Live data from Hacker News

Tell HN: I probably spend more on piracy than if I just paid for content

news.ycombinator.com

141–150 of 415 posts

Re: Tell HN: I probably spend more on piracy than if I just paid for content

#141

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In what sense is data hoarding a problem? I’ve only ever heard the term used in jest, at least partially, and in particular not ever with the same severity that actual hoarding receives.

Well it's costing this guy $45 a month apparently.

$45 a month is a pretty cheap vice as far as things go, though.

You could easily be spending $45 a month just on streaming services.

Re: Tell HN: I probably spend more on piracy than if I just paid for content

#142

For more of this/more people like OP, see /r/datahoarder

Yep, I'm subscribed.

I also do some digital archiving work (I don't want to get into specifics for anonymity sake), but since that's text it only takes up about 12TB right now. If I run out of space I delete some video.

Re: Tell HN: I probably spend more on piracy than if I just paid for content

#143
In the 80s/90s, I pirated a lot of software for Amiga/PC, because it was either unavailable or expensive for me.

Nowadays I don't bother pirating anything, for two reasons:

a) I don't feel comfortable any more to steal money from others, b) there is nothing out there to make me want it so badly. Everything looks so mediocre...

Re: Tell HN: I probably spend more on piracy than if I just paid for content

#144
post #128

Here in Germany, it is almost impossible to pirate for free . If you download shows via BitTorrent you almost immediately get a fine ("Abmahnung"). There are some illegal streaming sites, but quality and reliability is poor in my experience. But you can get a subscription to a VPN for about the same price as a Netflix subscription (~10€/month), that will allow you to torrent without worring about getting caught. Stra…

Torrents have been out of favor for a while. The pros are using Usenet subscriptions and a Usenet indexer (search engine) combined with Plex and automated tools such as NZBGet and Sonarr. I doubt the Usenet subscription would trigger any fines. This isn’t like torrents where some seeder could be giving IPs to whoever sends you the Abmahnung fines.

>Torrents have been out of favor for a while.

Have they? Because it seems to me from my sample size of friends (say 20) that torrent+VPN is definitely the preferred method, way over usenet.

Usenet seems to be for people who are trying to download EVERYTHING (like OP was originally complaining about) instead of just watch movies occasionally.

Re: Tell HN: I probably spend more on piracy than if I just paid for content

#145
post #95
post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you're buying secondhand DVD's, and I don't see how you aren't because who's still producing DVD's (or even, who's producing Blurays for older content), then you're on the same level as people who pirate from the eyes of publishers and media conglomerates. You might feel better about yourself, but it's a quirk of history that they haven't been able to make secondhand sales illegal.

You'd be surprised, lots of content is still available as new on places like Amazon, especially if you broaden to outside the US.

Actually, you're entirely right. I don't know why I thought they stopped printing DVDs for new releases.

Re: Tell HN: I probably spend more on piracy than if I just paid for content

#146
post #132

What you’re describing is data hoarding. I pirate a ton too, but you know what I do with a movie or TV show after I’ve watched it? I delete it. Poof, gone. But it’s still in the most important dataset I have. My memory. To help with the metadata of my own memory, I write down a list of the films I’ve seen. I only keep the movies I really love and want to rewatch (Robocop). That TV show I just finished that was great…

I rewatch things all the time. If I’m doing side work at night and just want something on the background I’ll put on a movie or show that I’ve seen before. Beyond that, hard drives are cheap! I have a single 18 TB disk in my main computer that runs Plex. It lets me and my kids watch content from anywhere with an Internet connection. 18 TB hard drives are about $300.

A single terabyte can hold at least 500 hours of 1080p video. A few terabytes is plenty to keep a large library of rewatchable content AND download new stuff frequently (and delete it when you need room)

Re: Tell HN: I probably spend more on piracy than if I just paid for content

#147

What you’re describing is data hoarding. I pirate a ton too, but you know what I do with a movie or TV show after I’ve watched it? I delete it. Poof, gone. But it’s still in the most important dataset I have. My memory. To help with the metadata of my own memory, I write down a list of the films I’ve seen. I only keep the movies I really love and want to rewatch (Robocop). That TV show I just finished that was great…

In what sense is data hoarding a problem? I’ve only ever heard the term used in jest, at least partially, and in particular not ever with the same severity that actual hoarding receives.

Like all "problems", it's only a problem if it has negative consequences for you. Drinking alcohol isn't a problem until it is. Collecting old newspapers isn't a problem until it is. Hoarding data isn't a problem until it is.

This post seems a bit tongue-in-cheek, but if it's costing the OP more money than they'd like to spend on it, then it is a problem. Or maybe it's not.

Re: Tell HN: I probably spend more on piracy than if I just paid for content

#148

What you’re describing is data hoarding. I pirate a ton too, but you know what I do with a movie or TV show after I’ve watched it? I delete it. Poof, gone. But it’s still in the most important dataset I have. My memory. To help with the metadata of my own memory, I write down a list of the films I’ve seen. I only keep the movies I really love and want to rewatch (Robocop). That TV show I just finished that was great…

In what sense is data hoarding a problem? I’ve only ever heard the term used in jest, at least partially, and in particular not ever with the same severity that actual hoarding receives.

When it causes undesired effects like spending more on hardware than you probably should.

Re: Tell HN: I probably spend more on piracy than if I just paid for content

#150

What you’re describing is data hoarding. I pirate a ton too, but you know what I do with a movie or TV show after I’ve watched it? I delete it. Poof, gone. But it’s still in the most important dataset I have. My memory. To help with the metadata of my own memory, I write down a list of the films I’ve seen. I only keep the movies I really love and want to rewatch (Robocop). That TV show I just finished that was great…

In what sense is data hoarding a problem? I’ve only ever heard the term used in jest, at least partially, and in particular not ever with the same severity that actual hoarding receives.

Using a lot of resources so that one person has a bunch of digital information they'll never use or see again. It's a bit of a waste don't you think?
Post reply on HN