Live data from Hacker News

Poll: Are you going to leave Twitter after Musk's acquisition?

news.ycombinator.com

61–70 of 122 posts

Re: Poll: Are you going to leave Twitter after Musk's acquisition?

#63
post #10

I'd like to call out that individual responses to this don't matter. What matters is if Twitter remains a place for public discourse. So long as we allow public discourse to happen on private platforms that aren't held responsible for maintaining the availability, accountability, and freedom (as in speech) of these public forums, Twitter will continue to be problematic. Whether it's Musk or a private group of shareho…

...Twitter ... a place for public discourse..." lol

Re: Poll: Are you going to leave Twitter after Musk's acquisition?

#64
My sincere, however unlikely hope is that the division regarding Musk's acquisition causes enough users to leave to cripple the platform. I don't think there will be another Twitter if this one fails. I can't foresee any single platform gaining the same network effect now that the idea of this style of site has been replicated. I think that Twitter is already waning in relevance, and too politically fractious as is.

I legitimately think that Twitter has a net negative moral utility, and I hope it dies.

Re: Poll: Are you going to leave Twitter after Musk's acquisition?

#65
post #46
post #10

I'd like to call out that individual responses to this don't matter. What matters is if Twitter remains a place for public discourse. So long as we allow public discourse to happen on private platforms that aren't held responsible for maintaining the availability, accountability, and freedom (as in speech) of these public forums, Twitter will continue to be problematic. Whether it's Musk or a private group of shareho…

The platforms themselves, expressions of free enterprise and free association, are part of the discourse - not merely a location. We're not, and never really have been over the full course of the information age so far, in need of new, online public fora. (Go to your city council meetings.) They are just neat.

If you think people on Twitter are crazy, go to your city council meetings. Especially if you live in a major city.

Re: Poll: Are you going to leave Twitter after Musk's acquisition?

#66
post #62

I'm curious about those voting option 5 — thinking about joining now. What do you expect to get on a Musk-owned Twitter that's not there now? Is there a specific promise made by him that you find appealing?

Just a quick FYI, poll option orders are randomized on HN iirc.

Re: Poll: Are you going to leave Twitter after Musk's acquisition?

#67
post #41

been on the fediverse for years now, no reason to head back.

Except for the hundred people or so that I follow and are drunk on their popularity with zero incentive to leave, I guess?

My wet dream is for New Twitter to open up the API so that I can implement a bi-directional bridge and do full POSSE.

Re: Poll: Are you going to leave Twitter after Musk's acquisition?

#68
post #62

I'm curious about those voting option 5 — thinking about joining now. What do you expect to get on a Musk-owned Twitter that's not there now? Is there a specific promise made by him that you find appealing?

Not my views personally, but there was a time on Twitter when doubting the effectiveness of certain drugs, expressing views about the 2020 election could get your account suspended. I think people are hoping that things like this won't happen any more because of Musk's views on free speech.

Re: Poll: Are you going to leave Twitter after Musk's acquisition?

#70
post #48

I honestly don't think it'll change that much. Musk's statements thus far suggest that he lacks a basic understanding of the problems inherent to running a platform like Twitter, so he'll probably just get frustrated and lose interest once he starts running into them. I suspect that the company will end up in the hands of a group indistinguishable from the current board, except they'll be Musk's friends.

Why do people keep saying he'll get frustrated and lose interest, as though he has a history of giving up on things once they get hard? People were saying that about his bid too.

Same... I'm not sure why people think that the guy who spent billions to create a reusable rocket that can land on little tiny pads in the ocean would throw his hands up and think the problem of bots and spam on Twitter is unsolvable.
Post reply on HN