Live data from Hacker News

Marginalia Goes Open Source

memex.marginalia.nu

51–60 of 75 posts

Re: Marginalia Goes Open Source

#51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If I can solve the logistics, maybe. I don't have the needed bandwidth and off-site storage at this point.

What sort of sizes are we talking about? I'm thinking if it would be possible to "crowdfund" the storage-costs for a requester-pays s3 bucket for it.

I'm probably producing around 250-500 Gb data/month at this point.

Re: Marginalia Goes Open Source

#52

> I'm currently looking for hosting for a large term frequency data file that is necessary for several of the search engine's core functions. I really don't have the bandwidth to serve it myself. It's only a couple of hundred megabytes so it'll probably be solvable somehow. I have a bit of (rented) space available. Most of it on Uberspace. What are the expected traffic requirements? Contact me if you like. Will updat…

I'm not sure if it is appropriate for this use case, but wouldn't it be possible to host it on Backblaze, distribute through Cloudflare for free traffic? Or even just a torrent.

Re: Marginalia Goes Open Source

#53

Haven't there been estimates that running a globally indexed search engine product costs a billion dollars per year? As always, thank you for marginalia!

I think the helpful thing is that if you don’t intend to keep all blogspam, you are in a relatively good position.

Re: Marginalia Goes Open Source

#54

Thanks for making this open source. What about the index? Are you open sourcing that also?

If I can solve the logistics of publishing that data, then sure. In its most compressed form it's still of order 100 Gb. The intermediate goal is to have some standardized testing dataset of a couple of hundred megabytes to a gigabyte or so.

Cool. Looking forward to see the intermediate dataset.

I think you should post a ToDo list on the git repo. People can then contribute their skills.

Re: Marginalia Goes Open Source

#55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If I can solve the logistics of publishing that data, then sure. In its most compressed form it's still of order 100 Gb. The intermediate goal is to have some standardized testing dataset of a couple of hundred megabytes to a gigabyte or so.

Cool. Looking forward to see the intermediate dataset. I think you should post a ToDo list on the git repo. People can then contribute their skills.

Yeah, that's a good idea. I'm looking at a bunch of ideas for reducing the friction to contributing, still a bit of work that needs doing in that area.

Re: Marginalia Goes Open Source

#56

> I feel GitHub has taken an incredibly toxic turn with its emphasis on social features This the first time I've seen this view of GitHub, and I'm struggling to figure out what specifically he's referring to.

This is a great gift to the community, but I really wish it would be hosted where the community is active. It seems like a lot of people will miss out because they won't be able to discover this.

I find a lot of projects because I follow people on github that star or fork really neat projects. I download projects from bitbucket, gitlab, and other self-hosted instances.

I don't know that I've ever contributed a PR back as it's just a more friction-prone process. However, I've opened hundreds of PR's and Issues on github because it's already a part of my daily process.

Thanks again

Re: Marginalia Goes Open Source

#57

> I feel GitHub has taken an incredibly toxic turn with its emphasis on social features This the first time I've seen this view of GitHub, and I'm struggling to figure out what specifically he's referring to.

This is a great gift to the community, but I really wish it would be hosted where the community is active. It seems like a lot of people will miss out because they won't be able to discover this. I find a lot of projects because I follow people on github that star or fork really neat projects. I download projects from bitbucket, gitlab, and other self-hosted instances. I don't know that I've ever contributed a PR bac…

Thinking that a community lives in a git provider is a bad idea. It shouldn't matter who hosts a git instance, and I would argue it's better to fight for diversity here.

Re: Marginalia Goes Open Source

#60
post #58

What is Marginalia? Feels like a links database.

It's a grab-bag of projects geared toward internet discovery and information access.

It's got an internet search engine, a lo-fi wikipedia mirror, this thing https://search.marginalia.nu/explore/random>, and more.

Post reply on HN