Live data from Hacker News

A group of open source Android apps without ads or unnecessary permissions

simplemobiletools.com

41–50 of 173 posts

Re: A group of open source Android apps without ads or unnecessary permissions

#41
post #12

Note that some of these apps, the one that have "Pro" at the end, are not free (they cost $0.99). Here is the announcement by the author of the apps: https://tibbi.medium.com/some-simple-mobile-tools-apps-are-b...

Considering they're free (software; GPL), I'm surprised no one went full jerk mode and put them on store for free (ware; 0$).

Re: A group of open source Android apps without ads or unnecessary permissions

#42
I am a heavy user of f-droid and avoid these 'Simple' apps. The high level of nag is not just annoying but borders on begging. Having pro versions where you can change colors defeats the idea of open source. I hate bringing the negative energy, but there is a treasure of apps available with f-droid other than these. I am glad they have their own website and wish they just went and did their own thing there.

Re: A group of open source Android apps without ads or unnecessary permissions

#44
post #42

I am a heavy user of f-droid and avoid these 'Simple' apps. The high level of nag is not just annoying but borders on begging. Having pro versions where you can change colors defeats the idea of open source. I hate bringing the negative energy, but there is a treasure of apps available with f-droid other than these. I am glad they have their own website and wish they just went and did their own thing there.

> Having pro versions where you can change colors defeats the idea of open source

Do you have any other ways the developer can make a living?

AFAIK the pro features (excluding the closed source 3rd party SDKs) are all open source. You can build them on your own or download it off F-Droid.

Re: A group of open source Android apps without ads or unnecessary permissions

#45
post #4
post #2

https://github.com/SimpleMobileTools And of course, you should install these from F-Droid, not Google Play

Why?

I'm guessing because of what's mentioned here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31491321

TLDR: Their Calendar app became "not free" and you needed to pay to get notifications or alerts, but only if you downloaded from the Play Store. It's still completely free on f-droid

Re: A group of open source Android apps without ads or unnecessary permissions

#46
post #42

I am a heavy user of f-droid and avoid these 'Simple' apps. The high level of nag is not just annoying but borders on begging. Having pro versions where you can change colors defeats the idea of open source. I hate bringing the negative energy, but there is a treasure of apps available with f-droid other than these. I am glad they have their own website and wish they just went and did their own thing there.

Wait, are you saying even the F-Droid versions nag you? I've never seen that.

Re: A group of open source Android apps without ads or unnecessary permissions

#47

I still have old Android phones that I'm not using because of outdated kernels/OS versions and their disadvantages in terms of vulnerabilities, but given the hardware is completely fine I would use them as offline general purpose tools if I had an easy way to install old store apps in them. So does anybody know if there is perhaps an archive of old APK app files (old as in Android KitKat and earlier)?

back when Yalp Store was working, it would let you decrement version numbers. if the author hadn't removed them from the play store and you guessed correctly, you could download older versions. i think sites like apkmirror also provide older versions.

APKmirror does allow you to download older versions. APKMirror started in 2014 so they may have versions of some apps which are old enough to work on KitKat, released in 2013, and older.

Re: A group of open source Android apps without ads or unnecessary permissions

#48
post #42

I am a heavy user of f-droid and avoid these 'Simple' apps. The high level of nag is not just annoying but borders on begging. Having pro versions where you can change colors defeats the idea of open source. I hate bringing the negative energy, but there is a treasure of apps available with f-droid other than these. I am glad they have their own website and wish they just went and did their own thing there.

Free in FOSS "as in free speech, not free beer."

As far as pro version is opensourced, distributed under free license and fully auditable, there is nothing defeating the idea of open source.

Re: A group of open source Android apps without ads or unnecessary permissions

#50

I made a free shopping list app its not open source as ive lost the source...I made this about 10 years ago. Play store basically shadow bans completely free apps from small developers without adverts as far as i can tell. This is the app https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.flabbyfish...

Do you have some evidence of that or is this rather a feeling of yours? (Genuinely interested)
Post reply on HN