Live data from Hacker News

Ly – A TUI Display Manager

github.com

21–26 of 26 posts

Re: Ly – A TUI Display Manager

#21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm interested in trying this out with i3. I've only just started using i3 and the default lightdm display manager (on NixOS) looks and feels out-of-place with it. Ly seems to be a logical next step.

Are you the only user? Do you always use i3? If yes to both, you could have your bashrc (or you shell's equivalent) start X and i3 on a TTY login? https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/Xinit#Autostart_X_at_login

Is this an approach that works well with screen locking, or is a display manager really necessary for that feature?

Re: Ly – A TUI Display Manager

#22
post #3

I envy nice display managers, they're the nostalgia for me. I'm not using one for a long time, thanks to disk encryption and auto-login.

> disk encryption and auto-login.

How does this work? I'd think that auto-login is a convenience that reduces security, and disk encryption would only be meaningful with some factor of authentication?

Re: Ly – A TUI Display Manager

#23
post #3

I envy nice display managers, they're the nostalgia for me. I'm not using one for a long time, thanks to disk encryption and auto-login.

> disk encryption and auto-login. How does this work? I'd think that auto-login is a convenience that reduces security, and disk encryption would only be meaningful with some factor of authentication?

You need to enter the key to decrypt the disk during the boot process, so having another password just to login is slightly unnecessary unless you have multiple users on the device

Re: Ly – A TUI Display Manager

#24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are you the only user? Do you always use i3? If yes to both, you could have your bashrc (or you shell's equivalent) start X and i3 on a TTY login? https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/Xinit#Autostart_X_at_login

Is this an approach that works well with screen locking, or is a display manager really necessary for that feature?

You don't need display manager to lock screen in i3. Just run or bind a key to run i3lock (or other lockers like slock)

Re: Ly – A TUI Display Manager

#25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> disk encryption and auto-login. How does this work? I'd think that auto-login is a convenience that reduces security, and disk encryption would only be meaningful with some factor of authentication?

You need to enter the key to decrypt the disk during the boot process, so having another password just to login is slightly unnecessary unless you have multiple users on the device

i wanted to do this too, but I have to enter my password to unlock my key manager (ie: seahorse on gnome), any way to work around this?

Re: Ly – A TUI Display Manager

#26

1- Tangential, Why "login manager" is called display manager in Linux-speak? 2- Isn't it better to use a login manager that is 1- graphical and 2- uses the same GUI tech as your DE (for example gtk for xfce/gnome and qt for KDE) so the actual GUI apps could be hot-loaded in memory and the initial cold-runs of programs could be faster? Thanks for the project. Seems clean.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN