Live data from Hacker News

Rank at HN: Stop saying "This."

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 37 posts

Re: Rank at HN: Stop saying "This."

#11
post #9
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

1) I'm not a college kid. 2) That is plain English.

I didn't mean you, sorry if it came across that way. I am referring to a tendency of over-embellishing that I see a lot on HN and which frankly just adds noise.

I don't like the contrived 'good sir' type of stuff (from reddit as well), but a demonstration of the full power of this language, from time to time, can be fun and creative, if it doesn't distract from the point.

Re: Rank at HN: Stop saying "This."

#12
post #2

I reflexively downvote people who do that. It's an extremely jarring abuse of the English language, and furthermore, serves absolutely no purpose, as jgrahamc points out, on a site with the possibility to either simply upvote, or comment in a more meaningful way. As an alternative, try something creative like "I completely concur with the spirit of this comment, and would like to add ...." or "The sentiments expresse…

>serves absolutely no purpose, as jgrahamc points out, on a site with the possibility to either simply upvote, or comment in a more meaningful way. //

He must have said this before he stripped comment scores off the site.

The only current way to indicate assent to anyone other than the commenter you're agreeing with is to make a short comment. "Yes" or "this" fits, is easily parsed and easily input. Until comment scores return I hope more people use this technique. It adds information that is not otherwise available.

Re: Rank at HN: Stop saying "This."

#14
post #5

Agreed with the parent and I would also like to add please consider not using periods to Make. Your. Statement. Seem. Profound.

>Agreed with the parent //

You're being ironic right? He said not to write indicating mere assent. You should _only_ have upvoted him.

Re: Rank at HN: Stop saying "This."

#16

It adds information that is not otherwise available. 'This', 'Yes' or something similar works for showing what an 'upvote' would show on an other system.

We still have upvotes.

But they are hidden from users (except for when a post is greyed out).

Re: Rank at HN: Stop saying "This."

#17
post #2

I reflexively downvote people who do that. It's an extremely jarring abuse of the English language, and furthermore, serves absolutely no purpose, as jgrahamc points out, on a site with the possibility to either simply upvote, or comment in a more meaningful way. As an alternative, try something creative like "I completely concur with the spirit of this comment, and would like to add ...." or "The sentiments expresse…

This. It's a generational thing. It's short for "this guy's got it, this guy has articulated what we are all/I am thinking". or sometimes "this is the point that must be addressed".

I don't even use "This.", but your suggestion to write "I completely concur with the spirit of.." had me falling asleep before I'd even got to the end of the sentence.

Consider this: lots of people are using the word, why not adjust to them, rather than have them adjust to you?

Re: Rank at HN: Stop saying "This."

#18
post #17
post #2

I reflexively downvote people who do that. It's an extremely jarring abuse of the English language, and furthermore, serves absolutely no purpose, as jgrahamc points out, on a site with the possibility to either simply upvote, or comment in a more meaningful way. As an alternative, try something creative like "I completely concur with the spirit of this comment, and would like to add ...." or "The sentiments expresse…

This. It's a generational thing. It's short for "this guy's got it, this guy has articulated what we are all/I am thinking". or sometimes "this is the point that must be addressed". I don't even use "This.", but your suggestion to write "I completely concur with the spirit of.." had me falling asleep before I'd even got to the end of the sentence. Consider this: lots of people are using the word, why not adjust to th…

> had me falling asleep before I'd even got to the end of the sentence.

Apologies, but I'm not interested in dumbed down conversations, and will continue to employ, and advocate the use of English from beyond a 6th grade level, as it makes for richer, more nuanced discussions.

Re: Rank at HN: Stop saying "This."

#19
post #18
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This. It's a generational thing. It's short for "this guy's got it, this guy has articulated what we are all/I am thinking". or sometimes "this is the point that must be addressed". I don't even use "This.", but your suggestion to write "I completely concur with the spirit of.." had me falling asleep before I'd even got to the end of the sentence. Consider this: lots of people are using the word, why not adjust to th…

> had me falling asleep before I'd even got to the end of the sentence. Apologies, but I'm not interested in dumbed down conversations, and will continue to employ, and advocate the use of English from beyond a 6th grade level, as it makes for richer, more nuanced discussions.

Making a sentence longer for the sake of it doesn't increase the value of a conversation.

Re: Rank at HN: Stop saying "This."

#20
post #19
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> had me falling asleep before I'd even got to the end of the sentence. Apologies, but I'm not interested in dumbed down conversations, and will continue to employ, and advocate the use of English from beyond a 6th grade level, as it makes for richer, more nuanced discussions.

Making a sentence longer for the sake of it doesn't increase the value of a conversation.

While I agree with your sentiment, I don't believe davidw wants longer sentences for the sake of length. He simply wants people to use fully formed sentences, with variety in their structure and sophistication. If you ever see some Reddit threads, you may be inclined to agree.
Post reply on HN