Live data from Hacker News

Crowdsource by Google

crowdsource.google.com

31–40 of 142 posts

Re: Crowdsource by Google

#31

So this helps improve Google’s proprietary products. But they aren’t willing to open source the data set?

According to this page, they have already open sourced some datasets: https://crowdsource.google.com/about/open-source/

But they say nothing about it in the linked announcement.

> Help Google create AI that understands your language and culture. Make your favorite apps and services even more useful and delightful for your community.

Re: Crowdsource by Google

#32

Because calling it "free labour" just wouldn't attract quite as many people... Perhaps ~2 decades ago I would've been a bit more optimistic, but now that I'm aware of the authoritarian dystopia which Google and the rest of Big Tech are trying to drive society towards, I feel obliged to point out that helping it achieve that goal is a really bad idea.

Free labor is all that is being pedaled in most of these projects... It really worries me about our future as a planet.

It's crazy how many people jump on doing surveys for free , and even in creating content for social platforms daily for free, because it's promoted by billion dollar profit companies that could easily hire and pay people while still making good profit.

The free labor economy is insanely out of control now, and accurate truths about the exploitation and data mining never will be discussed because these companies can easily suppress and downvote them. I don't do any surveys, haven't since before the Cambridge Analytica story.

Re: Crowdsource by Google

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That blog post doesn't state that _all_ collected data through Crowdsource will get published.

Do you really want raw, unmoderated user generated content?

Yes! They can provide both filtered & unfiltered data.

Re: Crowdsource by Google

#36
post #8

Now let's imagine it's fun enough so that people don't see it as free labor, but see it as genuine entertainment, like, say, Wordle. How would they weed out bad-faith players who would try to teach the AI bad ideas, just for, well, fun of it? I don't believe they might fail to anticipate that; I want to understand their approach.

If you ask enough people the same question, it's easy to identify and drop outlier answers.

That depends how political the question is.

Re: Crowdsource by Google

#37
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not really, you can't get child labor on MTurk (officially). But hey, you get badges, and you help the community by providing them training data they'll lock up in a server and use to monopolize more sectors of the economy. Everyone wins when google can do better sentiment analysis on your non-english emails.

Quoted post unavailable.

[deleted]

Re: Crowdsource by Google

#38

I was expecting to be pessimistic, but Google actually releases the datasets under a permissive license (CC-By 4.0). Awesome! https://research.google/tools/datasets/open-images-extended-... https://github.com/google-research-datasets/hiertext

Would this be compatible with importing into OpenStreetMap and similar open data projects?

Re: Crowdsource by Google

#39
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not really, you can't get child labor on MTurk (officially). But hey, you get badges, and you help the community by providing them training data they'll lock up in a server and use to monopolize more sectors of the economy. Everyone wins when google can do better sentiment analysis on your non-english emails.

Quoted post unavailable.

Your aggressive tone is completely inappropriate, especially considering that you are mostly wrong. They have released a single dataset, and specifically state on the site that only some of the data will be open sourced. So, perhaps it is you who should be reading further.

"Google shares some Crowdsource data via open-sourcing, for the benefit of the global research and developer communities. This includes the 400,000 images that we've already released as Open Images Extended, with more sharing to come."

https://crowdsource.google.com/about/how-it-works/

Re: Crowdsource by Google

#40

They should avoid using the word community, if side product of these contributions are going to empower their sales. I had been contributing to Google Maps for more than 8 years now, but in return all i get is stars and maximum an invite to a meetup. But, when i saw the other side of Google Maps with respect to consuming it through API usage point of view, the prices are not affordable in long term. Also, there is a…

You should put your efforts into open street map instead
Post reply on HN