Live data from Hacker News

GoodWill ransomware forces victims to donate to the poor

cloudsek.com

141–150 of 366 posts

Re: GoodWill ransomware forces victims to donate to the poor

#141
post #88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’ve met tons of script kiddies over the years and none of them were concerned about employment. They do what they do just to show that they can.

>I’ve met tons of script kiddies over the years and none of them were concerned about employment. Your sample is probably biased in some way. I've met many who feel trapped in wage slavery, here in the USA.

Most I’ve known do it for the lols. This trait makes them really bad at holding down a good job.

Re: GoodWill ransomware forces victims to donate to the poor

#142

Tangentially, I dislike strongly when people record videos of themselves doing "goodwill" for others—especially for social media; it always reeks [to me] of insincerity. Not to mention the often unwanted spotlight it casts onto the receiver of said goodwill. If one cares, one does acts of goodwill privately, without thinking about how others will react—including and especially—on the internet. "The true test of a man…

I actually think the complete opposite, there is so little good in the world that doing it to boost your ego or getting viewers on YouTube it's as good reason as any, and it can influence others to do the same, we learn pretty much everything by imitation, why would being good be any different? That guy who went viral for recording himself picking tons of litter without doubt made thousands of people think before littering and his actions have had a more positive impact than most people on this site.

I only had to sleep in the streets one single cold night, I wouldn't have mind in the slightest to be filmed thanking the helper in exchange for a warm room, I definitely would had feel I got the upper hand on such "deal".

Re: GoodWill ransomware forces victims to donate to the poor

#143

This thing was written by someone who doesn't live in a developed country... There's no way to do those actions in a developed country. Does this person think that just random children are available to be given food to?

People generally accept free stuff. Kids aren't some exception to this. You can accomplish this in any developed country with minor effort imo. Have any kids even distantly in your family? Kids know other kids so ask them to invite friends. "less fortunate" is a very broad descriptor for the children you need to feed, especially if you're fortunate.

Depending on the context you could probably give away pizzas pretty easily/innocently. Walking up to some children you do not know and offering to take them to a secondary location in return for free food… would come across very differently

Re: GoodWill ransomware forces victims to donate to the poor

#144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can just as well say that property is coercion. Like I get that you won't agree, but you are asserting a value system when you do that.

taking something with the threat of force is not the same as owning something that you traded for in a mutually agreed upon transaction

There still needs to be an initial act of taking by force to set up the initial ownership, creating the possibility of trade.

Re: GoodWill ransomware forces victims to donate to the poor

#146

This thing was written by someone who doesn't live in a developed country... There's no way to do those actions in a developed country. Does this person think that just random children are available to be given food to?

No post body was provided.

Re: GoodWill ransomware forces victims to donate to the poor

#147

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's the specifics that give it away. "Take 5 poor children from your neighborhood to Pizza Hut." Screaming kids at Pizza Hut aside, we can't make other people have empathy. They have to find it and explore it themselves, perhaps by seeing others do the same. It's especially ironic that someone with lowered empathy would be demanding someone else show fake empathy publicly before giving them back control of their own…

I just can imagine how I'd convince 5 kids to go to lunch with me, without outright kidnapping them. This sounds like Black Mirror material.

Convince or not, I'm thinking you might attract some really personal attention from law enforcement by the time you made your pitch to the 5th kid.

Or maybe you happen to be a 97-year-old retired nun, who everyone in your neighborhood knows, and it'd be fine. Not trying to be judgemental or anything.

Re: GoodWill ransomware forces victims to donate to the poor

#148
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Quoted post unavailable.

Nobody gets arrested for buying pizza for a bunch of kids.

Maybe not arrested, but you are pretty likely to have an unpleasant interaction with the police at a minimum if you're walking up to kids and asking them to come with you. Honestly the best way to do this (as in least likely to interact with the police) in the U.S. would be to hire actors -- which would feel awfully scummy to me, but that's honestly the safest way to do it.

Now, if it asked you to buy some pizzas and just hand them to some less fortunate kids, you could probably do that without interacting with the police. You'd still need to be careful, but it could probably be done.

Re: GoodWill ransomware forces victims to donate to the poor

#149
post #23

Can I assume that the author of this ransomware is American or at least is very immersed in American culture? Because the activities listed sound very America-centric. I've never seen someone actually sleeping roadside in the cold, and since we have universal healthcare, I've also not heard of someone dying in the hospital because their loved ones couldn't gather up enough money. I guess I might as well just smash my…

> Can I assume that the author of this ransomware is American or at least is very immersed in American culture?

No, they sound like someone who learned about the US from internet memes, but doesn’t have firsthand experience. For example, hospitals in the US do not generally collect payment at the time of treatment so it wouldn’t really make much sense to show up to one and try to pay for someone needing urgent medical care

Re: GoodWill ransomware forces victims to donate to the poor

#150

This thing was written by someone who doesn't live in a developed country... There's no way to do those actions in a developed country. Does this person think that just random children are available to be given food to?

Do you mean US?
Post reply on HN