Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Have you invested in self-development and done inner work?

news.ycombinator.com

41–50 of 105 posts

Re: Ask HN: Have you invested in self-development and done inner work?

#41
"Invested" in "inner work". Indie, maker, optimizer. Maybe it is just a different kinds of people thing but I think we shouldn't use business jargon language, with all the implicit values and associations that come along with it, to define, of all things, our fundamental mindset and relationship to ourselves. Don't frame yourself that way. Don't become another tool or asset to be burned up like so much VC cash in the making of something ultimately trivial. That language has a purpose but is not good for the soul. Sorry for the rant.

Re: Ask HN: Have you invested in self-development and done inner work?

#42
Be careful with thinking that deep work, expanding your mind, culture, emotional and spiritual literacy, philosophical, psychological and political understanding will make you better.

You will become different. Whatever measures by which you discern 'better' before, will be irrelevant, almost laughable to the person you become. And beware too that growth can itself become a preoccupation.

If you have goals like be more productive, make more money, change the world, be more liked... then prepare yourself for at least the possibility that you will, in the course of real growth, end up rejecting those things as silly.

edit: accidentally posted as reply to wrong comment

Re: Ask HN: Have you invested in self-development and done inner work?

#43
I haven't got time to write a better comment, but stopping past to say that I've found Vertical Development the most helpful conceptual framework for my own growth and for making sense of others.

As a mental model, it has applications from very basic to extremely rich and complex.

I've worked as an eng/manager/executive coach and keep discovering new insights.

I always enjoy discussing it more if you're interested

Re: Ask HN: Have you invested in self-development and done inner work?

#44

Be careful with thinking that deep work, expanding your mind, culture, emotional and spiritual literacy, philosophical, psychological and political understanding will make you better. You will become different. Whatever measures by which you discern 'better' before, will be irrelevant, almost laughable to the person you become. And beware too that growth can itself become a preoccupation. If you have goals like be mo…

No post body was provided.

Re: Ask HN: Have you invested in self-development and done inner work?

#45
What might be throwing off some of the commenters here:

You're using language like "personal growth" and "inner work" to describe what just sounds to be professional development.

Maybe professional capacity and personal identity are all tied up for you. That's certainly true for a lot of people here, including myself sometimes. But it's also maybe just an echo of working so long in an industry that tried to sell one as the other. It reads as an extraordinarily narrow perspective in world where we only work for a few decades and only with about 25% of our time during those decades.

If you're genuinely interested in personal growth and inner work, consider stepping back from the professional space as you look for programs. And if you're just interested in professional development in your craft, consider using language that's more specifically associated with it.

Re: Ask HN: Have you invested in self-development and done inner work?

#47
I don't believe much into self-improvement industry, in fact I believe it is largely snake oil.

One of the things that I find most gross about this whole industry is pushing the idea that you need to be "fixed".

This kind of industry desperately needs to sell you there's something wrong with you that needs to be repaired or improved in order to sell you the solution.

That's not to say there is no good contents out there, but in the end it can all be summed up to: have a purpose in life, work towards that purpose, be self disciplined if you want to achieve anything, be honest with yourself and other people.

There isn't really much else to "self improvement" and "happiness" than understanding what you want to be and do, working towards that goal, having introspections and cultivating meaningful and healthy relationships.

There's no secret sauce out there, no shortcut, if there was we all would've known it already after thousands of years of books, movies and phylosophical essays, reality is simple, but I guess hard work and discipline isn't as sexy and appealing like snake oil.

Re: Ask HN: Have you invested in self-development and done inner work?

#49
There's emotional/spiritual inner work like therapy (invaluable for most, but not all).

And then there's mentorship sessions that I see are becoming more and more common in the visual arts world, where the focus is improving on a specific kind of craft and exploring mental blockages. Jayd (https://www.jaydaitkaci.com/services.html) was instrumental in my own maturity in the art world there, and I'd highly recommend those sessions if you're a maker in the visual/drawing sense.

Re: Ask HN: Have you invested in self-development and done inner work?

#50

IMO, people have the wrong idea about "self development" and "personal growth" - It sounds like some new age self-help, spiritual BS. This is not self development. Self development has nothing to do with positive thinking, visualizing success or spiritual stuff. That's a load of horse shit. Real self-development involves choosing difficult goals and focusing all your energy on attaining them; learning new skills and…

Figuring your self out and facing your darkness is about as difficult and challenging as goals get from my experience, anything else is a Sunday walk in the park in comparison.

It wont yield any improvement as long as you're too terrified to try and too busy judging those who are trying.

Post reply on HN