Live data from Hacker News

Elon Musk to join Twitter’s board of directors

sec.gov

101–110 of 1001 posts

Re: Elon Musk to join Twitter’s board of directors

#101
post #13

He filed forms that he was going to be a passive investor, and the same day joined the board after discussion that had been in the works for weeks. This is strike two on misleading investors. I haven't seen analysis on whether it was illegal, but I wouldn't want somebody like him on my board even if it succeeded in keeping him from buying up more stock. With him on the outside, maybe he causes more trouble than on th…

Shareholders like him on the board, and they would be even happier if he were running the company, because an Elon-run Twitter would be a lot more profitable.

[deleted]

Re: Elon Musk to join Twitter’s board of directors

#102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Shareholders like him on the board, and they would be even happier if he were running the company, because an Elon-run Twitter would be a lot more profitable.

More profitable, more open, and more fair to all voices. Twitter has become a liberal vacuum that, as a liberal, has gone way too far to the left in silencing voices. It's not a private company, it's a public company, and I hope Elon turns it around into a true, free speech town square, instead of just an echo chamber for blue checks.

"As a liberal, twitter has gone way too far to the left in silencing voices?" Twitter moderation is blind on harassment, nazis who brag about it are using the platform to dox people without any repercussions, send death threats, etc. what the hell are you even talking about?

Re: Elon Musk to join Twitter’s board of directors

#103

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Shareholders like him on the board, and they would be even happier if he were running the company, because an Elon-run Twitter would be a lot more profitable.

More profitable, more open, and more fair to all voices. Twitter has become a liberal vacuum that, as a liberal, has gone way too far to the left in silencing voices. It's not a private company, it's a public company, and I hope Elon turns it around into a true, free speech town square, instead of just an echo chamber for blue checks.

Blue checks do not equal blue voices, but you already know that. Twitter is the worst mainstream platform when it comes to right wing propaganda and scientific misinformation. Free speech in this case is code for saying anything without consequence and weaponizing it at morons. Twitter excels at it already, let's not make it worse.

Re: Elon Musk to join Twitter’s board of directors

#104

This is the biggest thing to happen to twitter since the trump presidency. Both big for twitter, and awful for society.

Quoted post unavailable.

Is Elon a Republican or Conservative? I've seen variations of this regarding balancing ownership and improving free speech, but aside from a few cryptic tweets about cancel culture, has Elon ever said anything? In interviews (especially the famous Rogan interview) he seems pretty disinterested in politics.

Re: Elon Musk to join Twitter’s board of directors

#106
post #85

I have obviously missed something but what is the main objection to Musk being part of Twitter's board?

A decent chunk of people in the previous thread were saying he’s doing it to kill the bot that tracks his plane’s movements. In general, he seems to be an active enough user that there’s concerns he will use his new power as a way to shield himself from the consequences of his activity.

Re: Elon Musk to join Twitter’s board of directors

#107
post #67
post #31

I am beyond tired of billionaires, who get to treat companies, public sentiment, and politics, and thus a fair portion of government and policy, as their personal sandbox. Greed and oligarchy are ruining America.

Agreed but I'm not sure how we can change it at this point. Our lives in the US are way too good for revolution. This move by him is strictly about not letting Twitter ever block his accounts. He can pump & dump and mislead investors for billions that will make him a lot more money than his Twitter stake cost.

> . Our lives in the US are way too good for revolution.

lol, maybe for "us" they are most people have serious trouble just living and near zero retirement funds

Re: Elon Musk to join Twitter’s board of directors

#108

This is the biggest thing to happen to twitter since the trump presidency. Both big for twitter, and awful for society.

Quoted post unavailable.

Be civil. That is the most uncharitable reading of a comment I’ve seen today.

Re: Elon Musk to join Twitter’s board of directors

#109
post #83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>This seems like a silly post on first reading, but actually thinking about it, that would mean the first amendment actually applies to Twitter right? Without Section 230 Twitter would be liable for every evil thing that is said on their platform. What Section 230 does is create a category in which you are not liable for the content on the platform but they specifically setup limited rules for what can be censored. A…

You seem slightly confused about what 230 does. What it does is allow companies to do some moderation without legally liable as publishers for all content they host. Without section 230 companies have a choice to either do no moderation or to assume full liability as publishers. Section 230 was created to encorage online moderation by removing the liability that moderation would bring in an offline context.

>You seem slightly confused about what 230 does. What it does is allow companies to do some moderation without legally liable as publishers for all content they host.

I did copy and paste the law. It's clear to me what is says and the free speech that is required. Censorship must be done in good faith.

>Without section 230 companies have a choice to either do no moderation or to assume full liability as publishers.

Without section 230 they would assume full liability as publisher.

>Section 230 was created to encorage online moderation by removing the liability that moderation would bring in an offline context.

Section 230 was created to allow entities like twitter to exist. Without section 230 twitter stops existing.

Let's be realistic, Elon just put $9 billion down because his poll showed significant problem with censorship. Fixing this will take twitter from $40 billion to much higher.

Re: Elon Musk to join Twitter’s board of directors

#110
post #95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I sympathize but very rich people owning the media never ends well

Because that wasn't happening in the first place?

The comparable cases are Bezos & Zuck, the parallel is Berlusconi. Yes it's all scary
Post reply on HN