Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What are the next internet infra problems?

news.ycombinator.com

41–50 of 230 posts

Re: Ask HN: What are the next internet infra problems?

#41

Re-writing all the software, in short. It is all a steaming pile of garbage.

What programming language is "short"?

None so far, they're all steaming piles of garbage.

We're still typing single characters in text files as if we're on a terminal in 1960s.

Re: Ask HN: What are the next internet infra problems?

#42
post #38

Low carbon footprint datacenters, but it requires better software performance. Law of Wirth explains that. Ability to do SDR for wireless networks with smarphones. 5G is not a good solution. Better security for routers, and generally better software security regulations, which are almost non existent right now. If cars have security regulations, software should, too.

>5G is not a good solution

Interesting viewpoint. Care to expand on your thoughts? To me, 5G seems like a stepping stone to UWB communication

Re: Ask HN: What are the next internet infra problems?

#43
post #39

Provable identity. Yes, you can do Oauth via the google or the facebook but sooner or later we need something that isn't tied to getting all your user interaction data ... Digital notary. So a third person (digitally) signing a transaction or other document exchange.

Could you expand on both of those? They sound really interesting but I'm not sure I understand the issues or use cases.

Provable identity: you get an email, hi i'm a hiring manager from company X, can we get in touch about job Y, could you please send me your (secret) phone number?

It should be possible for you, the receiver of the email, to check if the email originated at company X.

Digital Notary: this came up in several data privacy discussions. You (A) are in contact with B, but you don't want to send B something like a scan of your passport (e.g. for age restricted services). So you disclose the passport scan to Notary and he sends B the message, the passport was disclosed to me and the person is >21.

Re: Ask HN: What are the next internet infra problems?

#44

I think solving the "last mile" problem in the US is our greatest problem, especially in rural areas. Too many state and local governments have been paid off by lobbyists to pass laws to block any competition from offering cheaper and better options. Too many people are stuck with slow, expensive, and unreliable cable and/or DSL ISPs. Some have no choice whatsoever. Some others get to choose only from two equally awf…

Unfortunately that problem space is so large (every new line of fibre has how many stakeholders?) that a single individual or organisation might not be able to have any impact here. Which I think is the root of this question.

If there's above-ground electricity, there should be rules about getting pole access. And from what I understand those poles, and anything underground, work by getting easements rather than negotiating separately with every individual property owner.

Re: Ask HN: What are the next internet infra problems?

#45
post #13
post #8

Interesting question. Do we still have Internet infrastructural problems left? Akamai solved POPs (point of presence). Equinix solved DC. Both are matching towards table stakes in the context of internet infrastructural. (Not business models). We have lots of under-sea cables / international expansions on-going and planned. And it is now more of a cost efficiency problem, not an infrastructural problem . We have a de…

Dealing with denial of service attacks in a way that doesn't involve needing to own more bandwidth then the attacker can saturate would be something to look into.

Well, that would have to be either not having a link for them to try to saturate (ie, edge-distribute your stuff as CDNs do), or preventing them from sending packets to you (which means telling other people's routers to run your packet-filtering code, which I'd think might be a bit of a hard sell).

Re: Ask HN: What are the next internet infra problems?

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What programming language is "short"?

None so far, they're all steaming piles of garbage. We're still typing single characters in text files as if we're on a terminal in 1960s.

I don't think the medium (text files) is the real problem for SW. There are ways of creating SW by clicking things on a screen.

We're in the middle of a SW quality crisis, because a lot of people have not the slightest idea what they are doing, but they are encouraged by their managers to ship immediately.

Re: Ask HN: What are the next internet infra problems?

#47
post #22

De-ossifying the Internet is necessary for solving many other problems like the IPv6 and RPKI transitions. There's a lot of room to optimize latency whether it's removing bufferbloat, L4S, or cISP.

There is not many ways to get rid of bufferbloat if you want to keep packet routing/switching networks.

Re: Ask HN: What are the next internet infra problems?

#48
post #6
post #4

The biggest challenges are people problems. Why the hell don’t we have fiber to the home in most of America? Regulatory capture and market failures.

The cost of running new lines on poles is also insane, our infrastructure is racking up so much debt.

There was a well meaning president that wanted to solve the problem until his program was cut down to nothing. Instead, we are heading towards an economic recession. Quite amusing.

Re: Ask HN: What are the next internet infra problems?

#49
post #38

Low carbon footprint datacenters, but it requires better software performance. Law of Wirth explains that. Ability to do SDR for wireless networks with smarphones. 5G is not a good solution. Better security for routers, and generally better software security regulations, which are almost non existent right now. If cars have security regulations, software should, too.

"Ability to do SDR for wireless networks with smarphones" - you want to have SDR on the smartphone?

Re: Ask HN: What are the next internet infra problems?

#50
post #14

Those companies were not created to solve those problems, but to profit by them. Do you think that, say, Cloudflare would like a better web protocol which would be impossible to DDoS?

How would a web protocol solve this? Even if you were to create an internet protocol to counter DDoS attacks by allowing destination IP addresses to request hardware accelerated IP bans of abusive source addresses you still are stuck with a hardware and authorization problem.

Even if you properly implement this system, network operators will expose themselves to firewall DDoS attacks by malicious actors that are trying to fill the firewall blacklists with garbage.

We've reached counter counter DDoS warfare. What do you do now?

Post reply on HN