Live data from Hacker News

25+ years of personal knowledge management

dsebastien.net

41–50 of 72 posts

Re: 25+ years of personal knowledge management

#41
post #32

There are several principles that have helped me: - Do NOT migrate to new tools, even if they are really shiny and popular - this may end up being a big hurdle you'll regret down the line (looking at you, Notion, Todoist, Google Keep, the list goes on). Just stick to your tools for at least a couple of years before exploring alternatives. - Try search instead of organisation. I used to have elaborate folder structure…

>Do NOT migrate to new tools

Completely agree here. For better or worse (well, definitely worse), I've noticed that some part of my brain that loves list-making and re-organizing. This leads me to an impulse to be in a never-ending process of migrating from one tool to another, wind at my back with a new motivated epiphany about how to re-organize everything.

Of course, when I say it out loud, it's nonsense, but moment to moment it doesn't feel like that's what I'm doing.

I really love the wiki-style organization but I don't want to depend on a tool with features stuck to that tool. I want something universal, like text.

Right now I'm using Simplenote and its killer linked notes feature, but I fear perhaps I've got a bit of lock-in there too. I at least believe in the ability to easily backup and migrate out of Simplenote, I think it's kinda portable.

But I really think simple principles, like search don't sort, may cut through the unnecessary complexity that my brain loves to produce and administer.

Re: 25+ years of personal knowledge management

#43

I've long since "given up" organizing my files. I was a long time user of one or more NAS boxes (first was a Synology DS101g+), and ran everything self hosted up until 3-5 years ago. These days i just throw everything in the cloud, using Cryptomator[1] for privacy where applicapable, and everything else lives on a Mac Mini at home with a couple of USB drives attached, whose main purpose is backing up the cloud data.…

Thanks for the Cryptomator recommendation I've been looking for something that can encrypt cloud backups more easily than uploading encrypted 7z files. Not sure whether it would work for your use case since it doesn't support handwritten notes, but I've been using Notion as a cross-platform notes app and found it works well

Re: 25+ years of personal knowledge management

#45
post #32

There are several principles that have helped me: - Do NOT migrate to new tools, even if they are really shiny and popular - this may end up being a big hurdle you'll regret down the line (looking at you, Notion, Todoist, Google Keep, the list goes on). Just stick to your tools for at least a couple of years before exploring alternatives. - Try search instead of organisation. I used to have elaborate folder structure…

Maybe leave your friends and family alone - sure, it's fine to mention a product if the topic comes up but I find one of the things humans tend to want help with the least it's organization - everyone has their own system.

Re: 25+ years of personal knowledge management

#46
post #32

There are several principles that have helped me: - Do NOT migrate to new tools, even if they are really shiny and popular - this may end up being a big hurdle you'll regret down the line (looking at you, Notion, Todoist, Google Keep, the list goes on). Just stick to your tools for at least a couple of years before exploring alternatives. - Try search instead of organisation. I used to have elaborate folder structure…

+1 for "use search instead of organization". I've been taking notes for 2 years, zettelkasten-style, and 90% of them are just dumped in the same directory, without links or tags. If I'm looking for something and remember that I might have that in my notes, I just search for it. That also implies that, when writing a note, I sometimes add a line with a few related keywords and synonyms.

How though? People say this like search is simple, but how do you search for things?

I'm using Roam and I still have this issue.

Re: 25+ years of personal knowledge management

#47
post #43

I've long since "given up" organizing my files. I was a long time user of one or more NAS boxes (first was a Synology DS101g+), and ran everything self hosted up until 3-5 years ago. These days i just throw everything in the cloud, using Cryptomator[1] for privacy where applicapable, and everything else lives on a Mac Mini at home with a couple of USB drives attached, whose main purpose is backing up the cloud data.…

Thanks for the Cryptomator recommendation I've been looking for something that can encrypt cloud backups more easily than uploading encrypted 7z files. Not sure whether it would work for your use case since it doesn't support handwritten notes, but I've been using Notion as a cross-platform notes app and found it works well

I don't use Cryptomator for backups, i use it for encrypting and accessing my data in the cloud.

For Cloud backups i use Arq (https://www.arqbackup.com/).

It supports A LOT of different cloud providers, and does proper versioned, deduplicated backups.

Another great looking (but not yet stable!) option would be Kopia (https://kopia.io/) which is open source, and does much of the same stuff as Arq, and even supports deduplication across multiple backup sources. Duplicacy (https://duplicacy.com/) does as well, but i've not used it much.

Re: 25+ years of personal knowledge management

#48
>Reduce the number of tools you use for the same purpose to 1 if you can

This was the focus of Q1 for me. I had 2-3 apps doing the same thing so I had to make a choice and choose the most suitable and stick to that.

It's funny that this advice goes beyond PKM. Even programming tools, pick and stick to one. You can always explore later. Go with your use case but I digress.

Thanks dSebastien

Post reply on HN