people use it. I also don't find it visually invasive.

I liked it too. Particularly the fact that it shows 4 results to start & lets you extend.

Re: Ask YC: What do you think of my new search engine?

#114
post #70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree with you. I really like it. Worked well for me. I'm also incredibly impressed with the results. Is this a search engine grown from the ground up with its own crawler or is it using an existing dataset? If self-created this must be worth something right now

The search engine seems to have been built on top of Yahoo BOSS

Ahh, ok - I was completely blown away by what looked like a 1-man creation :) Indeed, I still think its great for one person to have done this. Gonna look at Yahoo! Boss now. Thanks for this

Re: Ask YC: What do you think of my new search engine?

#115

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For me, the highlight-and-underline-on-hover effect is very distracting. It would be nice if the search entry field had a stronger visual separation from the search results. There also needs to be a stronger visual separation between each search result. This might just be that I'm so heavily conditioned by Google, but I'm thrown off by the results being so far from the left edge of the screen. Also, the red, it's a l…

Regarding the "highlight-and-underline-on-hover effect", I liked that. It is really nice that the whole text area works as a link, clicking on a hit is easier. And the highlight, well, highlights that. Works for me.

Works for me too. But I would use a softer highlight.

Re: Ask YC: What do you think of my new search engine?

#116
post #70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree with you. I really like it. Worked well for me. I'm also incredibly impressed with the results. Is this a search engine grown from the ground up with its own crawler or is it using an existing dataset? If self-created this must be worth something right now

The search engine seems to have been built on top of Yahoo BOSS

Yahoo! BOSS launched on July 9, 2008: http://www.ysearchblog.com/archives/000599.html

Duck Duck Go's site says it was in development for about a year. If it was indeed built on top of BOSS, the developer must've spent 10 months doing pretty much nothing.

Post reply on HN