Live data from Hacker News

Total Commander forced to stop letting you install APKs

androidpolice.com

11–20 of 92 posts

Re: Total Commander forced to stop letting you install APKs

#11
post #2

Alternative app that's not encumbered by the Play Store's rules: https://f-droid.org/en/packages/com.ghostsq.commander/

You can also download the Total Commander APK from its own site[0] which includes that functionality, as mentioned in the forum post linked by the article this is only for the Play Store version.

[0] https://www.ghisler.ch/board/viewtopic.php?t=76644

Re: Total Commander forced to stop letting you install APKs

#12

I'm confused, I thought the ability to install apps outside of Play is supported by the OS. In fact there's a permissions dialog that pops up when an app tries to install another app. This is critical functionality for, say, the FDroid app store, as well as the browser, which is how most people would acquire FDroid. Seems like a bad omen.

Basically google doesn't allow app store competitors on their own app store.

Re: Total Commander forced to stop letting you install APKs

#13
post #2

Alternative app that's not encumbered by the Play Store's rules: https://f-droid.org/en/packages/com.ghostsq.commander/

Its functionality is hindered by Google in that it can not download and install updates in background as Google Play does. One has to root the phone and loose access to banking and SSO apps to get enough permissions for F-Droid. EU anti-competition monkeys should have looked at that a long time ago.

My OnePlus 6 is rooted (with Magisk) and I do banking with it all the time.

Re: Total Commander forced to stop letting you install APKs

#15

I am curious why Total Commander is the only one that is signaled out? There are thousand apps that are capable of doing this and TC is the only one that Google have an issue with. I feel that there is something more to the story. I read the article and Dev seemingly didn't do anything wrong but yet something fishy going on since Solid Explorer, F-Droid, Firefox, etc does not receive those notice from Google AFAIK.

Yeah if this was "just" a file manager that could potentially download APKs if you paste in a direct URL or connect to a file share then there's no way automated testing would have flagged this. The changelog seems to mention a "backup/restore" feature for APKs which seems different than just triggering an open intent.

Re: Total Commander forced to stop letting you install APKs

#17
The logical conclusion of applying this rule evenly is a scenario where you can't install apps except via the Play store, even if third party app installation is technically "allowed" on paper, because you can't actually install an app that will install apps. This is (yet another) stupid decision by Google, and Hanlon's Razor might not apply since they have a vested interest in the Play store being the only place to get Android apps.

"Of course the OS allows you to install third-party apps. We totally respect your freedom! Now, you'll have to install those with a third party installer, which aren't allowed on the Play store. And any app that would allow you to download and install the third party installer also isn't allowed."

A file manager which opens files should be allowed to open APK files.

Re: Total Commander forced to stop letting you install APKs

#19

I am curious why Total Commander is the only one that is signaled out? There are thousand apps that are capable of doing this and TC is the only one that Google have an issue with. I feel that there is something more to the story. I read the article and Dev seemingly didn't do anything wrong but yet something fishy going on since Solid Explorer, F-Droid, Firefox, etc does not receive those notice from Google AFAIK.

Maybe they've deployed some new scanning tools. Looks like google thinks the code is used by TC to update itself.

Re: Total Commander forced to stop letting you install APKs

#20
post #2

Alternative app that's not encumbered by the Play Store's rules: https://f-droid.org/en/packages/com.ghostsq.commander/

Its functionality is hindered by Google in that it can not download and install updates in background as Google Play does. One has to root the phone and loose access to banking and SSO apps to get enough permissions for F-Droid. EU anti-competition monkeys should have looked at that a long time ago.

I use something called Insular[1] to install some apps in a work profile so they don't have access to my personal contacts and activity.

A nice unexpected benefit has been that Insular does background installations and updates of APKs. When I click "update" in f-droid, I now choose Insular as the handler and it happens in the background. It's much more reliable than however f-droid does it internally.

[1] https://secure-system.gitlab.io/Insular/

Post reply on HN