Live data from Hacker News

Dear John Carmack.

iloapp.quelsolaar.com

41–50 of 98 posts

Re: Dear John Carmack.

#41
post #39
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm living out my top-choice fantasy already: working on my web startup. Gaming is a secondary love, but if no one else gets around to it I definitely will.

DaVinci tackled a dozen fantasies pretty much simultaneously. I think you're more capable than you give yourself credit for.

Hah. Da Vinci was a time traveler though. Unfair advantage.

Re: Dear John Carmack.

#42
post #12

I will agree with one thing from the article, he's John freakin' Carmack . This is a man who has been pushing the boundaries of realtime graphics since Wolfenstein3D. We owe him a lot, and I think he has earned the right to work on whatever project he damn well chooses. People seem to imagine all the amazing things he could have done with his time while glossing over the amazing things he has done right here, right n…

Minor (very minor) quibble: You said "since Wolf3D"; but "since Commander Keen" would be more accurate.

Keen was possible due to a stroke of genius, letting him trick the monitor itself into becoming part of his "adaptive tile refresh" system. I'm a little hazy on the details, but... it's just a cool, little-known fact that Carmack made the very first "Mario-style" side scroller for the PC -- a feat that no one else managed to pull off.

Re: Dear John Carmack.

#43
post #42
post #12

I will agree with one thing from the article, he's John freakin' Carmack . This is a man who has been pushing the boundaries of realtime graphics since Wolfenstein3D. We owe him a lot, and I think he has earned the right to work on whatever project he damn well chooses. People seem to imagine all the amazing things he could have done with his time while glossing over the amazing things he has done right here, right n…

Minor (very minor) quibble: You said "since Wolf3D"; but "since Commander Keen" would be more accurate. Keen was possible due to a stroke of genius, letting him trick the monitor itself into becoming part of his "adaptive tile refresh" system. I'm a little hazy on the details, but... it's just a cool, little-known fact that Carmack made the very first "Mario-style" side scroller for the PC -- a feat that no one else…

Minor quibble accepted!

It's easy to forget how crap PC graphics were at the time of Commander Keen. It was the first PC platform game I can remember that wasn't an obviously-CGA sprite flickerathon :)

Re: Dear John Carmack.

#44
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd say Carmack cares more about rockets than about games, at this point. Who wouldn't?

His interviews after he received the gdc lifetime achievement award suggest otherwise.

Really? Interesting. I haven't kept up.

That's... Well, that's ironic. I wonder why he decided to pursue gamedev with more passion than rocketdev?

Re: Dear John Carmack.

#45
Wtf Rage is amazing and I've never seen a game that looks better. I would say that getting Rage done is quite an achievement. If hoped that JC would do a different game then you can doit yourself.

Re: Dear John Carmack.

#46
post #39
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm living out my top-choice fantasy already: working on my web startup. Gaming is a secondary love, but if no one else gets around to it I definitely will.

DaVinci tackled a dozen fantasies pretty much simultaneously. I think you're more capable than you give yourself credit for.

That's like saying that somebody should be pretty good at physics because Einstein was. Juggling lots of ideas at once was pretty much Leonardo da Vinci's thing.

Re: Dear John Carmack.

#47
post #39
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm living out my top-choice fantasy already: working on my web startup. Gaming is a secondary love, but if no one else gets around to it I definitely will.

DaVinci tackled a dozen fantasies pretty much simultaneously. I think you're more capable than you give yourself credit for.

Yeah but a lot of what you think of when you think DaVinci never really got past the idea state.

Re: Dear John Carmack.

#48
> Many games designers think its their job to tell stories, but games isn't a story medium, they should go write books or make films.

Couldn't be more wrong. In fact, lack of compelling story is one of the things that's wrong with gaming today.

Re: Dear John Carmack.

#49
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

DaVinci tackled a dozen fantasies pretty much simultaneously. I think you're more capable than you give yourself credit for.

That's like saying that somebody should be pretty good at physics because Einstein was. Juggling lots of ideas at once was pretty much Leonardo da Vinci's thing.

Discouraging people from having confidence in themselves (even when that confidence is unrealistic) is one of the biggest tragedies brought about by modern-day mediums such as HN et al.

I'd rather strike out a dozen times than watch from the stands.

Re: Dear John Carmack.

#50

Carmack needs to be paired up with a real gameplay/product/market counterpart. His Steve Jobs so to speak. But if he is happy doing it his way then he should continue. I just hope Bethesda won't punish him for Rage's commercial disappointment.

He needs Romero back. I think if these two were still working together, we would see some amazing games being made.

I thought about John Romero but from i've read his (game) design sensibilities/taste wasn't quite the equivalent of Carmack's technical chops.
Post reply on HN