Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: 6-hour workdays more important than 4-day workweeks IMO

news.ycombinator.com

241–250 of 312 posts

Re: Ask HN: 6-hour workdays more important than 4-day workweeks IMO

#241
post #24

Why not both? 4 days, 6 hours each. Hey employers reading this. Having a hard time finding software engineers? Offer me this and I will come running. I’ll be banging on your door with my resume. Think about it.

Too bad companies don't know how to hire, and will disqualify you when the first micro-flaw is found. So people running in with their resume makes no difference.

Re: Ask HN: 6-hour workdays more important than 4-day workweeks IMO

#243
post #230

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think they just explained it in their comment… your coworkers are your friends. I think the flip side of what you’re saying is, why would you not want to be friends with the people you spend 8+ hours a day with during the workweek?

And if you get fired, you get fired from being friends with them too? I certainly want to be able to get along with my coworkers, but it's not quite the same thing as being friends. There are few former coworkers that I keep in touch with after I leave a job. I tend to have my friends outside work. And my family too.

I mean I am an American, and I live my life in accordance with American norms.

I just am pointing out how cultural differences lead to different perspectives. I would imagine that Chinese corporate culture around layoffs is also very different from how it is in America.

It’s really difficult to comprehend all of the small details that go into living within a different culture, and isolated components end up seeming bizarre, while they are perfectly logical when you live within the system itself.

Re: Ask HN: 6-hour workdays more important than 4-day workweeks IMO

#244
Working from home has immensely increased the value of the lunch hour and my afternoon productivity. Spending an hour in my home, whether in the kitchen or just relaxing, recharges me in ways that sitting in the company cafeteria or in my cube never could. Even when I worked at jobs that had a nice park nearby, it simply didn't compare to the decompression and mind clearing that I get from a midday hour at home. Six hours in an office would easily collide with my point of declining productivity but at home I'm still going good at the end of the day.

This is of course dependent on each individual's needs and circumstances. My manager has three kids that need feeding at lunchtime for several weeks at the end of and beginning of the school year because his wife is an assistant principal so the kids get a longer summer break than she does. He seems a bit frazzled after lunch during those periods.

Re: Ask HN: 6-hour workdays more important than 4-day workweeks IMO

#246
post #226
post #55

So I am seeing more and more of ideas like this; but I feel the need to challenge them a bit. Not the ideal; work less, have more fulfilling lives - I am all in. But all of these initiatives are focused on the wealthier office workers and sometimes factory/shift workers who are non-customer facing. But it totally ignores the service industry which is a huge part of our society (and arguably even more so if we end up…

Thanks for this. There is a bit of tone deafness in this thread with everyone calling for fewer days of work so they can relax and then go to the cafe or linger over dinner while also wanting all those businesses to be open for them at all times. If we want to change the societal norms around working hours it has to include everyone, not just software developers or else it isn't going to stick. Though honestly this t…

Service folks almost always work in shifts already, many are part time. One of the benefits of moving up the ladder is to get holidays off. I think this is the only way it could possibly work.

Agree that most people should have say, Sunday off, but there are many import things that must have 24/7 or close to it coverage. Groceries (every day), medical personnel, firefighters, etc. Lot's of nurses work 3*12hr shifts per week for example.

Re: Ask HN: 6-hour workdays more important than 4-day workweeks IMO

#247

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hire based on working style.

This is a really great way to introduce systemic neurodivergency filters and expose a greater surface area for unfair hiring practice lawsuits.

Normal working conditions are a neurodivergence filter.

Re: Ask HN: 6-hour workdays more important than 4-day workweeks IMO

#248

Meanwhile in China... Excerpts below taken from the website https://996.icu/#/en_US What is "996"? 996 working, ICU waiting. A "996" work schedule refers to an unofficial work schedule (9a.m. ~ 9p.m., 6 days a week) that has been gaining in popularity. Serving a company that encourages the "996" work schedule usually means working for at least 60 hours a week. In early September 2016, it was said that 58.com (58同城, a…

Jack Ma said 996 was a blessing. Then he said other things that pissed off the wrong people and has not been seen since then.

Guys like Jack Ma consider being awake to be working. It's how a former CEO of mine justified his 10 week a year vacation schedule with 2.5 day work weeks. The man would walk into the office after a weekend at around 11:30am on a Tuesday to select a few employees to eat lunch with, and then make up for his missed work by staying until 7:30 on Thursdays.

Re: Ask HN: 6-hour workdays more important than 4-day workweeks IMO

#249
post #207

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Another thing to look into is whether you have snoring / sleep apnea. Most people who do, it seems, are not aware of it. 2 easy, objective tests: 1) Ask your sleeping partner, if you have one, if you snore. 2) Record yourself sleeping. I used an app called SnoreLab which does audio analysis to give you a numerical rating and pulls clips of likely snoring moments so you don't have to scrub through the entire night's r…

I often snore when I sleep on my back. So I always sleep on my belly and don't snore. This developed before I even finished high school. I have never been (and am not) even slightly overweight.

Weight is often a cause but is not necessary to produce apnea. The human breathing apparatus is just weird.

I'm glad you have a way to prevent snoring. But I wonder if sleeping on your belly isn't also bad for your sleep. Everything I've read recommends side sleeping for back-snorers. I've seen some sources say belly sleeping is bad for you as well.

In any case, good luck on your health journey

Re: Ask HN: 6-hour workdays more important than 4-day workweeks IMO

#250
post #55

So I am seeing more and more of ideas like this; but I feel the need to challenge them a bit. Not the ideal; work less, have more fulfilling lives - I am all in. But all of these initiatives are focused on the wealthier office workers and sometimes factory/shift workers who are non-customer facing. But it totally ignores the service industry which is a huge part of our society (and arguably even more so if we end up…

> You will still want an Uber after 5pm,

No, I don't.

I want a way to get where I want to go after 5pm, sure, but reduced working hours means, necessarily, that for a greater portion of the population than is currently the case, that will not be an individual, human-driven conveyance per party seeking transportation, and that's fine.

> 4 Day work weeks, shorter hours - all great ideas but all ideas that either negatively impact the poorest portion of our society.

No, they don't. Your argument that they do is based on the assumption that they are not applied to that group, which is odd because they are exactly the group (unlike elite workers who are generally exempt) to whom wage and hour laws apply.

> or a shop or restaurant to be open on a public holiday.

Actually, I want far fewer shops and restaurants open on public holidays, of which I would like to see more than currently exist.

> Even universal basic income, which ostensibly would have a positive impact there would still not allow those individuals to work less.

Yes, it will. It would drive up the costs for the wealthier people that would like the things provided by them working as much as they currently do, which would lead to a mix of reductions I working hours and downward movement of wealth, both of which benefit the poorer workers.

> Which is why my challenge is always; first we need to automate out the poorest roles in society (and then give them UBI obviously) before we solve our own lengthy work weeks.

That's backwards. We change the general workweek standards (which aren't, after all, hard limits but when, for non-exempt workers, extra costs for the employer and extra pay for the worker in the form of mandatory overtime compensation kick in), and establish UBI funded by taxes on capital income, and then the resulting pressure on labor costs drives automation, with the increasing pre-tax aggregate returns to capital as labor is minimized in production increasing the UBI funding bucket.

Post reply on HN