Earlier quoted context omitted.
At least in the US, look on the bright side- the odds of anyone needing your marrow are low, so there would be no sense in a systematic harvesting of marrow prison-wide every month. Inmates already work in labor gangs. So, if you are a prisoner and you get selected, strike a deal and get out of labor gangs for a month (because you just earned as much as if you had been in a labor gang). It'd be a good thing to get pi…
Maybe. Bone marrow donation is debilitating and really painful. I suspect not everybody would want to duck out on labor gang for it.
Photojojo, Jelly founder needs bone marrow match to save his life
71–78 of 78 posts
Re: Photojojo, Jelly founder needs bone marrow match to save his life
#72Earlier quoted context omitted.
How about people can sell it and the gov't has to pay for it when someone needs it? Seems a lot less distopian that way.
Well, I think the question of "who pays for it", while important, is orthogonal to this particular issue, which is about increasing the available supply . If a poor but healthy south asian immigrant wants startup capital to open a restaurant, and Amit wants a long and fruitful life, a legal market that allowed such a transaction would dramatically increase the supply of available materials. And it may even be possibl…
I would say it's at the heart of the issue. Presumably, the rationale for disallowing a body parts market is that, while there might be more supply overall, there would be less available to the poor, because they would be competing with the rich. If the cost is socialized then that issue goes away.
Re: Photojojo, Jelly founder needs bone marrow match to save his life
#73PBSC donation is through a non-surgical procedure known as apheresis. It's essentially a blood donation, except that blood components not required for a procedure are actually returned to the patient.
In this case, the desired component is blood stem cells. These aren't normally found in peripheral blood (which is any blood outside the bone marrow), so a series of injections are required for five days prior to donation to coax more out. Then, the donor's blood is removed and passed through a machine that extracts the stem cells and returns the rest of the blood to the donor, typically through a second needle in the other arm.
It's a time-consuming process; about four hours, according to our guide. Donors may also experience headaches, or bone or muscle aches for several days prior to donations, side effects related to the movement of more stem cells from the marrow to the peripheral blood. On the up side, it doesn't require penetration of the pelvic bone, as a marrow transplant does. It is a bit more complicated than a regular blood donation, and the need for a needle in each arm is certainly inconvenient. Some apheresis machines are now able to perform the withdrawl and return process through a single needle, but I'm not sure if this method has been adapted for PBSC donation yet.
Anyone interested in learning more might like to check out the National Marrow Donor Program at http://www.marrow.org/Home.aspx. The donations FAQ is especially informative: http://www.marrow.org/Registry_Members/Donation/Donation_FAQ...
Re: Photojojo, Jelly founder needs bone marrow match to save his life
#74How about people based in the sub-continent. Do you necessarily have to be based out of US or Canada to donate.
A friend-of-a-friend ran a similar campaign for her brother, and she assembled a long list of registries: http://www.healemru.com/registries.php I think the national registries share data, so a match in a non-US country should be reported.
Re: Photojojo, Jelly founder needs bone marrow match to save his life
#75Dept. of Transplant Immunology and Immunogenetics All India Institute of Medical Science Ansari Nagar 110029 New Delhi India Email: narin98@hotmail.com Telephone: +91-11-265-88-588
Re: Photojojo, Jelly founder needs bone marrow match to save his life
#76Re: Photojojo, Jelly founder needs bone marrow match to save his life
#77Here's an unpopular thought, but one that may not be on the list of "things too taboo to think about" for HN readers. What if marrow donation was a for-profit industry, or at the very least a nonprofit or government-run industry that allowed people to sell their marrow at market prices? Would Amit and thousands of others in his position be resorting to begging for access to life-saving treatments, or being put on wai…
Organ transplant is a for-profit industry in India. Blood, bone marrow, kidneys; everything is bought and sold. There are no waiting lists, doctors sell it to the highest bidder. Indian doctors engage in organs trading, nice doctors would hook you up with a poor and offer to buy his organs. Evil ones will abduct poor laborers, take out both of their kidneys & other organs, and dump their dead body. There have been th…
I think that translates into: the waiting list is invisible, it contains everybody that is poor.
This is reminiscent of the quote by Douglas Adams: "no one was really poor, at least no one worth speaking of.".