Live data from Hacker News

Things I can’t do on macOS which I can do on Ubuntu (2020)

shkspr.mobi

381–390 of 740 posts

Re: Things I can’t do on macOS which I can do on Ubuntu (2020)

#381
post #243

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or simply the third button on the top left of nearly every window?

No, that hides the menu bar.

You can stop it hiding the menu bar in full screen. System Preferences -> Dock and Menu Bar -> Automatically Hide and Show Menu Bar in Full Screen (at the bottom of the window).

Re: Things I can’t do on macOS which I can do on Ubuntu (2020)

#382

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In return, I'm amazed that people don't just use the software as it's designed. Why do people want to tweak like this? Like he wants to move the clock. Oh my god just leave it where it is and get on with your job. Lack of customisability gives us more stable software. And he wants his windows to wobble? What on earth is the point of that?

Because people have different needs, expectations, and preferences. It’s part of what makes humans interesting. Computers should be made to serve people, not the other way around.

Having different preferences, and using a different platform that serves them better, is absolutely fine.

Deciding that the platform that doesn't meet your needs is somehow illegitimate, "not a computer," or somehow morally unacceptable is juvenile fanboy crap.

Re: Things I can’t do on macOS which I can do on Ubuntu (2020)

#383

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because people have different needs, expectations, and preferences. It’s part of what makes humans interesting. Computers should be made to serve people, not the other way around.

I don't know - I'm a big fan of sensible defaults, lack of customisation (so lack of entropy) and just getting on and using it as designed, rather than trying to bend it to be something else. I'm not sure there can really be any reasonable requirement to move the clock. I think that's just being fussy. For every wacky feature or option someone wants, that has to be built, maintained, tested. Every boolean option you…

I somewhat agree, except maybe:

> This blog post is a set of requirements for a Homer car, not a sensible professional tool

"Professional" is a wide category for sure, but I would argue professionals are the ones who need more customization, not less. They are the ones with esoteric tools and workflows, and where customizing their environment to match how their mind works allows them to focus on the problems at hand and not their tools.

> For every wacky feature or option someone wants, that has to be built, maintained, tested

True. However, these are trillion-dollar companies. Look at all the options for cars, or refrigerators, or whatever. And all these have the constraints of the physical world. And all made by companies with a heck of a lot less cash than Apple and Microsoft.

Re: Things I can’t do on macOS which I can do on Ubuntu (2020)

#384

I don't use a Mac often (mainly Linux), but I do troubleshoot my significant other's. I'll add on my gripes: - SMB shares are wonky and will randomly disconnect with vague errors. - A large USB drive formatted with NTFS can't be mounted as read/write natively, you have to pay for a third party tool for that. - Mac's built in gatekeeper software is inferior to Windows Defender. While there's less malware available, th…

"lastly, Mac restore process is not as easy as Windows, you can reset a Windows PC in a few clicks. Mac your manually nuking volumes, which for a newbie isn't really friendly. "

This is not true. Macs had an in-place reinstall before Windows did, IIRC.

https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204904

Re: Things I can’t do on macOS which I can do on Ubuntu (2020)

#385

I wonder if the OP has switched from Windows to Linux initially. And did he write a piece complaining that everything isn't exactly how they're used to then? A lot of "i'd switch but" articles - in all directions - basically come down to "the destination doesn't work how i'm used to". Even though they're fundamentally as crappy in the background. When someone asks me why I use Mac OS as my main desktop I answer "it's…

I think you've hit the nail on the head. I'm happily using Windows now but used a Mac before and it took a long time for me to realise that my complaints about Windows largely boiled down to "it doesn't do things in the way that I'm used to". With that said, whilst I do like macOS overall I always found it infuriating how on macOS applications could steal focus. Something I do appreciate on Windows is that focus stea…

> Something I do appreciate on Windows is that focus stealing by and large isn't a thing.

Until you need to run an app as Administrator, and then… everything disappears in favor of a blue screen (even on external monitors), with only a single confirmation modal remaining.

I’ve never understood why what is effectively ‘sudo’ needs to be a full-screen event.

Re: Things I can’t do on macOS which I can do on Ubuntu (2020)

#386

> Read MTP devices > Mount an SSH or NFS drive I know fanboy debates are tiresome, but... I really do struggle to comprehend taking a device that can't do these things seriously as a computer. As a toy yes, or as a specialised tool for video or audio rendering, which... fair enough. But moving bytes is something any general purpose computing device should be good at. It's almost something you have to actively design…

I'd not heard of MTP before, so looked it up: " MTP is part of the "Windows Media" framework and thus closely related to Windows Media Player. " I wonder, can Windows natively work with APFS volumes..? I know with extra software it can, but then with extra software macOS can do all the things in the blog post too. There is at least one thing I can do on macOS though that I can't on Ubuntu: run the latest version of P…

I think you are making an understandable misreading (but perhaps i am!). MTP is a standard promulgated by the USB Implementers Forum [1], just like the mass storage or human interface device protocols. What that paragraph means is that on Windows, MTP is dealt with by the media framework, as opposed to being part of the storage subsystem, as SMB and NFS are. Why is why you can't access MTP devices as if they were volumes on Windows.

[1] https://www.usb.org/document-library/media-transfer-protocol...

Re: Things I can’t do on macOS which I can do on Ubuntu (2020)

#387
post #368
post #355

Number 1 for me is definitely "Control which audio device an app is playing to, without that app having to implement an internal picker"

Can’t you do this with audio hijack?

What's audio hijack? Under Linux with pipewire or pulse its just a dropdown next to the application name in your OS volume mixer

Re: Things I can’t do on macOS which I can do on Ubuntu (2020)

#388

> Read MTP devices > Mount an SSH or NFS drive I know fanboy debates are tiresome, but... I really do struggle to comprehend taking a device that can't do these things seriously as a computer. As a toy yes, or as a specialised tool for video or audio rendering, which... fair enough. But moving bytes is something any general purpose computing device should be good at. It's almost something you have to actively design…

This reads like "my use case defines what a computer is," which is absolutely as tiresome an argument as any fanboy debate. I imagine iOS can't do those things, either, and yet an iPad is the computing platform of choice for an awful lot of people because it meets their computing needs. Examine your biases here.

(1) Good hardware with good software support goes a long way. I'd say that iOS is much more of a polished OS than macOS. No wonder, considering that it's the iOS devices that fuel Apple's profits, not Macbooks.

(2) For a lot of people, an iPad is more of a consumption device, or a device to run 2-3 specialized apps (e.g. for drawing or music). Maybe they would be glad if iOS offered wider universal computing capabilities, but their choice of a powerful and mobile device is pretty limited.

Re: Things I can’t do on macOS which I can do on Ubuntu (2020)

#389

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think you've hit the nail on the head. I'm happily using Windows now but used a Mac before and it took a long time for me to realise that my complaints about Windows largely boiled down to "it doesn't do things in the way that I'm used to". With that said, whilst I do like macOS overall I always found it infuriating how on macOS applications could steal focus. Something I do appreciate on Windows is that focus stea…

> Something I do appreciate on Windows is that focus stealing by and large isn't a thing. Interesting. Focus stealing really is annoying, but from my experience Windows is not really better.

Yeah, same. I HATE HATE HATE it, but it happens to me on both platforms all the time.

Re: Things I can’t do on macOS which I can do on Ubuntu (2020)

#390
post #367
post #217

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For those who don't mind "full screen" still including the top bar, I find https://www.hammerspoon.org/ to be a good compromise. I set up option+shift+f to full screen my window instantly.

If the top bar is still there, is this different to the built in "double click title bar" maximise?

The '+' button and double-clicking the title-bar doesn't maximize windows—it zooms them in Apple's terminology. It should just make the window big enough to display its contents, although some apps don't cooperate (Chrome). Hammerspoon can be configured to maximize windows, i.e. make them fill the screen.
Post reply on HN