Live data from Hacker News

Dropbox Said No To “Nine-Digit” Acquisition Offer From Steve Jobs

techcrunch.com

31–40 of 99 posts

Re: Dropbox Said No To “Nine-Digit” Acquisition Offer From Steve Jobs

#31

I think the fundamental differences between Dropbox and iCloud is the sharing feature and Windows/Linux/Mac/etc support. iCloud is never going to be on Windows and our company uses Dropbox to share project resources and our machines are a mixed of PCs and Macs so iCloud means nothing for us.

iCloud is already available on Windows: https://www.apple.com/icloud/setup/pc.html

Re: Dropbox Said No To “Nine-Digit” Acquisition Offer From Steve Jobs

#32

I think the fundamental differences between Dropbox and iCloud is the sharing feature and Windows/Linux/Mac/etc support. iCloud is never going to be on Windows and our company uses Dropbox to share project resources and our machines are a mixed of PCs and Macs so iCloud means nothing for us.

I think you have a good point generally speaking, but iCloud does in fact run on Windows.

Re: Dropbox Said No To “Nine-Digit” Acquisition Offer From Steve Jobs

#33
The major difference for me is Apple builds applications which work with its own products and not other platforms. Can I use icloud on my Linux box? Nope, but I can use Dropbox.

Granted, Dropbox comes with its own limitations, but when I'm looking for software, I want to make sure I'm not pigeon holing myself based on my OS.

Re: Dropbox Said No To “Nine-Digit” Acquisition Offer From Steve Jobs

#34
post #7

I still don't understand why google didn't launch the gdrive... we really begged for it.

There was an interesting point in "In The Plex" where, IIRC, some executive at Google decides to shoot down GDrive because they (Google) wants to push for a reality where you don't even need to keep files on a device in the first place - the files would just always be in the cloud, and then who needs a copy on whatever device you happen to be using? If true, this seems like a real wasted opportunity - even if that is…

They're hardly the only ones trying to abstract files away from the user. iOs has had a lot of success with non technical types doing just that. Here's hoping that osx doesn't fully take the plunge

Re: Dropbox Said No To “Nine-Digit” Acquisition Offer From Steve Jobs

#35
post #23

I love Dropbox, but Jobs is right -- they are a feature, not a product. They will be relevant up to the point where operating systems simply makes their functionality a native element of their file system. At least Drew is wise to the fact that they could become an also-ran, so it's not like this will happen to them overnight.

Wait for competition from Google, Facebook or Microsoft.

Microsoft bought FolderShare a few years back, which let you share & sync directories across PCs and Macs across the internet - so like Dropbox but without their online backup.

Unfortunately Microsoft turned it in to something that didn't work anywhere near as well. It might have been improved now, but my business partner and I moved across to Dropbox, which has been much better. Since then I've also received files from various people working on joint projects across Dropbox, within the web industry it appears to have become the standard for that.

Getting something else that works well on one OS will be straightforward, especially for someone like Apple. Getting it to work well (and wanting it to) for multiple OSes and getting people on the other OSes to adopt it will be another matter.

That's partly why Dropbox survived their security problems so well, it's become part of a lot of people's background workflow.

Re: Dropbox Said No To “Nine-Digit” Acquisition Offer From Steve Jobs

#36
post #31

I think the fundamental differences between Dropbox and iCloud is the sharing feature and Windows/Linux/Mac/etc support. iCloud is never going to be on Windows and our company uses Dropbox to share project resources and our machines are a mixed of PCs and Macs so iCloud means nothing for us.

iCloud is already available on Windows: https://www.apple.com/icloud/setup/pc.html

I bet it comes with Quicktime, iTunes and a lot of extra plugins which are absolutely necessary for to run the software. /joke

Does the Windows versions suck as much as iTunes? (including installing that pesky apple updater).

Going on-topic, I have a dropbox account but the 2 GB limit (which I managed to make 3.5GB after referring) is very limited. In addition they do not support WebDav.

I recently opened a free Box.net account and I am really happy with it. Because it has webdav support (box.net/dav) I can "mount" the disk in any computer as a drive (windows) or folder (linux).

I personally prefer this approach to the DropBox "replicate everything on each PC you enter". But I understand they are solutions to different issues.

Re: Dropbox Said No To “Nine-Digit” Acquisition Offer From Steve Jobs

#37
post #29

I love Dropbox, but Jobs is right -- they are a feature, not a product. They will be relevant up to the point where operating systems simply makes their functionality a native element of their file system. At least Drew is wise to the fact that they could become an also-ran, so it's not like this will happen to them overnight.

Operating systems we run Dropbox on at my house: Ubuntu, OSX, iOS, Windows, Blackberry 5. Someday they may all have Dropbox-like functionality built in, and someday after that they may interoperate. Dropbox can stay in their current business a long time regardless.

Given Ubuntu already has that functionality built in (Ubuntu One), and offers Win, Android and iOS 3.1+ clients, we're really not so far off from that being the case already.

Re: Dropbox Said No To “Nine-Digit” Acquisition Offer From Steve Jobs

#38

I think the fundamental differences between Dropbox and iCloud is the sharing feature and Windows/Linux/Mac/etc support. iCloud is never going to be on Windows and our company uses Dropbox to share project resources and our machines are a mixed of PCs and Macs so iCloud means nothing for us.

Don't forget Android, Windows Mobile, and Blackberry. iCloud is available on Windows, but I don't think it will be going to competing mobile platforms any time soon.

Re: Dropbox Said No To “Nine-Digit” Acquisition Offer From Steve Jobs

#39

I think the fundamental differences between Dropbox and iCloud is the sharing feature and Windows/Linux/Mac/etc support. iCloud is never going to be on Windows and our company uses Dropbox to share project resources and our machines are a mixed of PCs and Macs so iCloud means nothing for us.

More to the point iCloud will never be on Linux.

Re: Dropbox Said No To “Nine-Digit” Acquisition Offer From Steve Jobs

#40
post #30

I think the fundamental differences between Dropbox and iCloud is the sharing feature and Windows/Linux/Mac/etc support. iCloud is never going to be on Windows and our company uses Dropbox to share project resources and our machines are a mixed of PCs and Macs so iCloud means nothing for us.

"iCloud is never going to be on Windows" The same was said about iTunes, but it eventually appeared there. It wouldn't surprise me if more aspects of iCloud eventually appear on Windows.

iCloud is available on Windows - https://www.apple.com/icloud/setup/pc.html
Post reply on HN