Live data from Hacker News

Singapore Government Tech Stack

developer.tech.gov.sg

21–30 of 104 posts

Re: Singapore Government Tech Stack

#21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I feel dictators/autocrats come in two flavors. The first genuinely feel they know what is best for the country and how to best govern it. They might still enrich themselves and their cronies in the process of course. The second are primarily out to enrich themselves and their cronies. The country exists to support this selfish goal. Of course this is not black and white, but rather a spectrum but various historical…

And history repeatedly shows that even if you get a dictator of the first kind, it’s an unstable equilibrium of a system that eventually leads to a dictator of the second kind.

And that can happen with the same person !

Re: Singapore Government Tech Stack

#22
post #18
post #17

Let’s not forget the whole fiasco with Singapore’s TraceTogether app for contact tracing during the pandemic. The actual implementation of it differs significantly from the white paper they open-sourced. The actual app does not anonymize the data and the government has access to everyone’s location and interaction data. Initially, their privacy policy promised the data would only be used for tracking of the spread of…

Good thing the United States has a constitutional amendment that totally protects us from having our location data harvested sold and deanonymized by thousands of data brokers!

This practice should extend to the private sector in my opinion. Protection of location data should fall under the 14th amendment.

Re: Singapore Government Tech Stack

#23
post #22
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Good thing the United States has a constitutional amendment that totally protects us from having our location data harvested sold and deanonymized by thousands of data brokers!

This practice should extend to the private sector in my opinion. Protection of location data should fall under the 14th amendment.

[deleted]

Re: Singapore Government Tech Stack

#24
We have something similar to this in Antwerp, Belgium.

Most of our solutions are built on top of a kubernetes-powered microservices platform, with an API-first design approach. It is called the Antwerp City Platform as a Service (https://acpaas.digipolis.be).

To ensure technological consistency we have a Digipolis Antwerp Application Stack, which is the technological foundation for new projects. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vR9N3gAJoJFI...

And finally for UI consistency, we have a design system called Antwerp UI (https://antwerp-ui.digipolis.be), which includes a custom-designed font meant to evoke the city's historical architecture, used both for internally facing web apps, and for our public facing website https://www.antwerpen.be

Re: Singapore Government Tech Stack

#25
post #17

Let’s not forget the whole fiasco with Singapore’s TraceTogether app for contact tracing during the pandemic. The actual implementation of it differs significantly from the white paper they open-sourced. The actual app does not anonymize the data and the government has access to everyone’s location and interaction data. Initially, their privacy policy promised the data would only be used for tracking of the spread of…

the road to hell is paved with good intentions let not forget SG is a sort of single party system with no real freedom of press.

And that’s a big part of why their country is wealthy and successful while their neighboring countries are disasters.

Re: Singapore Government Tech Stack

#27
post #18
post #17

Let’s not forget the whole fiasco with Singapore’s TraceTogether app for contact tracing during the pandemic. The actual implementation of it differs significantly from the white paper they open-sourced. The actual app does not anonymize the data and the government has access to everyone’s location and interaction data. Initially, their privacy policy promised the data would only be used for tracking of the spread of…

Good thing the United States has a constitutional amendment that totally protects us from having our location data harvested sold and deanonymized by thousands of data brokers!

My favorite comment. Let's ignore any valid criticism and complain about something else instead.

Re: Singapore Government Tech Stack

#28
post #7

This looks impressive, and something we (America) should copy. Man, I can't help wishing that if we had to have a dictator why couldn't it be someone (mostly) reasonable like Lee Kwan Yew.

I understand the sentiment, and I don't think you were probably being serious, but, for the sake of conversation, I think the issue with dictatorships is eventually with stability. The allure of that much power in a single position leads to the wrong kind of people talking it.

Actually, when we frame things that way, it almost makes me feel like democracy is primarily designed to provide a certain amount of slowness in government; enough to spot corruption coming and head it off. Maybe corruption always eventually wins, just more slowly in democracies. Kinda feels that way lately.

Re: Singapore Government Tech Stack

#29
post #18
post #17

Let’s not forget the whole fiasco with Singapore’s TraceTogether app for contact tracing during the pandemic. The actual implementation of it differs significantly from the white paper they open-sourced. The actual app does not anonymize the data and the government has access to everyone’s location and interaction data. Initially, their privacy policy promised the data would only be used for tracking of the spread of…

Good thing the United States has a constitutional amendment that totally protects us from having our location data harvested sold and deanonymized by thousands of data brokers!

What is the value of this comment? The US government, privacy in the US, and the like is already discussed frequently here. People are also aware of it so you aren't bringing it to light.

Re: Singapore Government Tech Stack

#30

I was really worried when I saw APEX. I thought it was that crappy Oracle app-in-plsql nonsense. Thankfully not! This all looks pretty cool!

I thought it was going to be built on Salesforce

Yes, that would be better than the Oracle option!
Post reply on HN