Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: A Reddit style site to discuss podcast episodes

podbabble.com

91–100 of 138 posts

Re: Show HN: A Reddit style site to discuss podcast episodes

#91

To give it a try i typed "sceptics" and selected Sceptics Guide to the Universe which results in redirection to https://podbabble.com/podcast/undefined and an error "Error: could not handle the request"

I got the same searching "mindscape" but tried again and it worked. I think it's a race condition in the search-as-you-type system (which also appears to have some flakiness, with searches from previous searches showing up after the latest search arrived).

Re: Show HN: A Reddit style site to discuss podcast episodes

#92

I wish your homepage made it easier to more quickly engage in podcast discussion. Right now, my feedback is that it takes too long to get to proof of value, your UI is confusing and it's not clear to me what, or how, I can get to 'discussing podcasts'.

Yes, loading is quite slow. I typed in a name and the search result showed almost instantly but it took over thirty seconds to actually get to the comment section. There's no reason you need to embed a player for the episode on the comment page. If I'm going to go to a web page and comment on a podcast I've already listened to the podcast.

There's definitely reasons for it (to easily link to clips in comments) but there's no reason to block loading the comments on loading the episode or the player

Re: Show HN: A Reddit style site to discuss podcast episodes

#93
post #83

First podcast on the right: Ben Shapiro. So I scroll down to check out the second podcast: Jordan Peterson. Not really in the mood to join such a community.

They're using some kind of API to get the podcasts since a very rare pod that I followed showed up - so maybe that's just due to the listeners that BS and JP have.

That's right. There is no sophisticated feed algorithm (yet :-). It literally just pulls the most recent comments on the platform -

Re: Show HN: A Reddit style site to discuss podcast episodes

#94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, loading is quite slow. I typed in a name and the search result showed almost instantly but it took over thirty seconds to actually get to the comment section. There's no reason you need to embed a player for the episode on the comment page. If I'm going to go to a web page and comment on a podcast I've already listened to the podcast.

There's definitely reasons for it (to easily link to clips in comments) but there's no reason to block loading the comments on loading the episode or the player

That's fair. When you are the first user to ever visit a site for an episode, we pull info from the show's RSS feed. So unfortunately we depend on the RSS feed host's response time.

But the experience around it can and should definitely be a lot smoother.

Re: Show HN: A Reddit style site to discuss podcast episodes

#95
The biggest thing missing for me getting started is a reddit-like "feed" showing where discussion is actually happening. Like the reddit logged-out homepage (/best, not /new).

The value of Podbabble is the intersection of podcast episodes that 1) people are talking about and 2) I have listened to. Right now the only way for me to find that intersection is to start from (2), searching for every podcast I can think of, looking at several of the latest episodes and seeing there's no comments. It would be great to start from (1), so I can see right away which episodes people are discussing and see which ones might be relevant to me.

Also, it seems like the only way to add a podcast to "my podcasts" is with an RSS feed link? Not from a link on the podcast's page I searched for? I'm unsure on what the desired setup workflow is.

Re: Show HN: A Reddit style site to discuss podcast episodes

#96
post #83

First podcast on the right: Ben Shapiro. So I scroll down to check out the second podcast: Jordan Peterson. Not really in the mood to join such a community.

Yeah, I'd probably not highlight political podcasts on the front page if I was going for a general audience. Risks snowballing and becoming a partisan site (I'd also not highlight, say, a Crooked Media podcast there, despite being a fan...)

Re: Show HN: A Reddit style site to discuss podcast episodes

#97
Great idea, but bad execution. UI is not good. I expected examples of popular podcasts on the front page that I could immediately engage with. However, I was met by confusion. It took me way too long to realize that the search bar was the only method of discovery.

In my opinion, this isn't even at the beta level yet, let alone at a point where you should be asking for a subscription fee that high.

I'll keep an eye on this because this interests me, but the initial red flags give me pause. You need a talented UI/UX person pretty badly.

Re: Show HN: A Reddit style site to discuss podcast episodes

#98

Great idea, but bad execution. UI is not good. I expected examples of popular podcasts on the front page that I could immediately engage with. However, I was met by confusion. It took me way too long to realize that the search bar was the only method of discovery. In my opinion, this isn't even at the beta level yet, let alone at a point where you should be asking for a subscription fee that high. I'll keep an eye on…

[deleted]

Re: Show HN: A Reddit style site to discuss podcast episodes

#100
post #28
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I didn't realise that thanks, however you still need to give people a way to delete their account.

Absolutely, of course. We've just launched and there are a number of features missing

In the times of GDPR and CCPA, there is no excuse for not having a simple way to delete your data. You should be able to revoke consent and remove your data as easily as you provided consent.
Post reply on HN