Earlier quoted context omitted.
That's where I'm at with OmniFocus. I love it so much, but it's really expensive, and I'm finding the extra features above Reminders aren't as crucial to my daily life as I'd thought.
Yep same here, Omni was my next stop after Things and I came to much the same conclusion. Personally I'm pretty happy with Reminders, being able to shout reminders at Siri, and getting location-based reminders has actually been pretty useful for me especially these days when I don't know when specifically I'll be in the office.
A shared to-do list with my wife was the real killer feature.